3 ms·
I used to agree with this, and the same argument about DRM in general, but Netflix now has a significant body of original content, so I'm less sure about it. In
by geofft 10y ago
I used to agree with this, and the same argument about DRM in general, but Netflix now has a significant body of original content, so I'm less sure about it. In particular, they appear to be blocking the entire app from even downloading (not even running!) on affected devices.
Do their contracts with the content providers say "All your content, even content that doesn't come from us, must be provided with this much DRM"?
- xienze 10y agoIt's probably a lot easier to have a blanket ban on VPNs and rooted devices than to allow them when you watch X versus when you watch Y.
- jasonkostempski 10y agoMaybe one day they'll have a separate price plan and app just for Netflix Original content. I'd switch to that right now if they offered it. Then we'd see which side of the fence they're on.
- syshum 10y agoI am sure it is, I am also sure if netflix has a ethical problem with DRM, and is actually in active opposition to DRM they would put forth the effort to allow their content DRM free, eliminate geo-fences, and allow the app on Rooted devices limited to only Netflix owned content They however are not opposed to DRM like many people believe, they are Huge supporters and developers of DRM technology. If you oppose DRM, Netflix is just as much an enemy as the MPAA is
- jasonkostempski 10y agoI'm guessing they're on the same boat as Tim Berners-Lee, thinking it a necessary evil if the world wants big budget films delivered through their browser. Personally, I'd only get on that boat if my life depended on it, which I think is the case for Netflix (I'm still not sure why TBL is on it). I think Netflix is at least fighting for DRM that isn't based on rootkits, something of a win for the general population.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y ago> I think Netflix is at least fighting for DRM that isn't based on rootkits But you have read the headline, haven't you? They only work with a google rootkit installed, now.
- geofft 10y agoI think that describing Google Play Services (or Android? or I'm-not-sure-what) as "a google rootkit" isn't super conducive to a meaningful discussion, even if there's a technical interpretation under which it's true. In particular, most users of Netflix on Android have a threat model that involves Google legitimately having the ability to push software updates to the phone that run as root. So "rootkit" is not a very useful term, any more than describing any Debian package maintainer script as a "random volunteer's rootkit" would be.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y agoSuppose you needed to install this particular Debian package with root privileges (well, necessarily, but you get the point) that you otherwise would not want to install and that then goes on to enforce a certain behaviour of your computer against your interests as a prerequisite for using some other piece of software. Suppose further that someone put forward the argument that it's not so bad, as at least there is no rootkit involved. Then, yes, it would obviously be perfectly sensible to in that context call that Debian package a "random volunteer's rootkit". Whether most users would like to have some other functionality provided by that same package is completely irrelevant to the question at hand, as is whether most users would install the package.
- geofft 10y ago> Suppose you needed to install this particular Debian package with root privileges (well, necessarily, but you get the point) that you otherwise would not want to install and that then goes on to enforce a certain behaviour of your computer against your interests as a prerequisite for using some other piece of software. This happens to lots of people under the name of systemd. I think any definition of "rootkit" that includes involuntary installations of systemd is so broad that we cannot conclude anything from the term. (There are legitimate criticism of Debian requiring systemd, but they're basically entirely orthogonal from the criticisms of, say, the Sony BMG rootkit.) So, let me ask - what in particular are you seeing as the "google rootkit," and how would you describe its negative behavior in words other than "it's a rootkit"?
- Jach 10y agoDoing the easy thing isn't (or didn't used to be) Netflix's style, one of the reasons HN has long loved its tech writeups. So the blanket ban is either a reversal of that culture or simply Netflix finding itself with aligned interests with other content producers and acting accordingly.