4 ms·
Emulation should be a last resort. They should ship an SDK with all the proper import libs and a cl.exe etc. that can target proper Win32 on ARM.
by asveikau 10y ago
Emulation should be a last resort. They should ship an SDK with all the proper import libs and a cl.exe etc. that can target proper Win32 on ARM.
- alkonaut 10y agoAgree. But that would mean people would make new Win32 apps which can theoretically be sold on other places than the store. (I realize Win32 apps + bridge makes it possible to sell store apps based on Win32 too - but it's not exactly the way they want it to happen). It feels like microsoft these days think that people who make desktop apps and don't sell them in the store are robbing them. Microsoft just needs the library of legacy Win32 apps to get their Windows-on-arm to take off, but they want as much as possible of new apps to be using the store. Not least evident by the new "The app you are installing is not from the windows store" messages in Creators Update.
- asveikau 10y agoIt would mean they would have to admit that Windows is not an iPhone or an iPad, that they shouldn't blindly copy what that other fruit-themed vendor has been doing, that maybe people own their computers (not the platform vendor) and want to use them. Failure to acknowledge this is why 8/RT failed and they are trying to repeat it edging just a bit closer towards sane but it's pretty disappointing that they won't go the whole way.
- alkonaut 10y agoI think they are trying to make the legacy desktop a professional and enterprise one, because there is no money selling operating systems to consumers. If they can get the huge chunk of people who are using their computers without an enterprise domain, and without heavy workstation apps (basically just doing internet/docs/games) to use a cheap and safe iOS-style windows, then they can at least start getting 30% cut of the app sales from all those people. I'm not too worried about that as long as there is a proper windows for professionals. In the above scenario they could start charging more of a premium than they do today for the legacy windows desktop because there would be no consumer version of it.
- midnitewarrior 10y agoMicrosoft appears to have apps that are native to ARM, but the real value of the Windows ecosystem is all the Win32 apps that have been built over the last 2 decades. The emulation layer addresses that so that "it just works" with old apps. I assume they will be releasing a build configuration for native ARM software deployment on Windows.
- asveikau 10y agoI would not assume such. They actively seem to hate this scenario.
- poizan42 10y agoThe import libs for Windows IoT seems to contain the full api surface, so we already have those - it's just that a lot of the functions are stubbed out in the actual dlls on the system.
- poizan42 10y agoDidn't think about this when I wrote the comment above, but the IoT import libs are of course 32 bit, and the new Windows for ARM here is 64 bit, so I guess it's not actually very useful. Still you can easily make your own inmport libs, but that of course does not give prospective developers the best experience. I guess we will have to see what Microsoft are going to do about this.