5 ms·
Microsoft is so frustrating. On the one hand, they really seem earnest about wanting to make Windows 10 appealing to people like me who fled Windows for Unix-a
by smacktoward 10y ago
Microsoft is so frustrating.
On the one hand, they really seem earnest about wanting to make Windows 10 appealing to people like me who fled Windows for Unix-alike systems long ago. And steps like this show that they're not just addressing that at a shallow level, but are willing to dig deep to make it happen, which is sincerely encouraging.
But then on the other hand, they insist on loading Windows 10 up with privacy invasions you can't disable and ads in deeply inappropriate places like Windows Explorer, which is just a huge buzz-kill for the exact type of person who the other stuff is so clearly meant to appeal to. Which gives the whole effort a real Keystone Kops aspect.
It feels like there's different groups inside MS that are working from fundamentally incompatible premises, and Nadella either isn't willing or isn't able to wrangle them into all pulling in the same direction. I guess it's an improvement over the Microsoft of old to see the company's basic orientation go from "competent evil" to "incompetent good," but when you consider how few good things there are in the universe it's always sad to see a potential new one kneecapping itself.
- pilot72 10y agoIt's easy to understand: http://i.imgur.com/3zbOPJI.jpg http://i.imgur.com/3zbOPJI.jpg
- nbevans 10y agoI'm not saying it's not true but I am yet to see any advertisement in my Windows 10 anywhere... even Explorer! Anyone else?
- kodfodrasz 10y agoI have also not seen any anytime. It is also true that I only use managed Enterprise, and a pro at home where I have o365 subscription.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jcrawfordor 10y agoI think people have a bit of a popular misconception about the Explorer advertising thing. What's happening is that MS is adding a banner to Explorer advertising paid OneDrive subscriptions. I totally agree that it's massively inappropriate, but I do think that most people are imagining third-party advertising which is not what's happening - a lot of people might not consider the current situation to be an "ad" necessarily since it is pushing a subscription for OneDrive, a Microsoft product that you already have installed. It's more of an in-app purchase kind of offer.
- sbarre 10y agoYeah I don't understand why people are freaking out about this. I know the icon is there, but I never "see" it and I'll never click on it.. So who cares..
- badthingfactory 10y agoAs-is, I don't think it's a big deal. This is a slippery slope though. Look at what cable television has become. You pay for the product and they shove advertisements down your throat. Satellite radio is doing the same thing.
- Karunamon 10y agoI don't particular care who is trying to sell me shit in the file manager, I care that shit is being sold in the file manager. In an operating system I paid $100 for. Unacceptable.
- Semaphor 10y agoIt's all in the settings. I never had ads or privacy problems, but if you leave everything at the default settings, you'll have those problems
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI agree that it's all in the settings, but I also had to turn off Cortana making suggestions in 3 different spots. MS definitely didn't make it easy to get it to stop harassing you.
- komali2 10y agoThey don't necessarily make it easy to turn off all the weird ad-type-stuff, but they don't make it impossible either. A quick tour through settings on install can get rid of it all. There is still one absolutely heinous crime though - your system comes preinstalled with Minecraft and Candy Crush (and a couple other bullshit softares), and if you uninstall them, Windows 10 will automatically reinstall them. You have to do esoteric shit in the registry editor to disable this. It infuriates me.
- cryptarch 10y agoAre you for real? Is this really the world most of my friends live in?
- anonymfus 10y ago>There is still one absolutely heinous crime though - your system comes preinstalled with Minecraft and Candy Crush (and a couple other bullshit softares), and if you uninstall them, Windows 10 will automatically reinstall them. That was fixed in Creators Update: it now remembers uninstalled default applications.
- komali2 10y agoI'm not 100% on this, but I'm fairly certain I wiped and reinstalled Windows on my surface after the creator's update, and I still had this issue.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- badthingfactory 10y agoI formatted a few weeks ago. After installing Chrome and opening it, a popover appeared over the Edge icon in my toolbar explaining how much faster it is. I've also seen a few OneDrive ads.
- iaml 10y agoI recently did a fresh install of creators update on my laptop. Not only does it have crapware bundled that I had to uninstall, it has placeholders for apps from store which is literally advertisement. I also got edge ads when I was downloading other browser. I preemptively disabled all other "suggestions", but saying that windows 10 doesn't have ads is a blatant lie.
- stcredzero 10y agoOn the one hand, they really seem earnest about wanting to make Windows 10 appealing to people like me who fled Windows for Unix-alike systems long ago. I tried Ubuntu on Windows 10, and found it too wonky. I switched over to running Xubuntu in VirtualBox! It feels like there's different groups inside MS that are working from fundamentally incompatible premises It's always been like this.
