4 ms·
I don't think that's a fair criticism, because there have always been Communist critics of those regimes, even before they turned out to be murderously barbaric
by icebraining 10y ago
I don't think that's a fair criticism, because there have always been Communist critics of those regimes, even before they turned out to be murderously barbaric. It's not necessarily revisionist like in an NTS fallacy.
- ue_ 10y agoSocialist critics include George Orwell (known for his criticism of totalitarian Socialism in Animal Farm), economist I.I Rubin, the anarchists which the USSR suppressed, Luxemburg, Bordiga, Bookchin, and later on Hobsbawm, Trotsky (to some extent), Sylvia Pankhurt (and various other feminists) etc.
- remarkEon 10y agoI'm still waiting for one to not end up being murderously barbaric, existence of early critics or not.
- ue_ 10y agoWhy not contribute to the modern Marxist discourse in finding out how this can be achieved, then?
- thriftwy 10y agoWhy would an opponent to Marxist discourse want to contribute to it? There are a few discourses with much better traction than Marxism, why not stick to those? It's basically a request to produce Failblog-grade falling-on-a-face-while-smashing-your-balls results. Maybe you will be able to do what noone could before you, but chances are, you will just hurt yourself. And your society.