3 ms·
This is exactly the issue. And going halfway will do less than no good; if it isn't enough to live on (at a very basic level), the experiment would fail. Whil
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
This is exactly the issue. And going halfway will do less than no good; if it isn't enough to live on (at a very basic level), the experiment would fail.
While there are many programs that could potentially be cut to make way for BI, that wouldn't be nearly enough to actually pay for it. (And any complexity added to attempt to reduce its cost, such as not paying it to people who don't need it, starts to remove its benefit and add overhead, not to mention creating perverse incentives in many cases.)
There's also a question of locale adjustments, or lack thereof. On the one hand, "just enough to live on" in Mississippi is quite different from "just enough to live on" in California. On the other hand, should the federal government subsidize living in an expensive location rather than a cheap one? Or should expensive states have to supplement BI? (And that would further cement their position as expensive.)
- mrec 10y ago> if it isn't enough to live on (at a very basic level), the experiment would fail In terms of what I'm hoping for I agree, but it does depend on who you're pitching to and what their goals are. Assuming that BI is restricted to citizens, one non-obvious consequence of even a partial BI is that it serves as a protectionist barrier against non-citizen immigrant labour - a citizen claiming $4000 BI can afford to work for $4000 less than a non-citizen while maintaining the same standard of living.
- rayiner 10y ago> On the other hand, should the federal government subsidize living in an expensive location rather than a cheap one? Or should expensive states have to supplement BI? (And that would further cement their position as expensive.) The beauty of basic income is that makes location much less relevant. Poor folks don't spend hours commuting into high-COL areas for funsies. They do it because that's where the low-skill service jobs are.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoTrue, but that assumes people are 1) willing and 2) able to move.