6 ms·
I definitely think this is cool tech, and it's going to be amazing to see this whole setup work once completed. I do have to wonder, this seems like it a large
by arcticbull 10y ago
I definitely think this is cool tech, and it's going to be amazing to see this whole setup work once completed.
I do have to wonder, this seems like it a largely over-engineered solution to the problem of moving people -- wouldn't it be more practical to put a train down there? This still requires individuals own cars, so it does nothing to reduce costs, promote equality and seems to just move the traffic problem from the downtown core to the outlets of the tunnel. Am I missing something?
It feels like LA really needs public transit.
- robertfw 10y agoThere was a snippet in the video of a purpose built passenger transport vehicle that could fill in the role of public transit: https://youtu.be/u5V_VzRrSBI?t=47 https://youtu.be/u5V_VzRrSBI?t=47
- Robotbeat 10y agoExactly this. There's absolutely no reason you couldn't use the system for public transit. Just need pods with an enclosure as shown in the video. It'd be way cheaper than sending your whole car. Whether the car pod or the transit pod make the most sense is largely irrelevant at this phase. The system can (and seems to be planned to?) use both at the same time. So if a bunch of people want to pay to use this for their cars, then it can be used with cars. If people want to use this as a more responsive subway, then it can be used that way as well. They just configure the little pods one way or another, 98% of the system (tunnels, elevators, track, vast majority of the pod, etc) remains the same either way. I actually kind of suspect that enclosed pods will be used for both, since otherwise you have to worry about debris flying off of cars (like those dumb little flags, dirt, and drinks accidentally left on the roof) and hitting pods behind. Personally, my favorite mode of transport in a city is bikes mixed with public transit. This system seems to work well with both. But the point of a pod-based system like this is that you can let the market decide which exact mix makes the most sense. If people are willing to pay to transport their whole car, then why not let them? Or why not have just passenger pods? The system is designed to be expandable to arbitrary numbers of pods and tracks, so there needn't be any reason you couldn't do both.
- so33 10y agoWith all due respect, there already is a flexible platform where people can send whatever they want; it's called a road. The problem is that single-occupancy vehicles take up lots of road space and degrade bus service. Today, when buses get their own lane, service reliability increases for the buses. What you could say is that the current system of roads benefits single-occupancy vehicles and that this, as a private solution, would force people to pay the true costs. But quite frankly there will likely be subsidies for this, especially because Elon Musk seems to view this as a way to reduce car travel times for himself, which leaves us with the same problem as we had before.
- Robotbeat 10y agoOf course. Roads are great. But they have drawbacks: 1) two dimensional, meaning you have to deconflict intersections with stop signs, stop lights, low-speed traffic circles, or huge cloverleafs. Also means that adding more road capacity directly eats into land use. This drives density down, increasing travel times overall. It also is a huge barrier to foot traffic, bicycles (for high speed roads), and wildlife. 2) Weather. Inclement weather limits when you can drive on roads and how fast as well as reducing safety dramatically and reduces capacity. 3) Speeds. Can't safely go 125mph on a road unless you have a LOT of space to accelerate. Even on the autobahn, this is pretty dangerous. Tunnels are 3D and do not take up space from other things, deconflicting the tension between single-occupancy vehicles and buses (and other modes of public transport). And small tunnels (gas, water main, electrical and telecomm conduit, storm sewer, and sanitary sewer) are already ubiquitous, going under basically everyone's property and in multiple levels. This is especially so in large cities, when the size of those existing tunnels can approach what Musk envisions. If you could somehow dramatically lower the cost of tunneling (and tunneling in particular, not trench-and-covering, which disturbs the surface), then you could do transport much more efficiently. New York City shows what a great subway system is like and how tunneling enables efficient transport in spite of huge densities. But it's 100 years old, and for whatever reason (labor costs, safety, etc) we simply could not afford to build another system like it nowadays.
- eagsalazar2 10y agoI was thinking largely the same thing. Moving cars seems like the least interesting application of the boring tech if it really works.
- tbabb 10y agoPart of the expected cost reduction is in reduced cross sectional area, so a train won't fit into the 12 ft tunnels they're planning to make.
