4 ms·
This, judging from the fact that it's in bold, appears to be his main gripe: "The problem with this particular essay is the way Mr. Graham implies the only
by pg 19y ago
This, judging from the fact that it's in bold, appears to be his
main gripe:
"The problem with this particular essay is the way Mr. Graham
implies the only path to true happiness as a young programmer
lies in founding a startup."
whereas the essay actually contains the sentence:
"Working for yourself doesn't have to mean starting a startup,
of course.
I mean, how much clearer can I be?
As for this point about "participatory narcissism," you can make
the same attack on practically every nonfiction writer. Every
(good) essayist writes from experience. Most people who have the
freedom to work on what they want, work on things they admire.
Every book on robotics or carpentry or surfing has woven through
it the sinister subtext that robotics or carpentry or surfing is
an admirable activity. But to accuse the writer of "participatory
narcissism" is to confuse cause and effect: the writer of the
robotics book isn't claiming robotics is admirable to make himself
look good; it was because he thought it was admirable that he chose
to work on it.
A claim you could make with equal justification about any essayist
isn't much of a claim. But people will still believe it means
something if they disagree with him.
- jotto 19y ago3 people who have had disrupted the normal thinking track: DHH, PH, and AS, and many people hate them for it - defending their hatred or anger by accusing these people of arrogance or narcissism. think about it.
- tptacek 19y agoHow much clearer? Well, you could have started by not comparing employees to caged lions.
- pg 19y agoThat's a metaphor. The way metaphors work is that they're accurate in some respects and not in others. The advantage of metaphors is that they help explain things by isomorphism. The disadvantage is that people often take them too literally. Or pretend to if they want to attack the writer. Strange as it sounds, I expected to be criticized for telling readers what they wanted to hear, not for insulting them. If you actually read the essay, the thesis is that the famous founders who are made to seem like such gods in the press are actually not that different from ordinary programmers-- that the difference, as it says in the last paragraph, is "due mostly to environment." In other words the exact opposite of the summary Atwood quotes: "Oh... you haven't founded a company? You suck." How can so many people read an essay saying X and come away believing it said not-X? I think what happened in this case was that a lot of people who were already feeling self-conscious about working for big companies read the first section as some kind of criticism of them, and then either read that into the rest of the essay or (this is the Internet) didn't read any more before writing blog posts about it.
- pixcavator 19y agoWhich meaning of "isomorphism" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isomorphism_%28disambiguation%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isomorphism_%28disambiguation%2...) do you have in mind here?
- omouse 19y ago3 of those say basically the same thing, "a similarity of structure or form"...
- pixcavator 19y agoAs long as it's not #1...