4 ms·
So basically, its better that these workers be unemployed? Or you assume there will be an unlimited supply of alternate jobs available?
by Chris2048 10y ago
So basically, its better that these workers be unemployed? Or you assume there will be an unlimited supply of alternate jobs available?
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoWrong premise. It's better to design your economy in a way that doesn't privilege shareholder and investor "risk" over employee and citizen risk. Why should be corporations be given a free hand to act in ways that increase costs, increase personal risk, and lower opportunity for all but a tiny subset of the population?
- Chris2048 10y agoWhat do you mean "wrong premise"? It might be better to design your mathematics so that 1 + 1 = 3, but the argument here is if that is possible. At the level of an economy, the burden is on you to show that minimum wage results in lower risk/higher opportunity for employees.
- Chris2048 10y agoI got a bunch of down-votes for questioning unworkable economics? Just "imagining" there is a better way isn't a plan. Whatever. If ppl in this thread wants to argue magical economics and down-vote anyone that disagrees, go ahead.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoYes, it is better these people are unemployed and receive unemployment benefits until they manage to find a real job. Because they are making the situation worse for everyone.
- Chris2048 10y agoso your idea is necessarily tied to the existence of unemployment benefit.
- rapind 10y agoWhen there exists a social net, isn't it obvious that the existence of poor costs money? Plus, that money disproportionately comes from the lower and middle class in the form of tax. So in reality all you're doing with an underpaid gig economy is allowing corps to indirectly make money off of taxpayers instead of just the customers / companies involved in the service. TLDR; You're paying a tax for someone else to get their food delivered.
- Chris2048 10y agoThat's not true; if no one offered "underpaid" work we'd pay more tax, so that interpretation doesn't work. What you don't understand is that whike "existence of poor costs money", underpaid jobs do not made people poor - you'd have to assume that if companies where held to a minimum wage, that they just pay that (and/or raise prices), rather than employ less.
- rapind 10y agoIf companies are held to a minimum wage, then they'll pay it. Sure, maybe it becomes more cost effective to invest in technology that requires them to pay less people... but I would argue they are doing that already (especially in the context of Uber), regardless of whether it's gig or minimum wage. Rich people don't buy more stuff in proportion to what they make. So the more money that moves from the lower and middle class, the less business opportunity you have. I'm not going to use 10 times more uber eats than someone who makes 10 times less than me. It's not a hard problem to solve in theory. Just figure out how to move money the opposite direction and business will boom! It doesn't even have to be a socialist structure. Maybe we just tax companies for their external negative effects?
- prostoalex 10y agoSuppose one day gig economy companies all go out of business, and all their current workforce files for unemployment benefits. Is my tax burden as a taxpayer going up or down?