- astrodust 10y agoYou might not be able to fit a full-sized train in there, but don't forget the original New York City Subway had to fit in some relatively tiny tunnels: http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/The_Construction_of_the_Harlem_River_Tubes_(1915) http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/The_Construction_of_the_Harlem... Subway trains are often engineered to specification, so if you have a tunnel of a particular size the manufacturer can make a train for it. The precursor to the modern subway was a strange pneumatic system that would fit in that tunnel as well: http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/Beach_Pneumatic_Transit http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/Beach_Pneumatic_Transit
- spditner 10y agoThere are a few reasons that I'm aware of that new projects typically bore larger tunnels versus a 12ft bore that would reduce construction and operational costs: - Logistically, it is difficult to get a cement truck into a small tunnel, as each truck would need to back out of the tunnel. You end up offloading into smaller cement trucks that can turn around, which is the headache that the Eglinton LRT tunnels is dealing with now - Need space for a level floor, conduits/tunnel infrastructure and evacuation walkways - Air flow. The rail car is an effective cork. Small tunnels require more ventilation and draw more power to push that air being compressed around -- unless the underlying truck is going to be propelling itself via the air Barcelona's system is apparently the new gold standard for how it should be done [1] They were able to build it out at ~$39 million/km[2] [1] http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=1866842 http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=1866842 [2] https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/06/03/comparative-subway-construction-costs-revised/ https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/06/03/comp...
- tomarr 10y agoYou're missing the biggest one - evacuation. The reason many tunnels are oversized is to allow walkways for people to evacuate using in an emergency. This drives the size up a fair bit.
- _delirium 10y agoLA has been significantly expanding public transit in recent years. Lots more to be done of course, but there are actual new lines being built now [1], after a period of 10-20 years when investment in the system had stalled. [1] http://www.lamag.com/driver/mark-your-calendars-all-the-metro-rail-openings/ http://www.lamag.com/driver/mark-your-calendars-all-the-metr...
- hellcow 10y agoI live in LA, and I don't drive. I use public transit and Uber. The biggest problems I have with LA's public transit have nothing to do with a lack of lines. LA's public transit is unreliable -- sometimes the scheduled bus just doesn't show up and you have to wait ~45 mins for the next one. Hope you didn't have a meeting scheduled! London by comparison has GPS on all their buses, so you know precisely how far away they are and how long they'll take to reach you. But more importantly, LA's public transit is not terribly safe/comfortable. I'll never take the train after dark again after a homeless person had a psychotic break and threatened (in a very serious way) to kill me. Gang members are a common sight. They need security on the trains themselves.
- _delirium 10y agoDefinitely agree on needing more frequent and reliable bus service, with updates on actual bus locations. I do think some of the new lines are useful, but it depends on where you live and where you go. The Expo Line has improved the situation getting in and out of Santa Monica, for example.
- dsp1234 10y agoAm I missing something? "the problem of moving people" on Mars.
- arcticbull 10y agoAt the risk of sounding like a one-trick pony I recommend trains :P Space trains. Like in Galaxy Express 999 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy_Express_999 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy_Express_999)
- xemoka 10y agoOr the Quadrail! https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Quadrail_series https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Quadrail_series
- le-mark 10y agoIt also occurred to me that rapid, efficient tunneling would be very nice to have on Mars, or anywhere in the solar system really. Underground is the only place you can get protections from hard radiation, when your planet/moon doesn't have the beneft of a magnetosphere and atmosphere. Tunneling habitats seems a good way to go.
- mark212 10y agoLA has a lot of public transit, it's just really spread out and not very dense. Public transit tends to be hub-and-spoke, sort of, but the usual paths for commuting or shopping or socializing are way more distributed. (I lived in LA for ten years, on the West side, and went to downtown LA twice.) It's a geographic region that is heavily dependent on cars to get from, say, Sherman Oaks to Northridge; or Westwood to LAX. There are buses, but they run sporadically, aren't seen as very safe, and take twice as long to get there.
- iamacynic 10y agotrying to explain public transit in LA to people is always difficult. the long and short of it is, it takes too long to get anywhere you want to go, so people just drive instead. the exceptions are people who can't afford to drive, and people who just happen to live and work in convenient spots.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoYou're not missing anything. This is an example of implementing the wrong solution better instead of implementing the right solution. The right solution is as you state public transit, which is more space efficient at moving people than cars.
- Fricken 10y agoThe sleds are pretty cool, so long as you're using them to move people instead of cars. But if they can bring the cost of boring down by a factor of 10, that in and of itself would be a game changer, regardless of what you use the tunnel for.
- teej 10y agoThe right solution on earth, with its fancy pants atmosphere.
- _red 10y agoWhat about digging up 100 million tons of earth to get enough lithium to make a battery for your electric car which is powered by coal? Fake environmentalist love Elon - no reason why they won't like this.
- lukeschlather 10y agoPick a poison gas, buying and operating an all-electric car generates less of it per mile than a gasoline car, even if your electricity is all-coal. It also enables even greater poison control by using renewable electricity sources.