- cryptarch 10y agoXubuntu is lovely, but for the last year I've been on i3/IceWeasel/urxvt exclusively. So much faster and more convenient than clicking and dragging around all the time. When friends want to use my desktop I change my DE to XFCE for a sec. I also still use the XFCE login screen (because it's easy to install, it works and you get per-user DE defaults).
- jaboutboul 10y agoIt seems to me like the issue is that its just a really large ship and will take a while for the whole company to get on board with the new philosphy. Redmond wasn't built in a day.
- shepardrtc 10y ago> It feels like there's different groups inside MS that [...] Nadella either isn't willing or isn't able to wrangle them into all pulling in the same direction That's exactly how it is.
- Jach 10y agoAs illustrated here: http://www.bonkersworld.net/organizational-charts/ http://www.bonkersworld.net/organizational-charts/
- smichel17 10y agoKnow someone who works at Microsoft, can confirm.
- apardoe-MSFT 10y agoI know someone who works at Microsoft (and has for 15 years.) These cartoons are brilliant--especially the org charts for different companies--but things actually are changing at Microsoft. Some divisions change faster than others. And some old reputations are very hard to shake. But Microsoft isn't the company it used to be. There are other companies filling that role now. Example: Even though all you ever hear about is "Windows is spying on me!" I can name three big tech companies that probably know more about you than Microsoft does.
- apardoe-MSFT 10y agoThanks for the downvotes! But seriously, do you honestly think that Microsoft is spying on your more than Google, Facebook, or Amazon? And do you think your Mac OS doesn't have the exact same sort of telemetry (or more!) that Windows has? The 90's are over.
- flukus 10y ago> But seriously, do you honestly think that Microsoft is spying on your more than Google, Facebook, or Amazon? Yes. I have much more control* over what google and facebook can spy on. MS as the platform owner has the ability to spy on everything. *Except for on android, fuck google now in particular.
- aeleos 10y agoConsidering how much they are probably spending in order to make this happen (considering the amount of work being done to it), I feel like it was started as a proposal to the head people that there was a group of people that normally wouldn't use windows, but could be convinced to use it by having this subsystem. Along with this, supporting open source makes Microsoft look good. But, it wasn't anywhere close to enough of an importance for Microsoft to abandon their data collection system just to go "all the way" with the whole open source thing. It seems like their privacy model is more important to them than whatever an open source model could bring them.
- mnm1 10y agoWhat Microsoft is doing with Windows today is not just "competent evil," it's "deliberate competent evil." 90's Microsoft was tolerable. Since Windows 10, they've destroyed the entire Windows ecosystem for anyone that cares about privacy. IMO, that's orders of magnitude worse for everyone. But hey, at least if we find a keylogger in Microsoft software, at least we know it's a feature, not a bug or debugging tool.
- oridecon 10y agoSince everything and everyone is collecting user data, it would be fair to leave the starter/home/"cloud" editions as it is. But damn, if I'm going to pay for my OS I want ZERO data collection and the option to never use stuff like Cortana (opt-in). And if that's too much to ask, why don't they release a more expensive Windows 10 Tinfoil Edition? You would still have to trust MS but at least you would have the legal right to dispute it (if they decide to do something shady).
- shmed 10y agoGet the Enterprise Edition and you'll get full control on what data is leaving your machine.
- oridecon 10y agoThat's just not true: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12959097 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12959097
- vetinari 10y agoUnfortunately, not true anymore.
- oridecon 10y agoIn my opinion it was never truly off even when the label pointed to that. Explorer, Photos, Cortana and everything else is constantly making networks calls for "reasons". For me "Off" means it will only call home to check for updates and for opt-in features that requires a connection.
- apardoe-MSFT 10y agoSo what phone do you carry? A Nokia flip-phone?
- oridecon 10y agoReally? On a discussion about a desktop OS? There are so many things going through my mind after your comment that I can't even start typing. Branch limit reached. I'm using Android and I have the same concerns about it. I gave my Lumia away because it doesn't have the apps that I need and, again, I had the same concerns. My time is limited so I have to pick my battles. Mobile is a lost cause. So I decide to give feedback about one of the two desktop OSs that I use (Windows and Linux). I don't give a shit if Apple/Google is going to make you insert a coin every hour to use the OS, I would still complain to MS if they decided to do the same. I don't even know exactly what's your point. Feel free to ask if I write Microsoft with a $.
- grennis 10y agoAnd OSX keeps nagging me in various ways to use iCloud.. is that an "ad" also?
- Arcsech 10y agoiCloud is at least also an Apple product. The last time I installed Win10 (fresh, legal install media direct from Microsoft), on the first boot there was an ad for Candy Crush in the start menu. That's just unacceptable.
- KSS42 10y agoThat's why I switched to a Chromebook. ;)
- no_wizard 10y agoI thought the Enterprise edition had none of these problems. Might be worth grabbing that instead?