3 ms·
No, that's all Trump. He interviews terribly, which is part of what makes him appealing to people fed up with what they perceive to be the failings of professio
by throwanem 10y ago
No, that's all Trump. He interviews terribly, which is part of what makes him appealing to people fed up with what they perceive to be the failings of professional politicians - whatever else he may be, he certainly is not that.
- krapp 10y agoI've become convinced that Donald Trump wasn't actually elected to be President, he was elected to play the part of President on television - specifically, to be the angry, right-wing version of President Bartlett from the West Wing.
- throwanem 10y agoI don't think that the overlap between Trump voters and West Wing fans is likely to be all that large, but I take your point. I don't agree with it, though. Trump voters by and large voted for him because they wanted done what he said he would do, and he successfully enough presented himself as the kind of socially liberal, but America-first fiscally conservative, candidate that a lot of people have wanted to see for a very long time. Whether he'll actually do any of the things he claimed he would is a different question, of course, as is whether he - or anyone - can. But I don't think it takes an effort of hermeneutics to understand why people wanted to give him the job, when their stated reasons have been so clearly on display.
- krapp 10y agoI'm not certain Donald Trump's views or stated goals put him that far outside the general Republican mainstream or separated him from the other candidates. And arguably, other candidates have been more qualified and capable to actually pass the kind of legislation Trump supporters wanted. Which is why, to me, Trump's persona seemed to matter more than his actual policy positions. As a policy goal, "the wall" it makes little sense. From a "fiscally conservative and socially liberal" point of view, it makes no sense. But as a symbol of right-wing defiance, as a dramatic device, building a giant wall to keep out the foreigners and making them pay for it because America is just that strong makes perfect sense. >But I don't think it takes an effort of hermeneutics to understand why people wanted to give him the job, when their stated reasons have been so clearly on display. The stated reasons have been all over the place, though, and they include a general sense of disgust with political correctness and multiculturalism, and wanting someone to act as a "brick through the window of the establishment." I've seen so many things attributed to Trump's election at this point that I'm starting to wonder how many of his supporters actually voted for him rather than against something or someone else. I may not be entirely correct, but I'm not certain I'm entirely wrong, either.
- throwanem 10y ago> From a "fiscally conservative and socially liberal" point of view, it makes no sense From an America-first social liberal, it makes a great deal of sense. The argument would be that, first, it behooves the US government to look after bettering the lives of its own lawful citizens first, before attempting to police and/or provide welfare to the whole world; and, second, that incontinently accepting trespassers and extending them materially the same benefits offered citizens vitiates the government's capacity to discharge its responsibilities to those of us who have a right to be here. (And, yes, I realize precisely how heretical that sounds to a lot of people.) But I don't really have a good cite to point to, that demonstrates Trump actually made that argument in so many words - although it wouldn't surprise me to learn that one exists, and I'm just not closely familiar with it. After all, the man says a lot of things. I'd have a hard time arguing against the proposition that a lot of Trump voters were voting, not for him, but against Clinton - just like a lot of people voted not for Kerry, but against Bush, in 2004. But he did have a solid base of support, I think a large majority by comparison with "tactical" voters more like myself. He earned that support by dint of his policy claims, and with the "outsider" persona which lent credibility to his argument that, unlike those he faced in the various debates, his interest in the job revolved around actually delivering on those claims. Of course, now that he has the office, he seems to be completely falling apart in it. But that has no bearing I can see on how he came to be there in the first place.
- krapp 10y agoBut nothing in that argument requires spending billions of dollars to build a wall across the southern border like ancient Imperial China trying to keep the Mongols at bay. The wall, itself, as an actual thing, makes no sense. Arguably, the wall would do more harm than good, both to our relationship with Mexico, and the funding of other, more effective means of border control and enforcement.