- _red 10y agoHow much carbon was created digging up all that earth? Was that earth also dug up with battery powered trucks? Transported on battery powered ships? By the way, why does Singapore grade Tesla as a super-polluter category?
- scrollaway 10y agoIt's a wonder Teslas cost as little as they do when you consider each one requires "digging up 100 million tons of earth" just for the battery. Me, I can't even get 10 million tons dug for less than $100k! Those darn fake environmentalists. They're right up there with the scotsmen of the "no true" variety.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoWell, public transit is hard for the last mile to your destination. Having your own car with you, makes it pretty easy to go in and drive the "normal road" for the last miles. Eliminating the busiest roads and removing traffic jams, seems to be the main goal, i suppose
- antisthenes 10y agoIt's only hard because of the destructive and segregationist DECADES of policy of expanding the suburbia. I assure you, in most places outside of the US, public transport does go to last mile pretty well.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoWell, i live here in Belgium ( good public transport/very wide coverage). The hard thing about public transport is that you have to find out where to go / how, if you are suddenly changing plans in a "not-known" area. Not only that, it takes significantly longer than going by car. I think Elon Musk brings the best of both worlds by reducing travel time and avoiding busy roads/traffic jams ( no need to build it on the countryside) and if you want. You can return by night. Also, in Belgium, all our roads have severe traffic jams. The tunnels could reduce traffic jams on normal roads. Records break year after year with no solution ahead. ( and yeah, our governement invests a lot in public transport. It isn't profitable now and it will never be profitable -- heavily subsidised) No public transit is affordable at night over a long distance. Almost everything happens by daytime. I'm not saying public transport is bad, but it's not cost-effective if you want it everywhere / everytime. This could really be the solution, it's genius. The cost of the tunnels would be paid back in a short time, only because roads are less jammed.
- so33 10y agoWe already tried fast roads that avoid traffic in America in the form of elevated expressways that criss-cross the city core. They are an absolute eyesore and end up creating more traffic themselves due to induced demand. I think the real solution is a good, high-frequency public transport grid combined with an autonomous taxi or micro-transit system.
- dvnguyen 10y agoI guess Mr. Musk is preparing infrastructure for his future projects. A auto driving taxi service would have some benefits from this project: - convenient as taxi while being fast as subway trains. - less likely to crash. - easier to estimate transportation time.
- backpropaganda 10y agoIf you'd ask the people in 1900s, they'd say the "right solution" is faster horses. Public transit SUCKS. And I don't understand why people are pretending that it doesn't. Space efficiency and throughput are not the only important variables here. How about freedom? Once I take that train and reach my work, what if I have to go somewhere nearby work? There's a reason cars exist. In your imaginary world, trains might be better than cars, but in the real world, cars are way better, even in those higher culture societies with planned cities like Scandinavia. Cars exist there too. Why? Because they do solve some problem, which I'd imagine could be comfort, freedom, privacy, hygiene, and many others I'm sure.
- Retric 10y agoPublic transit can be awesome once you scale it enough. You basically want one subway stop per 4 blocks. With the upside being you don't have to park and unpack your car or deal with traffic, or stop lights. However, you want a train every 3 minutes in both directions and 2 train lines per stations. Which takes a lot of effing trains, but means your average wait time is 3 minutes per trip, and you generally only need to use 2 trains to get to any point in the city. Also, you want a nice layer of cabs for short hop trips.
- justjonathan 10y agoSmall Correction: if you have trains coming every three minutes I think your average wait time should be 1.5 minutes.
- Retric 10y ago1.5 minutes for first train, get off that train 1.5 minutes wait for second train. You can now get to any point on an XY grid with ~3 minutes of wait time. 1.5 minutes works if your only going down one line but that's not a huge number of stops.
- arcticbull 10y agoThat could also be improved with timed connections.
- Retric 10y agoThe real advantage is scaling up the number of machines so you can iterate more cheaply, and add capacity continuously. They can always scale up a design at some point in the future. As to tunnel exits, the goal is not to have 3 or 4 exits per city but hundreds. Even single lane roads can send vastly more people than any one building needs the problem is the longer the roads the more buildings you need to serve. So, his solution is to have multiple layers of grids under the surface.
- maxxxxx 10y agoTotally agree. Creating tunnels is good but why car tunnels? Put a subway there.
- zardo 10y ago>This still requires individuals own cars. I don't think it does. It's a moving platform, many different things can sit on a flat platform. In the CG video, they even showed something that looked more like a bar than a car on one.
