6 ms·
What it was like to be peer reviewed in the 1860s
- arcanus 10y agoI'm not a fan of returning to this form of communication. In a recent review, which was single-blind, I had a paper from a group I know well and the principle author was a heavy-weight in my field, and certainly will review proposals I write in the future. The paper had good content but it was clearly written by a graduate student of his and it really needed work. I made numerous suggestions for revision that I would have felt very hesitant to do if the reviews were fully open (e.g. if my name had been attached). I would have been inclined to simply accept this paper with minor revisions so that the PI did not have any impression I was being unreasonable. As another example, I had a recent double-open review for a conference where I had to attach my name to a review that was not able to accept the paper. I felt (and still do) that this submission was absolutely not acceptable given the standards of this proceedings. Now, this group has seen my name and associated it with a 'reject', and I am worried that should we meet in the future, this could cloud our interactions. For both, I've thought about this a great deal and I stand completely by my reviews, my criticisms, and I did try to come across as professional as possible. But I would have preferred to be anonymous, and I see no reason my name being attached would have helped the review process.
- forgottenpass 10y ago>I would have been inclined to simply accept this paper with minor revisions so that the PI did not have any impression I was being unreasonable. The impression I get is that this article is about the fact that despite your connections with the author and team, various pressures of the review process (and probably timelines) prevented you from saying to the principle author in private, "Hey buddy, your work looks promising, but your graduate student really needs an editor." I find that review of the form "this is good, but needs cleanup" is the easiest to give or to receive in the type of reviews I participate in. If you can't even attach your name to that, I'm inclined to believe there are problems with the system that anonymity alone doesn't solve.
- gosheroo 10y agoAgree it wouldn't work in the modern age of science with all the careers, bureaucracy and funding involved. But those days were the days of the amateur. And a return to amateurism may well be the best way forward in a number of intellectual pursuits.
- santaclaus 10y agoIt's not like you can't get a 95% idea of who is reviewing a paper now, at least in CS. Look up the list of technical committee members (since CS is conference centric), find the two with enough expertise in your area to be the primary or secondary reviewer, boom you have found two of your reviewers. Typically works when the papers are blind too, people have very different paper writing styles.
- arcanus 10y agoGood point. For the first paper, I bet that group would have put me in a top-5 list, and they certainly would have put my group (or someone from it) in the first place. But that slightly anonymous element helps, because typically you aren't sure who reviewed your paper.
- BeetleB 10y agoPeer review, as it is known today, only took off at a large scale with the invention of the photocopier. There's a story where Einstein withdrew a paper of his after he found out the editor had sent it for peer review without his permission. He was offended - it just wasn't the norm back then. http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/three-myths-about-scientific-peer-review/ http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/three-myths-about-scientific-...
- sndean 10y agoThat's a great article you linked to. Pretty eye-opening, to me at least. I feel a little different about peer review now. > decisions about what to publish and what to reject were usually made by journal editors, often acting largely on their own. These decisions were often made rapidly, with papers appearing days or weeks after submission, after a cursory review by the editor. Rejection rates at most journals were low, with only obviously inappropriate or unsound material being rejected Maybe this isn't possible today because of extreme specialization, but this sounds like a system with a lot of positives (relative to what we have now). ArXiv-like.
- gumby 10y agoThanks for posting that article! It's worth a standalone submission.
- nonbel 10y agoYes, when I looked into it I found there is actually zero evidence that institutionalized peer review is helpful at all. In fact, it looked like it's primary role was to impede science by enforcing whatever prevailing bias exists at the moment. For example: >"In addition to being poor at detecting gross defects and almost useless for detecting fraud it is slow, expensive, profligate of academic time, highly subjective, something of a lottery, prone to bias, and easily abused." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1420798/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1420798/
- BeetleB 10y ago>Yes, when I looked into it I found there is actually zero evidence that institutionalized peer review is helpful at all. In fact, it looked like it's primary role was to impede science by enforcing whatever prevailing bias exists at the moment. While I've experienced what you've described, I think throwing it all out is merely going to the other extreme. I think peer review should remain, but may need reform. The larger problem is the attitude of scientists today - some of the problems you yourself mentioned. Removing peer review will not fix those. And "fixing" peer review to handle those problems is merely treating a symptom. Ultimately, the larger problem is the mentality that has spread amongst academics - and the problems will remain no matter how you tweak peer review. >In addition to being poor at detecting gross defects and almost useless for detecting fraud This gets mentioned a lot, so I'll repeat what many others have said: Peer review was never meant to detect fraud, and should not be expected to. Back during the Schon scandal, people kept asking how peer review had failed the system to let him get so far before he was caught. And the answer was always the same: Peer review is not the appropriate method to catch such people. It was never meant for it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sch%C3%B6n_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sch%C3%B6n_scandal