12 ms·
I've never been presented with one (and hope I never will) so this is hypothetical, but I have a hard time imagining even doing that. A company is paying me to
by mikeash 10y ago
I've never been presented with one (and hope I never will) so this is hypothetical, but I have a hard time imagining even doing that.
A company is paying me to work for them, they're not paying to own me. When I'm off the clock, my time is my own, up to and including doing paid work for anyone else I want.
I'd make an exception if they increased my pay accordingly. But considering that they're asking for 4.2x more of my time than usual, they'd better be paying me at least 4.2x a normal full-time salary.
I do have a little experience with making changes to contracts that the other party doesn't want to change, and to that end I'd like to add two more things. First, it's likely they'll use the phrase "standard contract" and say that it just can't be changed. Second, if you've gotten that far, it's quite likely they'll change your minds if you stick to your guns. It's tempting to cave in when they say "sorry, we can't accept changes," but don't.
- etjossem 10y agoThis suggestion is mainly directed at newcomers to the industry, who may not have the reputation or experience to be able to credibly push back on many points of their employment agreement. Once you're in a seller's market for your level of skill (as I'm sure you are), you don't need this advice anymore and I'd encourage you not to let your employer restrict your moonlight projects. But particularly if it's your first job, you may have to make concessions - for some folks, "if you want a paycheck, sign here" is a reality. If nothing else, it is very important that you keep the right to move up and out to a new job. That's the point you should focus on. In a realistic full-time first job, you're not going to work for a competitor at the same time, so it is fine to tell them you won't if that helps the two sides reach agreement. Good point about not taking "this is the standard agreement" for an answer. That's not good enough. Say you understand that it's a boilerplate legal document, and you'd be more than happy to give them a couple days to double-check your proposed change with their boss, counsel, or whoever they need to. Again, be firm while giving them an avenue to save face, and wait for them to call back with a sudden change of heart.
- stale2002 10y agoIt depends on the state. In California, for example, Non-completes are notoriously unenforceable. I'll sign whatever illegal documents you want me to sign, knowning that they don't matter. You might respond by saying something like "what if they go after you anyway, even though it is unenforceable.". But the problem is that they could just do that anyway, illegal contract or not.
- juiyout 10y agoSame here in Taiwan. Court has ruled more than once that non-complete cannot be applied to any employee who is not top-level executive.
- etjossem 10y ago> But the problem is that they could just do that anyway, illegal contract or not. The difference is that with an illegal contract, your future employer might actually believe it's more headache than it's worth to fight. I would err on the side of casually striking it out of the employment contract, simply saying "this part of the standard document doesn't apply in our state" etc.
- deaddodo 10y agoYour new employer doesn't have to fight anything. Non-executive non-competes are specifically disallowed by the CA gov't. It's up to your previous employer to prove you were an executive (upper management/c-suite) and sue you, not vice versa.
- pfarnsworth 10y agoBut then you have to deal with a lawsuit, hire a lawyer, etc. Just because it's unenforceable doesn't mean that your shitty employer can't sue you. Why not just head it off at the beginning and have it right there in the signed contract?
- ulucs 10y ago
- lotharbot 10y ago> "When I'm off the clock, my time is my own, up to and including doing paid work for anyone else I want." At least one of the reasons for a non-compete clause is to make sure you're not doing stuff on the clock for your employer, and then getting double-paid by a competitor for essentially the same end result but without the competitor having to pay for the whole process of getting that result. Like, if they're paying you to spend 40 hours a week learning about the key problems in their industry and designing and implementing solutions, and then a competitor hires you for 10 hours a week to re-implement those solutions (not paying for the learning/designing phases). So the competitor is getting the benefit of work you're doing that in some sense should belong to your main employer. There might be something better than a non-compete clause for that sort of scenario, I just don't know what it is.
- etjossem 10y agoGenerally this is covered under a confidentiality agreement, which forbids the disclosure of the company's intellectual property. The designs you mention in your example would be considered work-for-hire, and (depending on how specific/proprietary they were) if you sold them to a competitor on the sly, you might be in violation of such an agreement. So no, a noncompete - even one that only applies to the time you are employed by the company - isn't typically necessary.
- hammock 10y agoExtremely difficult to enforce, depending on the nature of the designs. Cf. the Waymo case for an example of an easier-than-average, but still difficult, case to enforce.
- etjossem 10y agoAgreed. It's all a negotiation, though, and from the perspective of the employee you're going to want to present the confidentiality agreement (and possibly a term-of-employment noncompete) as sufficient to ensure your loyalty. You should under no circumstances agree to anything that restricts your options after term of employment.
