4 ms·
It's nice to see economic considerations. For many everyday things we must assume that Mars needs aerospace level reliability and safety. Typically it's assume
by nabla9 10y ago
It's nice to see economic considerations.
For many everyday things we must assume that Mars needs aerospace level reliability and safety. Typically it's assumed that there is at leas factor of ten increase when developing with aerospace standards. So multiply value of everything that can affect health with 10, including housing, fire alarms, ventilation and outdoor gear.
It can't be assumed that settling Mars is preplanned. Every form of manufacturing and every process must constantly adapt and innovate to overcome the obstacles not seen beforehand. This takes lots of time and timelines will slow down. You can't just keep sending up robots in massive amounts. You need to send small batches and refine and constantly adapt them. This requires highly educated manpower.
I's probably hard to find millions of people ready to sentence themselves into very low life standards and lower life expectancy once the hype wears off. There are lots of dreamers cheering who eventually balk or don't survive. How do you get millions of "right stuff" to live the life of constant maintenance. Maybe you need to have cult like sci-fi religion like Mormons :)
- fsloth 10y ago"Typically it's assumed that there is at leas factor of ten increase when developing with aerospace standards. " To my understanding Skunk Works developed e.g. the Blackbird from scratch with much better cost efficiency than a modern greenfield project would if they followed best practices written in stone. I think high quality engineering can be implemented with far less cost if the project allows for iterative development and efficient communication and ownership between stakeholders (e.g. the engineer and the machinist can figure things out on their own instead of rotating everythong through cost and quality control authorities). Ben Rich [0], an ex Skunkworks director laments at length of the inefficiency of bureaucratic style of product development - which is probably an outgrowth of the same phenomena that causes so many bullshit jobs. So, to my mind what things like F-35 cost and what are the intrinsic costs of proper, durable engineering are not entirely related. [0] Rich, Skunk works
- nabla9 10y agoI'm not talking about developing experimental aircraft, I'm talking about manufacturing and maintaining safety critical equipment for everyday use. If you could order wide body jet without the attached standards, they would be able to build exact replica of the fleet with fraction of the cost. Same aluminum pieces with random quality inspections is much cheaper than every piece of aluminum checked and tested before installing, plus verifying that it's tested and inspected. Installing that piece would be cheaper if there would be no inspectors for every phase of work doubling or tripling the manpower. Just tightening a bolt is cheap. Tightening it the right amount, cheeking that it has been done correctly etc. are costly. Astronauts living in ISS periodically inspect every hatch and every safety critical device. Their days are filled with checklists. Things wear down and break and small undetected error can end life.
- fsloth 10y agoI'm not disagreeing with anything you say. I just pointed out that it's not obvious what are the necessary costs of durable systems and engineering. As for my example, I think it meets the criterion for a good example. Blackbird was not 'experimental', it was designed as a workhorse and functioned and operated as such.
- robbiep 10y agoInteresting >* I's probably hard to find millions of people ready to sentence themselves into very low life standards and lower life expectancy once the hype wears off.* Have you seen how billions of humanity live today? There are always going to be millions of people looking for a better something somewhere. Doesn't mean they will find it
- nabla9 10y agoPeople you send to Mars have to be highly educated and capable of running the most high-tech society in the world. They will be able to find better jobs and better life on Earth. Engineer living with minimum income on earth gets more free time, travel and swimming opportunities on Earth.
- robbiep 10y agoHighly educated Indian/Chinese/African/Russian fight it out at home or roll the dice?