4 ms·
So if his argument is that geeks in the corporate trenches aren't using it to quietly get their jobs done without involving management, I'd say the reason is th
by DennisP 10y ago
So if his argument is that geeks in the corporate trenches aren't using it to quietly get their jobs done without involving management, I'd say the reason is that if you're just doing internal work, you're better off using a database.
Blockchains are useful for reducing the overhead due to lack of trust when you're working with other companies. You can't really make that happen without management on both sides getting involved. There's no way a back office geek working on his own can make complicated auditing and settlement procedures go away, and that's the sort of thing where blockchains help.
(And of course not every new technology gets adopted first by corporate geeks; iPhone apps are one example of consumers taking the lead.)
- AstralStorm 10y agoThey don't actually help, they take away power and control from the hands of the bank. This makes blockchains in fact completely against the interest of banks. Do you see consumers commonly paying in BTC? Real offline shops accepting it? (Never mind tiny things like Ethereum.)
- acdha 10y ago> Blockchains are useful for reducing the overhead due to lack of trust when you're working with other companies Can you expand on what you're defining this problem as and how Bitcoin reduces costs relative to the traditional approaches with trusted third parties, PKI, etc. I've seen the marketing pitches but they're always conspicuously lacking the kind of specific “we pay X to do Y but could pay Z” pitches which I've seen used to justify bringing new tech inside.
- DennisP 10y agoNot so much Bitcoin as smart contract platforms like Ethereum, or various private offshoots. Most of what I know about this comes from watching the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance conference, which had people from JP Morgan, Santander, and several other large corporations. Interbank settlement is one example. Right now it involves auditing process that take days. A blockchain implementation could reduce it to seconds. Insurance and supply chains are a couple other things they mentioned. Pretty much any time you're either doing a lot of mutual auditing, or paying someone a lot to maintain a trusted transactional database for a group of companies, there's an opportunity to reduce costs and/or speed things up with a blockchain. For now, that probably doesn't mean a public blockchain, due to privacy and scalability issues. The companies in the EEA are focusing on private versions for now; if you have a known set of nodes and trust that no more than a third of them will commit fraud, you can get away with much faster consensus mechanisms. At the EEA conference they said if Ethereum succeeds in its scaling and privacy efforts, they hope to move at least some applications to the public chain, but that's a couple years off.
- davidgerard 10y ago> Blockchains are useful for reducing the overhead due to lack of trust when you're working with other companies. That's an "is" statement, not a "could" statement. Please show me, not a possibility, not a press release about a pilot scheme, but a present-day working example of this in practice as part of an industry.