6 ms·
Google beats the competition in some markets because they have so much power in other markets. If you start a startup even in cloud photo storage, and suddenly
by kuschku 10y ago
Google beats the competition in some markets because they have so much power in other markets.
If you start a startup even in cloud photo storage, and suddenly Google Photos comes along, you’re dead. No one will fund you anymore, and you’ve basically lost.
Google has such an immense amount of network effect, and of knowledge they can gain from dominating in other markets, that if Google enters a market – unless there’s regulations or network effects that prevent this – they immediately dominate it.
- throwaway91111 10y agoMaybe that's a sign that photo storage is already commodity and such a startup shouldn't be funded.
- drucik 10y agoI'm sure that such attitude doesn't help innovation
- angryasian 10y agoWell I don't see why funding should be a consideration. Maybe they should release a better product based off of a viable business model.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zitterbewegung 10y agoWhat about imgur?
- kuschku 10y agoImgur exists based on the network effect – its pitch was "hey, there’s this huge community called reddit, we can start by providing photo services to them, and then expand, once we have a large enough community and the network effect applies". And that’s exactly what they’ve done.
- klipt 10y agoDoesn't Apple have iCloud photo storage that pretty much all iPhone owners use by default? I find it difficult to see Google as a monopoly when Apple has an even bigger market cap.
- ubernostrum 10y agoTry to start a video-sharing service. Go ahead, I'll wait. What will happen is that you will get a flood of DMCA takedown notices, and Google will get a flood of DMCA takedown notices for your site. Then Google will penalize you in search rankings for being a source of so many DMCA notices. Meanwhile, YouTube -- which generates far more takedown claims than you ever will -- is exempt from that ranking penalty because it's a Google service. The same is true of a lot of other areas; Google can and does use ranking penalties and placement priorities on the search-result pages to give preferential treatment to its non-search businesses. How will you compete with that?
- deelowe 10y agoThere are tons of video sharing services. Arguably Twitch is doing a pretty good job of taking on youtube. Do you expect a competitor to simply copy youtube and be successful? Business doesn't really work that way.
- ubernostrum 10y agoI don't mean a live-streaming service. I mean a place where you upload videos for on-demand viewing by others. You will have an uphill battle against Google ranking penalties, while YouTube gets a free pass.
- Klockan 10y agoYou can view old sessions in Twitch so they definitely get a lot of DMCA requests as well. See: https://www.twitch.tv/p/dmca-guidelines https://www.twitch.tv/p/dmca-guidelines
- 10y ago
- blfr 10y agoWhich markets do they really dominate? I can only think of search and Android.
- ticviking 10y agoOnline video, particularly for creators who want to earn based on someone else selling ads on their videos.
- ng12 10y agoSo how do you feel about Apple? When Google wins it's because they make a better product than the other guy. Apple can deliver a clearly inferior product (e.g. the last 5 years of iTunes) and still win because their customers are using iDevices. Google doesn't have that lock-in and they still do really well which makes me feel like they're not really a monopoly.
- ticviking 10y agoI think a big part of it is that Google controls one of the single most effective advertising channels to drive the growth of a competitor, and can therefore strangle them in the cradle.
- dannyr 10y agoWait Google does not allow its competitors to use Adsense?
- ticviking 10y agoFair response there. They have unilateral power to bury someone in search results though. Which can effectively require them to use adsense. I don't think this is reasonable. Buy our other product or get poor search results. There's a few really good examples on other threads here. The best example I saw involved a hypothetical YouTube competitor facing a large number of DMCA takedowns, they may be complying with the law, but the takedowns will give google an excuse to bury them in search results forever more, while they can "excuse" YouTube.
- kuschku 10y agoI consider that also unfair, just like I consider Microsofts participation in the browser market unfair. That said, I know that splitting companies until they only do one thing isn’t possible. But Google’s scale of domination is quite unique. Especially recently, as they’ve forced Android devs into using Google services more and more.
- 10y ago
- abraham 10y agoGoogle didn't enter the photo sharing/hosting market with Google Photos. It entered with Picasa Web Albums and 2006 and Photos was just a rebranding and new UI for that.
- nickik 10y agoThat's true for almost all large companies. Why would invest in some startup X if Boing announces the same product? Size gives you advantage, but its not an auto win.
- dannyr 10y agoTo add, Yahoo, Excite, Altavista were much bigger companies when Google entered the search space.
- angryasian 10y agoYou must not be paying attention to all the failures that google releases. Google dominates email, but waves and even inbox I would say aren't catching on. They are failing in mobile messaging. Even though they own a huge part of your social graph through phone and email, they still can't get social right. Google owns ITA but Google flights is not the first place you look for plane tickets. Google also owns Zagat, but foursquare and yelp still dominate. I think the argument only looks at the wins and completely ignores everything else.
- kuschku 10y ago> They are failing in mobile messaging Because there is a pre-existing market with network effects. The one thing that Google just doesn’t 'get' are network effects. Regarding Yelp!: Google has spent a lot of effort (leading even to confrontation in court) trying to kill Yelp!’s business already.
- angryasian 10y ago> pre-existing market with network effects. (a phenomenon whereby a product or service gains additional value as more people use it.) Google has network effects as well as they own Android dialer, hangouts, google messenger, and email. I don't buy this argument. They just failed. Also you'd be the first person I'd see that defends Yelp's business model, but yeah I'm not familiar with the Google vs Yelp court case.
- kuschku 10y ago> Also you'd be the first person I'd see that defends Yelp's business model, but yeah I'm not familiar with the Google vs Yelp court case. Google copied Yelp!’s ratings, showed them without any backlink in Maps and Places. Once Yelp! complained, Google told them to either suck it up, or to use robots.txt to opt-out of Google search entirely. "If you want to be in the index, you have to allow us to scrape your data and present it however we want". This is a big part of the current EU Antitrust case, btw.
- notatoad 10y agoGoogle has enough failed projects in their portfolio to prove this argument wrong. If they could make a product successful just by abusing their network effect, they'd be able to get Google+ or Hangouts off the ground. Also, Google Spaces, Android TV, Android Auto, Duo, Allo... Google Photos has crushed all the other startups in the space because it's so good, not because it's been forced on everybody by a monopoly. Their other apps that aren't good enough to take over a market don't take over a market.
- kuschku 10y agoHangouts, Duo, Allo, Auto are all things I already had accounted for. Because they have the issue of existing competitors with network effect. > Google Photos has crushed all the other startups in the space because it's so good And why is it so good? Because Google uses an advantage they gained from (partially illegally) datamining user data. Google Duo is better than Skype, Google Allo is better than Telegram. They don’t take over the market only because Skype and co have existing userbases – network effect.
- notatoad 10y ago>Google Duo is better than Skype, Google Allo is better than Telegram. Sure, if you want to pick the weakest competitor, they're better. Duo competes with facetime, not skype. Allo competes with WhatsApp, not Telegram. Yes, part of what makes Google Photos good is the integration with their other products. "network effect" is a thing. But leveraging your other products is not the same thing as being an illegal monopoly. iCloud Photos has a network effect. Facebook's photo sharing product has a much larger network effect than Google's.
- kuschku 10y ago> Duo competes with facetime, not skype. Allo competes with WhatsApp, not Telegram. Yet Allo has less users than IRC, or Signal, or Telegram. And Duo has less than Skype. The network effect is very powerful, and the network effect of social contacts is stronger than the network effect of software integration.