5 ms·
How do you identify a situation like this where people might have been helped by the "price gouging" vs something like a company running a festival where they d
by lovich 10y ago
How do you identify a situation like this where people might have been helped by the "price gouging" vs something like a company running a festival where they don't allow water to be brought in and you can only buy it from approved vendors who increase the price massively? If there's going to be error one one side or the other, I'd prefer it to be on the side that doesn't incentivize company's to do things that hurt people.
- tdb7893 10y agoThere was nothing stopping other people from buying generators and going down. It's the possibility of competition that's important in my mind. I've come to the conclusion that nothing protects consumers as much as competition
- lovich 10y agoISP's have a possibility of competition but they don't. The possibility of something happening can not be the end all for legislation
- rlpb 10y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly. ISPs are in an objectively different situation from gas stations and the supply of generators over a distance in a disaster situation.
- derefr 10y agoThe thing with gas stations is, the gas has to come from somewhere. For various reasons, oil companies are in a natural-monopoly position (or rather, a natural cartel position, that uses various branding tactics to discourage the appearance of collusion—much like the deBeers cartel does for diamonds.) With so much leverage over their direct customers, the oil cartel isn't interested in allowing gas stations to eat into their profit margin. So they buy them. Thus, gas stations become another facet of the cartel.
- tdb7893 10y agoI dont think that ISPs have a realistic possibility of competition. There are lots of barriers to entry to start an ISP and the current ISPs could probably just price you out of existence in whatever market you tried to enter anyway
- Spooky23 10y agoThere absolutely is. Until the phone companies decided to get out of the business of supplying landlines, there was a competitive market for both dialup and DSL service in the US. In my area, I used to buy EarthLink cable service because they offered higher upload speeds. In the UK, many people can choose one of a dozen ISPs. That's the real reasoning behind Ajit Pai and his pals in the industry hatred of the Title II regulatory classification of internet access. They want to head off local loop unbundling (which requires companies to share local infrastructure at non-discriminatory rates) and ultimately re-create the old Bell Telephone monopoly. Companies like Verizon and Comcast are incredibly inefficient and poorly administered organizations. If meaningful competition were possible, they would be slaughtered in the marketplace.
- rlpb 10y agoI think it's quite easy to identify if in a given situation it is possible for an enterprising competitor to appear, or if there is some artificial distortion that prevents such competition from appearing such as in your example. In your example, the real problem isn't that they're charging artificially high prices for water; it's that they're not allowing water to be brought in and then surprising attendees with high prices. If you want to fix that problem, fix it there. You could either require people to be allowed to bring water in (for obvious public health reasons, for example), or require the event organisers to prominently include the price of water in any advertising that includes the event ticket price, or require them to provide free water (again for public health reasons) and include the cost of supplying that in the ticket price.