6 ms·
I sometimes wonder whether the "best" way to solve this is to enable cockpit access by democratic vote of the pax, with buttons at every seat that allow for sec
by FabHK 10y ago
I sometimes wonder whether the "best" way to solve this is to enable cockpit access by democratic vote of the pax, with buttons at every seat that allow for secret voting (i.e. hidden from view). Like with BitCoin, terrorists would have to control a majority of the seats then to gain illegitimate access, while in a case like the suicidal GermanWings pilot the pax would let the legitimate captain in.
- StavrosK 10y agoSo every time a pilot wants to use the restroom and return, he has to wake up the whole plane and ask them to vote him in? I feel like your proposal addresses the one-in-a-billion case and doesn't think at all about the multiple-times-per-flight case.
- FabHK 10y agoNope, this would be invoked only after a standard access request has been denied from the cockpit.
- kej 10y agoAn emergency, real or supposed, is about the worst case scenario for democratic voting.
- FabHK 10y agoGenerally agreed, which is why I support the fairly wide authority a captain has. But the existing solutions might fail, as in the Germanwings case. As a passenger, you definitely have a stake in the safe landing of the plane. Just to be clear, I'm not advocating this as a realistic proposal. I'm just saying that it might have addressed the Germanwings (and possibly MH 370) case, without lending itself to compromise as in 9/11.
- mikeash 10y agoLet's take it one step further and let the passengers directly control the plane in this way. Then you wouldn't have to worry about pilots at all. Twitch Plays United Airlines.
- openasocket 10y agoMight help with the suicidal pilot problem, but not with hijacking, which is more common. They can threaten all the passengers to vote 'yes' to let them into the cockpit
- FabHK 10y agoThey cannot see who votes what though. They could threaten to kill one after the other, unless they're let in. Question is who is more susceptible to this threat, pilots or pax. Would be worse than the current situation?