4 ms·
My question is why is it so easy to have advertisements that directly link to downloadable software? If I'm clicking on an advertisement I want to know more abo
by giancarlostoro 10y ago
My question is why is it so easy to have advertisements that directly link to downloadable software? If I'm clicking on an advertisement I want to know more about a product, not be forced to run a binary of which I have no certainty of it's true purpose. Or am I thinking wrong? If you disallow download based advertising including linking to pages that only offer you a download, this could be a little more useful against malvertisements. More reason to run an adblocker.
- GeneralMayhem 10y agoThe problem is enforcement. Telling malware distributors "that's not allowed" obviously isn't going to do anything, and it's easy to have the ad go to one place when Google is investigating and another when a user clicks the ad in the wild.
- ethbro 10y agoI can't believe Google couldn't categoricatically add context to these type of ads if they really cared. Google knows the ad link. Google can crawl the target page / file. If it's an installer, Google can run it in a VM and note what ends up being installed. If you can't pull a clear "this is crapware" signal out of that, then their ML is a lot less advanced than it seems. And if they can, then just automatically put a stronger visual border around it with something like "This is an advertisement" in bold. Then let advertisers sort it out. Google penalizes SEO they disagree with all the time, and people stop doing it because they don't want to take the hit. And I'm pretty sure it is (image recognition) and they don't... so... advertising buys trump "don't be evil."
- sundvor 10y agoThey would care if thousands of organisations pulled their advertising over it.
- giancarlostoro 10y agoI really wish this were the case. It would be nice if more organizations were more action oriented against malvertisement. I seem to recall there was one blog / news site that got rid of Google Adsense from their website here on HN not over a year ago, and I'm sure others have. It's really sad that Google doesn't put any effort (that we know, though we would see less of this) against these advertisements.
- Buge 10y agoClicking the advertisement does what you want. It doesn't download anything (at least the one I clicked on), it takes you a site with more information where you can download the advertised thing.