3 ms·
When I was teaching calculus, I made a fundamental decision of how to define limits: I used limits of sequences. In our university, we encounter limits in eit
by EGreg 10y ago
When I was teaching calculus, I made a fundamental decision of how to define limits:
I used limits of sequences.
In our university, we encounter limits in either a handwavy way in Calc I or an epsilon-delta way in Advanced Calculus. Sequences and series are introduced in Calculus II.
Continuity is then described in the same terms. Or perhaps in terms of open sets if there is some topological topic.
I think this is pretty terrible for intuition. Not just that, but it's not even general enough - it requires normed spaces, so then you have to generalize again.
Much simpler to talk about ancient Greeks and Zeno's paradox. And then rigorously define limits of sequences, and define limits of real valued functions in terms of "for any sequence x_n that approaches x, y_n = f(x_n) approaches y". Simple and right away lets me show counterexamples beyond "left and right limits", like cos(1/x), and show students how to produce two sequences that converge to different numbers.
There are similar ah-ha moments when discussing fundamental concepts of linear algebra, number theory, complex numbers etc.
The two best books I have ever found on teaching Complex Numbers are:
1) Bak and Newman
2) Schaum's Outlines
They actually give you the understanding and ceeling behind WHY analytic functions are the way they are, and derive holomorphic functions from that. Imho a more terrible approach is that of Serge Lang and proving everything the other way, with Taylor power series.
Bottom line - make a directed graph of how you will teach your subject and then figure out the best entry point an direction for the greatest cohesion, as you would when telling a story.
If you are curious, now I teach a course on "Thinking Matematically" and here are this semester's results of that approach:
Numbers and Algebra:
https://qbix.com/docs/mathematically1.pdf https://qbix.com/docs/mathematically1.pdf
(https://vimeo.com/215335666 https://vimeo.com/215335666)
Sets and Infinity:
https://qbix.com/docs/mathematically2.pdf https://qbix.com/docs/mathematically2.pdf
(https://vimeo.com/210500111 https://vimeo.com/210500111)
Boolean Algebra:
https://qbix.com/docs/mathematically3.pdf https://qbix.com/docs/mathematically3.pdf
Logic and Probability
(Coming up)
The above videos were made with help from video exditors on upwork.com