6 ms·
Neat, but in practice it doesn't work. In my ~20 years experience, I've found that while things like salary and vacation are negotiable, the terms in tech emplo
by ryandrake 10y ago
Neat, but in practice it doesn't work. In my ~20 years experience, I've found that while things like salary and vacation are negotiable, the terms in tech employment contracts are not negotiable.
I've tried that cute "strike out the stuff in your employment agreement that you don't agree to" move, and in ALL cases, received a stern note from the corporate legal department a few days later basically saying "Sign it unmodified or GTFO." I don't know who all you Captains Of Industry are who have the power to negotiate these things, but I've found employees basically have no ability to change them.
- paulddraper 10y agoYes. While the engineering manager might desperately want you, legal/HR couldn't care less. You can negotiate successfully with the former, but not the latter.
- ethbro 10y agoI think the parent point is that if even your hiring manager / new boss can't negotiate with legal / HR... then the company is probably dysfunctional and you wouldn't want to be working there anyway.
- Confusion 10y agoCorporate legal departements try to pull the same thing with B2B contracts, but in our experience almost anything can be changed if you stand your ground.
- NoGravitas 10y agoB2B contracts are different, though, because they are effectively between equals, in a way employment contracts are not.
- Confusion 10y agoThe legal department usually tries to tell us differently and gives the same kinds of arguments as they would give for the 'non-standard' employment contract. "You are only a small company and every other company accepts these conditions". "Only manager X of small department Y wants to do business with you: we won't change our conditions just for them". "The contract is only for few$, we can't do specials for that". But in the end the wishes of someone in the business are more important and conditions can be changed to satisfy both parties.
- stickfigure 10y agoAs a contractor, I've seen these before - and more frequently, the indemnification clause. I've always just sent a apologetic but firm email saying that I cannot accept those clauses and they always get removed without any drama or handwringing. Admittedly I'm on the upper end of the experience scale, but I think there's a lot more wiggle room than most people realize. Also, this is a pretty decent litmus test for an organization - I would avoid companies run by their legal departments.
- rattray 10y agoIt may be easier for companies to change contractor contracts than full-time employee contracts. The latter is likely to be much more standardized (and companies may generally demand more conformity from FTE's).
- developer2 10y ago>> I've always just sent a apologetic but firm email saying that I cannot accept those clauses and they always get removed Hold on, everyone! My parent(^) said something simple, yet it is powerful. I don't believe s/he realized they were providing such insightful information, but the little gem that makes a huge difference is in that short quote. While many companies may not be flexible with their contracts, I love your approach. Surely the odds of success must improve - if only slightly - by simply pointing out undesirable clauses and requesting that they modify and reissue the contract to accommodate, rather than striking it out in red ink yourself and shoving it back in their faces as an ultimatum. The former tactic de-escalates the issue to being a reasonable request from a respectful person, while the latter comes across as coming from an immovably stubborn personality who may bring a habit of causing drama into the company. Better to politely identify how the employer can effect a positive difference on your end, rather than railing against the company's policies with your demands before you've even been hired. "My way or the highway" doesn't sound very amiable. How often do companies reject red-inked contracts, not because they are unwilling to amend the contract, but because their intuition has triggered them into avoiding your coarse methods of getting what you want? Seriously, this is quite eye-opening. You've made me rethink my negotiation phase. I will be unapologetically thieving this diplomatic approach for my personal use in the future. Thank you!
- mcv 10y agoI always negotiate. Not a redlined version, but I make a list of points I have questions about or disagree with, and call them to discuss it. If they won't budge, I look elsewhere. Of course I have the advantage of living in a place where there's plenty of work. If jobs are scarce where you live, that significantly changes the labour market.
- pm90 10y agoReally depends on a case by case basis. In smaller companies or the recently founded megacorps, managers often have a lot of sway since they are responsible for the survival/growth of the company. So if you're a required hire, the manager might ask his/her manager to push your request through. Much harder to do this in a bureaucratic company that has been around forever since they tend to be pretty inflexible on everything except salary/benefits.
- ethbro 10y agoBecause of this, I usually frame it with a salary-and-benefits-adjusted alternative. E.g. "I'm very interested in the position we discussed, but would like to discuss clauses X, Y, and Z. These pose a problem for me for reasons. If this is something you could be flexible on, I'd love to see what we can agree on! If these aren't clauses that can be changed, I feel that salary +A and benefits +B would be more in line with what you're asking for." If phrased like that, you're putting the "choice" back in their hands, but making it clear just how much these things are worth to you. They may say "Neither of those options works for us," but the difference is that they're making the decision to torpedo your hiring over one of their own clauses. Imo, it's much more difficult to say "These clauses are worth A & B" than it is to say "These clauses are super important."
- bythckr 10y agoI have ~10 yrs exp. Till date I have got non-competence clause 4 times, of that I removed the clause 3 times and did not sign the time they refused to remove it. I just explained my case logically, respectfully and directly (face to face) to my line manager. My case was: - Its understood that I will not work a second job. Though I will volunteer for some charity. - Considering my domain expertise, I am more likely to get a job in a similar domain. If my future employer demands me to implement the same tech as my pervious employer, its a red flag that this company is clueless and will sink soon. If I volunteer the details of my previous companies operations, it just means that I am untrustworthy and I will not be trusted in the new company. So sharing details of my previous job is a bad idea. The 4th company manager was not even willing to discuss with me about my agreement and wanted me to go to the legal dept directly. That was clear sign that this was a very bureaucratic and not suited for me. Of course, I have only worked in small to medium sized company and they was no secret algorithms worth in the millions or billions involved. That I am sure is a different case, like the current Google vs Uber over the tech stolen by Otto from Waymo.
- eloisant 10y agoIt depends of the company, its size in particular. In a big company the manager wanting to hire you might not have the power to overrule the legal department. In a smaller company however you might get hired by the CTO or CEO himself, the contract has been written by a contractor lawyer and if we wants you he'll change the terms.
- JPKab 10y agoAgreed. When contracts are redlined in any way, even relatively small companies have procedures in place to require review by the legal counsel. As soon as you introduce lawyers, the delays kick in and nobody is happy.