4 ms·
What's the (right wing) libertarian strategy for mitigating our winner takes all economy?
by specialist 10y ago
What's the (right wing) libertarian strategy for mitigating our winner takes all economy?
- snomad 10y agoHaving actually read some Adam Smith (not the whole book), he goes on and on about asymmetric access / advantages granted through government and how it must be prevented. The free-market strategy is to recognize that the winner take all capitalist frequently uses the government as the vehicle for winning, and thus limit government. That is not the same as no regulation / de-regulation! Adam Smith was basically saying we need regulation, to keep the government and business apart. IMO, government regulation works when it is structural (e.g. Glass-Steagall worked because it was a simple structural rule) and when it is at the right level (DMVs works because they are state based) and it is easily understood.
- specialist 10y agoI want to believe that governance (such as market regulations) can work when there are checks & balances, transparency, accountability.
- mac01021 10y agoWho says they need one? Define a "libertarian" as someone who advocates for the state to play a minimal role in the lives of people. There are a few different reasons I could be libertarian: 1> I believe that I will be better off if the scope of the state's activity is minimized. 2> I believe that most people will be better off if the scope of the state's activity is minimized. 3> I believe the world will be more just if the scope of the state's activity is minimized, whether or not that leads to anyone being better off. Libertarians in groups [1] & [3] need not offer a strategy for mitigating any economic phenomenon, even if that phenomenon is to the detriment of the majority. I've heard people argue the validity of belief [2], saying that the amount of value in the economy will grow faster than than it is absorbed by the "winners" who are amassing it. I'm not convinced, though.
- fivestar 10y agoWhy does everyone think this has to somehow be "mitigated?" If we had a level playing field, then winners should win, but on the next round, if they screw up and lose big, then others should get their chance to overtake them. What we have these days is socialized losses--there's nothing even remotely libertarian about that! The problems are self-correcting, but we don't let them ever correct and instead we get these massive industries who run to government for sweetheart deals and to clobber their competitors via regulation. Why can't I get decent broadband service from a company that is ethical instead of these total shitbird outfits like Comcast?