3 ms·
This is an old argument, but it isn't very useful. The problem with simplifications is you can easily go too far, and not realize it. This kind of arithmetic
by ska 10y ago
This is an old argument, but it isn't very useful. The problem with simplifications is you can easily go too far, and not realize it.
This kind of arithmetic assumes the tax code stays basically the same. This is just silly. The whole point of UBI schemes for those that support them, is to be part of a complete overhaul of the tax code, in order to [avoid bad things happening]. Regardless if you support this view or not, you can't really get anywhere without accepting the premise.
Ok, so what if there is a real overhaul? First off, a lot of programs and tax credits don't make any sense anymore. So your number of 10k/person wiping out the entire tax base just doesn't work. More realistically keeping the rest of spending and tax code fixed, people have worked out that you end up with approx $3k/person (just using round numbers) in UBI "for free". Not much of a UBI rate, obviously, but hardly the scenario you present. This doesn't really speak to the economic impact of that many state and federal employees suddenly being unemployed, either, but bear with it for now.
So how do you get from 3k/person to 10k/person? Bear in mind, the whole premise of UBI is that a combination of income inequality and automation are going to unavoidably cause massive job loss and further inequality. So you restructure your tax code to directly address that. Something like an effective rate of 6 or 7% on the first 150k/yr (i.e. basically the same as today), and double that or a bit more on anything above... would get you to the 10k/person, without touching any current spending. That last part is important, this assumes entitlements like SS through payroll taxes are left alone. Obviously, it would be more sensible to roll those whole programs into a UBI also.
I'm not saying this is the right thing to do, I'm just pointing out that the arithmetic you are using isn't actually demonstrating anything useful. UBI programs only make sense if you make progressive changes in the tax code, but they can be made to work in a way that is not a radical change to today.
[edit] Found a similar but better articulated argument, see: https://medium.com/whatever-source-derived/the-case-against-a-universal-basic-income-that-isnt-b95cc84e3b24 https://medium.com/whatever-source-derived/the-case-against-...