3 ms·
Anyone know where to get clean git builds for Windows without any extra crap like the "git for Windows" builds have? - Windows comes with bash - Microsoft hav
by nailer 10y ago
Anyone know where to get clean git builds for Windows without any extra crap like the "git for Windows" builds have?
- Windows comes with bash
- Microsoft have an excellent openssh implementation on their github
- I don't want some dude's cool $PS1 and shortcuts and icons.
I just want git.
- speps 10y agoThe GitHub page seems to have `MinGit` releases : https://github.com/git-for-windows/git/releases/latest https://github.com/git-for-windows/git/releases/latest
- nailer 10y agoMinGit-2.13.0-64-bit.zip\usr\bin still includes an entire copy of openssh and much more besides.
- tetromino_ 10y ago> Windows comes with bash That's an extremely charitable way of phrasing it. 64-bit Windows 10 in developer mode has bash as an optionally installable component. AFAIK, bash is not installed by default and it's unavailable on 32-bit or in older Windows versions. If you want to allow a wide range of users, including those with corporate- or government-IT issued machines, to run your build, you need to support older Windows versions down to at least 7. Which means that you cannot assume native bash.
- nailer 10y agoNobody is discussing assuming anything. It's simply preferable to have optional components for legacy systems than to add a second copy of bash and ssh to every machine.
- tetromino_ 10y agoIt is certainly preferable to you and others in a similar situation. It is, I suspect, somewhat less preferable to git maintainers, who would need to build and test an additional binary package using a different toolchain for every release, and deal with bug reports from confused users mixing up git-with-bash and git-without-bash.