4 ms·
> It's not just the equipment rendered useless and data lost due to their software. It's also the millions of hours spent by IT departments worldwide battling w
by naasking 10y ago
> It's not just the equipment rendered useless and data lost due to their software. It's also the millions of hours spent by IT departments worldwide battling with infected computers and securing not yet infected computers. Damages are easily in the tens of billions of USD.
You can't pin that on spy agencies. Criminals would have exploited the same holes eventually. Manufacturers and software developers could just start using better languages and better development practices instead of whinging every time their C/C++ software is trivially owned.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chimeracoder 10y ago> You can't pin that on spy agencies. Criminals would have exploited the same holes eventually. Officially, the NSA's role is not to sit on zero-day exploits. If it discovers zero-day exploits (either by accident or through active research), then it should follow industry practices for disclosing and patching it[0]. [0] There are discussions of what constitututes "industry best practices", but I think we can all agree that "telling nobody, including the software vendors, with the hopes of being able to exploit it later" does not qualify.
- PeterisP 10y agoEither NSA's role involves using zero-day exploits, in which case they shouldn't disclose them; or NSA's role doesn't involve using zero-day exploits, in which case it shouldn't be looking for them and would have nothing to disclose. You might argue whether or not NSA should be into 'hacking other people with 0-days' business or 'making computers more vulnerable' business, but NSA definitely is not in the business of making computers less vulnerable. Especially for computers located in other countries, they have no business helping to protect them - that's against their role, they're paid to facilitate the exact opposite goal.
- infogulch 10y agoThat looks like a false dichotomy to me. I don't see any reason why the NSA's role couldn't include protecting the nation's citizens. I mean that's the original purpose of government, no?
- sillysaurus3 10y agoThe purpose of the NSA is the same as the purpose of the military: To apply force in the digital arena, the same way the military applies force in the physical arena. In the same vein, the NSA isn't about protection. That's not their role, just like the point of the military isn't protection.
- infogulch 10y ago> the point of the military isn't protection I'd argue that it is, if indirectly.
- sillysaurus3 10y agoIt's true. We're all safer thanks to the enormous success of our military. That's why it's valuable, just like the NSA. So it leads to the same logical conclusions: If the point of the military is to apply force to an opponent, then the NSA has to have ways of applying force to a digital opponent. Disclosing vulnerabilities would be precisely the opposite of what they should do.
- ionised 10y ago> We're all safer thanks to the enormous success of our military Examples from the last 50 years?
- extra88 10y agoNSA has dual roles, not only spying on others but also protecting U.S. resources. This creates this tension between keeping exploits secret or informing vendors and others. For a long time, security researchers like Bruce Schneier have advocated for splitting the NSA up, essentially one for offense and one for defense.