3 ms·
Many of the jobs that people fear going away (and that thus motivate them to want BI) are the middle-class ones. And any revenue strategy to attempt to pay for
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
Many of the jobs that people fear going away (and that thus motivate them to want BI) are the middle-class ones.
And any revenue strategy to attempt to pay for it would need to take into account the substantially decreased tax revenue from all the people no longer working. (On the other hand, there might be increased tax revenue from jobs that now have to pay a higher salary to get people to do them. But at the very least, a static model seems insufficient.)
- vostok 10y agoI'm simply demonstrating that there exists a tuple (tax increase, basic income) that does not affect the median household. Note that post tax income is still a monotonic function of pre tax income. This is one of the reasons why I support BI. The current system is rather complicated and there are rare instances where it's better to not work. If benefits programs are largely replaced by BI then you will always make more money by working. This systems is also much easier to administer and doesn't involve anyone checking if you "deserve" the benefits because everyone gets them.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 10y agoRight! The money from all the people no longer working is not just vanishing--it's simply being captured by a different set of people, namely already-wealthy business owners and shareholders. So, a government that wants to keep being funded needs to ensure its tax system is flexible enough to "follow the money".
- JoshTriplett 10y agoThat's not quite the conclusion I was suggesting. I'm not talking about people no longer working because their job disappeared; I'm talking about people choosing not to work a job because BI is more appealing than that job. If a job still needs doing, but because of BI nobody wants to do it (e.g. sanitation pickup), then either the job will have to pay more (due to decreased supply), or will have to push harder to automate more. Either way, there's no fundamental reason that'll end up revenue-neutral.