- hammock 10y ago>A company is paying me to work for them, they're not paying to own me. When I'm off the clock, my time is my own, up to and including doing paid work for anyone else I want. Suboptimal if you're working for a direct competitor. Standard conflict of interest stuff. Would you accept Donald Trump working for Russia on the night shift? Remember, non-compete is not the same as IP clause - which says anything you create on the job (and potentially off the job) is owned by the company.
- mikeash 10y agoDonald Trump gets paid more than enough to be considered to be on the clock 24/7, and it's generally understood that this is the nature of that job.
- Cerium 10y agoWell, as President Donald Trump gets paid a base salary of 400k. As another poster pointed out the difference between 40 hours / week, and 24/7 is 4.2x. That would mean that "more than enough" for a normal salary is $95k.
- mikeash 10y agoThat was me. And $95,000/year is a pretty good salary. Don't forget the free room and board on top of that.
- coredog64 10y agoThe government provides the cooks and household staff, but the president is responsible for paying for the food.
- saganus 10y agoReally? Do you have a link for this? This sounds very interesting and sort of funny. Not really sure how it works on other presidential houses, but still sounds amusing since it will probably require rules and guidelines on what exactly to deduct from the president's paycheck, no? What if the president invites someone over, in a sort-of-unofficial way but not really, do you get deducted as well? or maybe not because it was "for the job" sort of? Definitely interested to know more.
- ScottBurson 10y ago> First, it's likely they'll use the phrase "standard contract" and say that it just can't be changed. I wonder what would happen if you said "Ah, so you're stipulating that it's a contract of adhesion. I'd like that in writing, please." Contracts of adhesion can be harder to enforce [0]. (IANAL, and I'm not necessarily recommending doing this, but I am curious what kind of response one would be likely to get.) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_form_contract#Contracts_of_adhesion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_form_contract#Contrac...
- hkmurakami 10y agoI think the response is rescinded offer. The reasons will likely be along the lines of litigation risk, flight risk, culture fit, etc. Not joking btw. It's rather amazing that employers who expect rational, logical decision making on the job want applicants to suspend their reasoning and good judgment when it comes to negotiating compensation and employment terms.
- fictioncircle 10y ago> Not joking btw. It's rather amazing that employers who expect rational, logical decision making on the job want applicants to suspend their reasoning and good judgment when it comes to negotiating compensation and employment terms. Which is when you move on to the next employer if at all possible.
- otoburb 10y agoIt's the "if at all possible" part that is not easy for most job applicants. This is probably only marginally easier even for HN users with a higher chance of being in white hot job markets.
- taneq 10y agoEspecially when, if you're in a position of any authority, there's a good chance you'll be negotiating in their behalf. So they want you to make good deals on their behalf while making a poor one on your own behalf...I guess they're hoping you have really poor self-esteem?
- bspn 10y agoSomething I've seen a few times is a disclosure mechanism that allows you to declare any side projects that you're working on in your own time and carve those out from the IP assignment rights usually found within NDAs. Now, you can argue that it's not your employer's business what you do off the clock, but it at least provides a way to protect yourself from falling foul of the agreement and having the company later claim ownership of your work. The key though is to ensure that you don't do any personal work on a company laptop - I believe once you do that all bets are off.
- bicubic 10y agoDo you have any evidence of that disclosure mechanism actually working in the employee's interest? I always read these clauses as 'notify us when you start new side projects so we can decide if we like them and take them off you for some reason or other'.
- closeparen 10y agoAh, but this is the nature of salary employment. There is no clock, so there is no such thing as "off the clock."
- ue_ 10y agoYou raise a very interesting point. Engels said (I can't find the quote at the moment) that the time when the employee is away from work, i.e not selling his labour-power, he is useful to the employer, as the worker repairs himself and maintains himself with the wage given to him, and recharges his faculties by rest and sleep. In this way, the employee is never off the clock, he is always working for that employer in some form, readying himself for more work. This is evident; the employer pays for the upkeep and maintenance of a machine, and in the same way he pays for the upkeep and maintenance of the worker in the form of a wage. The worker is a self-fixing machine which sells a commodity which is able to not only transfer but create value.
- phkahler 10y agoAnd while he's working another shift at another company he's getting additional training which is good for the first employer. This is all bullshit trying to argue the validity of modern day slavery.
- kobeya 10y agoBe reasonable. It's not slavery, nor even indentured servitude when you can quit at any time.
