Not sure what you mean. It's pretty much the industry standard to use entire device as the royalty basis. Further, many companies like Qualcomm, Nokia, Ericsso

Not sure what you mean. It's pretty much the industry standard to use entire device as the royalty basis. Further, many companies like Qualcomm, Nokia, Ericsson, do publish their per-device rates publicly. http://www.investorvillage.com/uploads/82827/files/LESI-Royalty-Rates.pdf http://www.investorvillage.com/uploads/82827/files/LESI-Roya... Apple in their quest to penny-pinch challenged the entire-device royalty basis theory in another ITC case involving Samsung back in 2012 and lost. As for your doubt on my point #3, Qualcomm translated KFTC's decision last year. Apple also explains quite clearly why Qualcomm stopped paying Apple "rebates." (see "Nature of Action" in Apple's complaint)