4 ms·
I don't think the police should be able to compel people to disclose their passwords. However, there's a possibility that 'human rights activist' should be take
by foldr 10y ago
I don't think the police should be able to compel people to disclose their passwords. However, there's a possibility that 'human rights activist' should be taken with a pinch of salt here. CAGE is a pretty shady organization in some respects. For example see this interview with its 'research director' Asim Qureshi (who to be clear, is not the guy featured in the article):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0n-08I3P8s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0n-08I3P8s
- bmelton 10y agoI don't know much about CAGE, and my Googling isn't proving to be terribly enlightening (yet), but: The trouble with fighting for human freedom is that one spends most of one's time defending scoundrels. For it is against scoundrels that oppressive laws are first aimed, and oppression must be stopped at the beginning if it is to be stopped at all.
- foldr 10y agoThat's true but not really relevant to the video that I linked to. The issue is that CAGE has at times crossed the line into offering support for what the scoundrels are doing, rather than just defending their legal rights. For example, Asim Qureshi still has kind words for Mohammed Emwazi even after he committed beheadings. As I said, I am not in favour of the security services having these powers. However, from the fact that the powers are excessive and unjust, it does not follow that all of the people targeted are innocent victims.
- bmelton 10y agoThey may well have. After watching the video you linked, it seems that there is a very blurry, very nuanced line between supporting the rights of the offender and supporting the offenses, and listening to that interview with a blank-slate understanding of the matter, it seemed as though they were mostly talking past each other. Again though, my knowledge is short on the subject, but the Mencken quote felt an appropriate addenda to the video you linked, from a variety of ways. Remember that even if CAGE organizers are sympathetic to the goals of those they defend, once they've defended them, they're still defending civil rights.
- foldr 10y agoIt's not a blurry line at all. You defend their legal rights, but you don't support terrorism.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoThat interview was a shambles. It's true that in order to protect rights in general you have to defend shady people - however when asked if you agree with FGM/stoning for adultery/homosexuality is evil/etc. your answer should be a point blank, "No". He had valid points at the beginning of the interview but when pressed he doesn't make himself look very good. >> Remember that even if CAGE organizers are sympathetic to the goals of those they defend, once they've defended them, they're still defending civil rights. While this is a valid point in general, it is not in this context of showing schedule 7 to be overreaching. If the man in the article works for the CAGE and they actually are known as sympathetic to the goals of terrorists it makes perfect sense to detain him after he returns from a 'work' trip as there are likely valid, evidence based suspicions for it.
- laumars 10y agoWhat ever happened to being innocent until proven guilty? Besides if he wasn't innocent then there would be a crime that he could be charged for and/or a warrant produced to search his devices.
- foldr 10y ago>As I said, I am not in favour of the security services having these powers.
- EpicEng 10y agoHow do you reconcile that with the state's legitimate need for discovery and gathering of evidence? We can debate the merits of any specific case, but in general, do you feel that a state has the right to legally issue a warrant and search for evidence? If so I don't see how compelling someone to hand over a password is any different than searching their home, asking them to open a safe, etc.
- gpderetta 10y ago> warrant judicial oversight.
- EpicEng 10y agoOk... I don't see how that leads to "no one should be compelled to.give up their password." So fine, you get oversight; you're still stuck with the fact that people will be compelled to hand over their creds or face obstruction charges. You're inly addressing instances where you feel that the search was improper.