8 ms·
But how do you know this? I've come across articles on certain subjects that are far more illuminating than usual - these shouldn't exist if mathematics is jus
by Chris2048 10y ago
But how do you know this?
I've come across articles on certain subjects that are far more illuminating than usual - these shouldn't exist if mathematics is just irredeemably difficult to learn. The only conclusion I can draw is mathematicians care more about advancing mathematics, than concepts in teaching; How many lecturers are actively involved in psychology of learning, or real testing of their students comprehension?
A lot of books are perfectly happy to bullet point list the properties of some concept, like feeding data to a machine, then try a combination of explanations and diagrams to describe how these properties fit together, or an intuition of their emergent properties.
It's funny, I've often gotten a lot more help from offhanded comments of characterisations of a concept, than from their formalities. It seems some lecturers are scared of making such observations, in case they mislead students, so they stick to the "safety" of irrefutable formality. set theory might be sufficiently abstract that it won't strictly mislead, but it won't enlighten either.
{ as an aside, it was years after my first undergraduate class that I finally realised that the integral notation represented a summation, and that it was literally the continuous form of the discrete "sigma" summation notation, I was surprised I hadn't realised it before! being able to relate the two gave me a stronger basis to reason about them in some ways - for example, I now thing of the variable of differentiation (dx, etc) like a 'counter' variable (the n=.. atop the sigma in summations), which helped when trying when reasoning about integrals etc with more than one (obv. if you try to derive a limit as some variable goes to inf., there is ambiguity if there are two unrelated variables), plus most continuous forms are based on discrete concepts taken to some limit. in fact, it even gives a little intuition about why an integral might be followed by "* dx", in such a way that the 'd' variable can be treated as an independent unit (taken to the other side of an equation, for example) - it is bound to the integral in some sense, but also represents a quantity in itself that can be shared amongst integrals }
I also get the feeling that mathematics is too "pen and paper", and ripe for an overhaul wrt anything that can be easily done using a math program. I feel the human part of maths should be high level concepts, not the actual calculation (although some understanding of what a calculation does is important) - hence, it is more important I understand what an integral represents, than know how to calculate it.
> an important number of math books are written not for laypersons but for mathematicians
But some math is useful outside of mathematical study, so 'maths for engineers' books are sadly too uncommon. Consider a software engineer trying to understand cryptography better, reading about elliptical functions..
> Not all mathematical concepts need to have a direct application
All but a few can at least be characterised somehow, even by mapping to similarly abstract social constructs.
- Chris2048 10y agosorry that should be " like feeding data to a machine, than trying a combination.."