- fittingin 10y agoYou know what you might do if you were a problem solver like Elon? You would identify the problem you just described, then you would start a company that operates van-sized buses that could easily use the Boring company's tunnels. You pick up 4-10 people and carry them through the tunnels and let them out. For bonus points, your vans could be autonomous. Or, you could, you know... complain that tunnels aren't a complete solution.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 10y agoWhy not both? How about a combination tunnel-taxi solution, or a sled to carry bicyclists? To be successful, this will have to adapt to a variety of cars and could carry other car-like things. It could be pretty modular system.
- bb88 10y ago>>> wouldn't it be more practical to put a train down there? Because speaking from someone that Uber's 10 times a week, rode busses all throughout college, I gotta say, I really really like car ownership. There's no smells. There's no weird homeless people. I don't have to wait 45 minutes for the next bus to show up. I don't have to schedule a ride to go to the grocery store. The same vehicle takes me from the city to the rural areas. The driver doesn't cancel on you if you're destination is not far enough away. (Uber) I don't experience surge fees. (Uber) I don't have to cross 3 different types of transportation to get from point A to B.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoAnother way to eliminate the problems you had with public transit would have been to move to Japan. Well, you would probably have to switch trains/buses to go to a rural area, but those rural areas are very well served so you wouldn't mind.
- bb88 10y agolol... and speak Japanese. That's such a simple solution to my problem.
- jugad 10y agoI have seen many sides of this dice... I have lived in New Delhi for 20 years, in Singapore for 5 years and in SF/Berkeley for 10 years. Public transit in SF Bay area is horrible. You are right... it smells because of the homeless riding it all day, and service times are bad, and its quite expensive too. Even New Delhi's metro is nicer and cleaner than the BART / Caltrain (because its newer but also because the company keeps it clean). Singapore's public transit system is out of this world. Its absolutely amazing. Clean, efficient, reasonably priced, etc. It was a shock to me when I landed in the "greatest country on earth" to see such a pathetic public transport systems. I brought a motorcycle after my first year in US. We have 2 cars now, not only because we like the cars, but precisely because we would like to avoid the public transport. However, people who have seen good public transport would always vote for that. I would love to see a Singapore like public transport in the US. I loved it and would give up 1 of our cars for that (still need 1 car to head out to Yosemite). But alas, I don't see that happening in the US because US people have not seen good public transport.
- marcell 10y agoBecause public transit is terrible. I don't know--have you ridden busses in LA? You have to walk to the bus stop, wait, ride the smelly bus, possibly transfer, walk to your final destination, carry your heavy bags. It's terrible, no one who can afford a car will use it. If you want to improve public transit you have to solve the last-mile problem, which is expensive. You can't afford a bus every 5 minutes for 1 person to ride. Alternately you can take an Uber, which is very similar to driving your own car. People who are putting down this project because it's not public transit should consider that public transit has been around for decades. It works in some cities (NYC, Tokyo, etc.) but not in others (LA, Bay Area). We need a new solution, and having it car based for last-mile makes a lot of sense. Edit: Example, a 20 minute car ride takes ~50 minutes with a transfer using public transit in LA: http://goo.gl/1s6cxL http://goo.gl/1s6cxL
- burkaman 10y agoAre you sure the reason it works in Tokyo and not LA is because LA is unsuited for public transit? It could be that public transit was just executed very poorly in LA.
- bb88 10y agoIt could be LA's fault, You're right. However it does show that putting in a public transportation system isn't like spreading magical fairy dust that solves the world's problems. It's like saying: "The world would be so much better if everyone could just learn to juggle 9 balls." Not only is the premise that juggling saves the world problematic, but there's a huge barrier of entry just to prove it could work.
- so33 10y agoBut it has already been proven to work, in Tokyo and Hong Kong and Shanghai and London and Paris and countless other cities, countless other times.
- burkaman 10y agoMy analogy would be: "America would be so much better if everyone voted." It's not wrong, it's incomplete, we really want everyone to fully understand the issues and then vote. Likewise, a public transit system alone won't make a city better, but a well-planned and executed one will. I don't think it's unreasonable to say that if Elon successfully revolutionizes boring technology, it might be better to use it on a really good public transit system. And it's an especially important conversation if his fully realized tunnel network would make a later subway system more difficult/impossible even if people wanted one.
- oceanswave 10y agoIsn't it also Musk's vision that self driving community or corporation owned electric cars are the future of public transit?
- tkxxx7 10y agoI don't see any reason this can't be a halfway point though. If he wants to pour effort into building better drills, it's a good way to start profiting now before committing to public transit efforts (and maybe make the proposition a little more attractive to local governments).