3 ms·
I'm not entirely sure if this is scalable. Do we (as in the world) have enough reserves of Lithium for this to be possible ? There is also the question of trade
by throwaway23498 10y ago
I'm not entirely sure if this is scalable. Do we (as in the world) have enough reserves of Lithium for this to be possible ? There is also the question of trade balance (presumably with China/Japan as well as upstream Lithium miners). Add to this, India barely has power for normal domestic consumption; even in Bangalore, the ostensible "Silicon valley" of India, power cuts for an hour or two is a daily affair.
Environmental solutions, incl. solar, are okay for assuaging the guilt about wrecking the environment (and India is totally wrecked), but frankly it's not clear if any of these are really scalable. This appears to me as another PR stunt pulled by the new regime in charge.
- Gravityloss 10y agoThere might be something else than lithium running out, like cobalt. On the other hand, if you're willing to go with somewhat less range, you can go with lithium iron phosphate.
- Gibbon1 10y ago> lithium iron phosphate Far as I can tell, lithium iron phosphate battery technology is sustainable over geologic time scales. Unlike other things that require minerals that are rapidly being depleted and will be low supply and expensive in 50 years.
- Gravityloss 10y agoFor the person who downvoted me, do you think I'm wrong? I would like to hear why.
- _ph_ 10y agoLithium is a more common element than lead - and there has been no lead shortage for cars yet. Even a Tesla uses less lithium than lead for its batteries. For the trade balance of India this is a big help, as the reduced needs of oil imports vastly overshadow any lithium imports. With charging controlled by the supply, electrical cars can actually help stabilizing the grid. It is also very easy to supply them with solar energy during daytime.
- padiyar83 10y ago>> India barely has power for normal domestic consumption; even in Bangalore, the ostensible "Silicon valley" of India, power cuts for an hour or two is a daily affair. - Thats because India today relies heavily on hydro electric power and does not have as many peaker plants to handle peak capacity loads. One could make an argument that this is a perfect scenario for solar on rooftops (South India is a temperate country and gets lots of sun) generating the needed power locally and feeding the rest back into the grid as a perfect example that would work for India. >> There is also the question of trade balance (presumably with China/Japan as well as upstream Lithium miners) - Those are today's constraints. I am not so sure, these are the same challenges that we would be worrying about a decade from now. Geopolitics and tech. change all the time. >> Environmental solutions, incl. solar, are okay for assuaging the guilt about wrecking the environment (and India is totally wrecked) - Thats true, India today is totally wrecked, but so was 18th century London. You can always get better.
- intended 10y agoI've looked for data on Indian power production regularly and the statement that India relies heavily on hydro power is dubious. The best I could find is that 42 GW is hydro, while 42 is renewables and 211 is thermal. The North and South grids have only recently been linked (maybe only as recent as 2014). So Saying India relies heavily on Hydro Power goes against my intuition with the industry and I would like to understand your position.