3 ms·
Housing is one of things that can be solved by UBI - currently in many regions housing is scarce in places "where all the jobs are" and plentiful, cheap, and ev
by PeterisP 10y ago
Housing is one of things that can be solved by UBI - currently in many regions housing is scarce in places "where all the jobs are" and plentiful, cheap, and even empty and abandoned in places with few jobs. This imbalance happens in 'competition' between different centers, and also in the process of urbanization. We have people leaving their granparent's houses, and leaving them empty, just to go to the big city where they can actually earn a living.
UBI can change that by making it feasible for underemployed people to live in those cheaper areas. If there's no economic reason (good for society) to have them work at all, then there's no economic reason for them to live in the scarce housing in the economically most active areas - and they will revitalize the cheaper areas by bringing their spending there.
- mjevans 10y agoI agree this could help a little, but the "nice" places are still where people will /want/ to live. Where you see a city now is either a nice place, or someplace that has strategic value of some kind. (real cities, not suburb towns) Markets work best when lightly regulated, when there's corrective action to smooth out the ups and downs of overshoot and collapse tendencies. Something I see lacking is the will to ensure sufficient supply so that demand can have choice, instead of captivity and vulnerability.
- adrianN 10y agoI think a lot more people would live closer to greenery if they wouldn't have to commute to a job.
- redahs 10y agoHousing costs can be solved without massive social transfer payments simply by eliminating all income and consumption taxes and switching to a land value tax in order to pay for public services. If UBI transfer payments are paid out of a consumption or income tax, then landholders and mortgage companies will simply be able to charge all residents higher rent. If residents experience an increase in housing costs associated with savings which must be put away for purchases, rent, and mortgage payments that is in proportion to the increase income they receive via UBI, then UBI will not have made them better off. UBI will only have redistributed money from workers and entrepreneurs to landholders and banks invested in mortgages. Under a land value tax, landholders cannot charge higher rent due to an increase in land values brought on by public spending on public services. If they want to increase their profits, they have to invest in real property improvements, such as by expanding the stock of available housing. If UBI is paid out of taxes on labor rather than taxes on land, they will be able to charge higher rent.
- orthecreedence 10y agoCan anyone explain to me why this is being downvoted? A mob of angry property holders? OR is there some glaring flaw in this reasoning that I'm not seeing? It seems like a viable contribution to the discussion.
- prostoalex 10y ago> UBI can change that by making it feasible for underemployed people to live in those cheaper areas. Detroit or Baltimore are pretty affordable already, and some counties will give away free land if one agrees to settle there. That did not seem to spur much economic development.
- PeterisP 10y agoThat's the big difference I'm talking about. Cheap or even free housing is not sufficient, currently hard-to-employ people can't afford to live in Detroit - they also need to eat, so they need jobs that simply aren't there. So the practical result is that such people are forced to move to locations with much more expensive rent so that they'd have any income whatsoever. UBI would mean that the underemployed people could move to Detroit if they wanted to. That would effect a transfer of money towards Detroit - as money would be taxed elsewhere, flow through these people and get spent in Detroit, spurring economic development. Widespread remote work could achieve a similar result, having people live and spend in Detroit but earn money elsewhere; but currently it is not widespread and so doesn't make a meaningful impact.