7 ms·
As a contractor, I've seen these before - and more frequently, the indemnification clause. I've always just sent a apologetic but firm email saying that I canno
by stickfigure 10y ago
As a contractor, I've seen these before - and more frequently, the indemnification clause. I've always just sent a apologetic but firm email saying that I cannot accept those clauses and they always get removed without any drama or handwringing.
Admittedly I'm on the upper end of the experience scale, but I think there's a lot more wiggle room than most people realize. Also, this is a pretty decent litmus test for an organization - I would avoid companies run by their legal departments.
- rattray 10y agoIt may be easier for companies to change contractor contracts than full-time employee contracts. The latter is likely to be much more standardized (and companies may generally demand more conformity from FTE's).
- developer2 10y ago>> I've always just sent a apologetic but firm email saying that I cannot accept those clauses and they always get removed Hold on, everyone! My parent(^) said something simple, yet it is powerful. I don't believe s/he realized they were providing such insightful information, but the little gem that makes a huge difference is in that short quote. While many companies may not be flexible with their contracts, I love your approach. Surely the odds of success must improve - if only slightly - by simply pointing out undesirable clauses and requesting that they modify and reissue the contract to accommodate, rather than striking it out in red ink yourself and shoving it back in their faces as an ultimatum. The former tactic de-escalates the issue to being a reasonable request from a respectful person, while the latter comes across as coming from an immovably stubborn personality who may bring a habit of causing drama into the company. Better to politely identify how the employer can effect a positive difference on your end, rather than railing against the company's policies with your demands before you've even been hired. "My way or the highway" doesn't sound very amiable. How often do companies reject red-inked contracts, not because they are unwilling to amend the contract, but because their intuition has triggered them into avoiding your coarse methods of getting what you want? Seriously, this is quite eye-opening. You've made me rethink my negotiation phase. I will be unapologetically thieving this diplomatic approach for my personal use in the future. Thank you!
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI was under the impression that for laywers and people dealing with contracts, redlining is a standard practice of sorts, like sending patch diffs in Open Source software development.
- ConceptJunkie 10y agoWhile I would always strive to be cordial and civil about these kinds of things, I don't think the difference in presentation would make any difference if the lawyers are involved. Either modifying the terms is acceptable or it's not.
- developer2 10y agoWhile negotiating employment, one would think it would be natural for prospective employees to engage the services of a lawyer to ensure everything is aboveboard. After all, the company sure as hell had legal draw up and/or sign off on their contracts. With freelance contracts, of course both sides should have lawyers signing off to foster a fair relationship. Yet what does an employer think if a candidate indicates that they have involved their own lawyer during contract negotiations? Perhaps it's a normal occurrence in major centres (ie: Silicon Valley), or maybe even across the US. I have never heard of a single one of my 1000+ peers over 15 years of experience having done so in my country (Canada). The very act of engaging a lawyer to read through one's employment contract here would be seen as an aggressive attack against the "integrity" of the employer's business. Red flags galore raised about how this person would be a risk to employ, should they go running to a lawyer over every little grievance. If I had a lawyer make amendments to my contract and sign off on it, and slipped to my prospective employer that this act had taken place, I'm quite sure my résumé would hit the bottom of the recycling bin within seconds of my name being added to a blacklist of "never communicate with this person ever again; do not reply to their emails, hang up the phone the moment they give their name, call security if they show up at the front desk, etc.". I would be unemployable if I even mentioned the word "lawyer". I suspect cultural differences, with the US being desensitized to the presence of lawyers in an abundance of everyday situations? So, no lawyer for me. I much prefer the idea of requesting that the company amend the contract themselves to accommodate me, rather than red-inking it myself. Maybe Canadians really are too polite? ;) tldr; In Canada at least, red-inking your contract on your own has a chance to succeed. But involving a lawyer would make employers avoid you as a high-risk hire.