3 ms·
Sometimes I wonder how so much complexity and co-dependency has evolved on earth in such little time. Most estimates I've read say that we're likely within an
by jcims 10y ago
Sometimes I wonder how so much complexity and co-dependency has evolved on earth in such little time. Most estimates I've read say that we're likely within an order of magnitude of 100 trillion generations deep from the universal common ancestor at this point. That sounds like a lot, but not really. If you took 30 four sided die, you'd have to roll them a million trillion times to have a good shot at getting any specific permutation.
How many 'die rolls' does it take to get a selective feature to emerge in an organism? If you do a google image search for 'camouflage bugs', you'll find some brain-bending examples. There's clearly a selective advantage for some of those 'configurations', but how many generations would it take for each genetic mutation required to make a lichen katydid or an orchid mantis to converge?
- simooooo 10y agoI don't think dice are a good comparison, as each roll is a new "state", knowing nothing about the previous. Vs. evolution which has kind of a feedback loop which influences future output.
- runeks 10y agoWhy do you assume that progress only happens at the interface between generations? If that were the case, human beings would be at a huge disadvantage, given that we wait ~20 years or so before reproducing. The longer we wait before reproducing, the more intelligent the decision to reproduce will be -- which is what determines the genome of the resulting offspring.
- kahoon 10y ago> There's clearly a selective advantage for some of those 'configurations', but how many generations would it take for each genetic mutation required to make a lichen katydid or an orchid mantis to converge? If you pose the question like that with the posteriori knowledge in mind, then yes, these configurations are highly improbable. I think another question that could be asked is: How many generations would it take for some mutations to produce some camouflage effect in some of the millions of existing species? Surely some mutations that produce camouflage effects will happen.
- mikekchar 10y agoSome changes can happen really quickly too. If you look at breeders of fancy pigeons or fish, they can do incredible things in a relatively small number of generations. Of course, breeders are generally much more selective than nature, but it gives you a lower bound on what is possible.