- ue_ 10y agoSome would compare it to a form of slavery, and I think such comparisons are reasonable. "The only difference as compared with the old, outspoken slavery is this, that the worker of today seems to be free because he is not sold once for all, but piecemeal by the day, the week, the year, and because no one owner sells him to another, but he is forced to sell himself in this way instead, being the slave of no particular person, but of the whole property-holding class." (Engels) "The slave frees himself when, of all the relations of private property, he abolishes only the relation of slavery and thereby becomes a proletarian; the proletarian can free himself only by abolishing private property in general." The idea that you can "quit at any time" is a farce; you must then find employment under someone else in order to survive, or manage to amass sufficient capital, something which is not an option for most people, especially with family. An extreme example of this logic utterly failing is in those developing nations with sweatshops.
- tensor 10y agoFrankly I find working for a direct competitor in your off hours to be highly unethical and have no issues with employers trying to ban it in the contract. You're no more entitled to do whatever you want than you are to be employed. It's fair for you to want to work for direct competitors, and it's also fair for employers not to hire you if this is your demand.
- mikeash 10y agoWhat's wrong with it exactly? If I hired a flooring company to lay down some hardwood, I'm not going to tell them "now, don't go doing flooring for my competition for the duration of this job." What's the difference? You're right that it's fair for employers not to hire me if this is my demand. I never meant to imply otherwise. Employers can require all sorts of terrible things. Our recourse is mostly to either negotiate or put up with it.
- StavrosK 10y ago> What's the difference? The difference is that you didn't spend lots of money researching a better type of floor-laying and then have the flooring company come in to lay the hardwood according to your specs. If you had, you might want to protect that secret.
- ue_ 10y agoThen they should protect that with non-disclosure agreements, or realise that they can't survive as a business (or don't want to) without restricting the freedom of the workers to do what they want to outside of the time paid to the employee in the form of wage. I have little or no sympathy for businesses which insist on restricting freedom outside of those hours for which it pays me wage.
- StavrosK 10y agoI agree, I'm just playing devil's advocate.
- 10y ago
- mseebach 10y agoThat's sophistry. Being full time employed means just that. Obviously you have free time and that's great, but that's time to do not-work, not other work, and that's obvious and reasonable to the vast majority of employees, and it makes a lot of sense that prohibiting it is the default. The fact that we work in a field where your hobby might quite often be productive work to the extent that it could compete with your day job is an extreme privilege and is to be treated as such. That said, these things are often malleable, and that's a good thing to be aware of, but grandstanding on "4.2x salary" just makes you look entitled.
- StavrosK 10y ago> Obviously you have free time and that's great, but that's time to do not-work, not other work, and that's obvious and reasonable to the vast majority of employees, and it makes a lot of sense that prohibiting it is the default. Wow. So your point is that, because you like doing non-work on your own time, everybody should be prohibited from doing work? > The fact that we work in a field where your hobby might quite often be productive work to the extent that it could compete with your day job is an extreme privilege and is to be treated as such. Holy shit, seriously? I seriously have to ask my employer permission to have a hobby because the hobby might be lucrative? I have a hard time believing you actually hold these opinions. My employer isn't the one who made my hobby "a privilege". My hobby might be a privilege, but I'm sure as hell not going to ask my employer whether they'll allow me to practice it. It's not a privilege, by the way, because it's a hobby. At most, the "privilege" is the fact that people will pay for it, but it's the same for any person who actually enjoys the field they work in.
- mikeash 10y ago"Being full time employed means just that." "Full time" is just shorthand for "40 hours per week." Don't read things into it that aren't there.
- Steeeve 10y agoThat's interesting. As a contractor I saw them whenever subcontracting, but they were always willing to clarify to the point that they didn't want me contracting with any of their customers directly (and usually only ones that I met through the parent contractor). As an employee, every company I've ever worked for has given me one. Few have been negotiable, but pretty much all have openly stated/agreed they weren't enforceable in CA when I raised concerns.
- phkahler 10y agoThe proper response to "it's not enforceable in CA" is to say "then you won't mind if we cross it out before I sign".
- mirimir 10y ago> A company is paying me to work for them, they're not paying to own me. True. But said company may not want your experience, let alone anything you learn about their business, to benefit competitors. Indeed, they may consider your training with them to be an investment, which gives them rights about what you do with it.
- mirimir 10y agoBelated edit: I'm not agreeing with said company. I'm just pointing to its perspective and reasoning.