3 ms·
I don't know about the anti-trust aspect, but the situation in medicine goes far beyond "call for prices." It's often impossible, no matter what you do, to find
by mikeash 10y ago
I don't know about the anti-trust aspect, but the situation in medicine goes far beyond "call for prices." It's often impossible, no matter what you do, to find out what a procedure will cost. Billing systems are so complicated that the hospitals themselves barely understand it, and the only way they can find the cost for many things is to go ahead and do it and see how it comes out.
- ArtDev 10y agoThey provider may not even be allowed to tell you due to contracts with insurance companies. This kind of thing is outright criminal. We need transparent pricing regulation!
- prostoalex 10y agoWould be hard to enforce legislatively, as you're essentially forcing private companies to disclose the previously confidential pricing agreements between them and insurance companies. What will end up happening is the equivalent of MSRP in car sales - here's the list price, but since you're such a good guy, and we're running a promotion, you can get 5% off if you act today.
- beambot 10y agoSo instead you sign a contract to purchase a car (with no take backs!) and only then do you get told the must-pay MSRP? That's about how medical pricing works today.
- prostoalex 10y agoSome states do require chargemaster transparency, e.g. https://www.oshpd.ca.gov/chargemaster/ https://www.oshpd.ca.gov/chargemaster/
- mikeash 10y agoWhy would that be hard? I thought law takes precedence over contracts. Even having the equivalent of car MSRPs would be a huge improvement. As it stands today, you often cannot get any price for a procedure beforehand, not even a "forget about insurance, I'm just going to pull out a wad of benjamins and start counting until you tell me it's enough" price. Plus, car prices don't vary that much from MSRP. I can look up a car's MSRP and know that this is approximately what I'll pay. If I get a really good deal I might get away with paying 10-20% less. If the car is in extremely high demand, I might have to pay 10-20% more. But I can get a pretty decent idea. Medical pricing often varies by a factor of ten depending on whether you have insurance, and which provider it is.
- prostoalex 10y agoI posted a link below, but some states already mandate chargemaster transparency. It's close to useless, as one quickly discovers that (a) pretty much any procedure costs a trillion dollars, but discounts apply and (b) the consumer's view of "procedure" and hospital system's view of "services provided" differ radically, as every gauze used up, every vital measurement, and every painkiller is a billing item in hospital's book (cost of goods and labor), but are integral part of the "procedure" the way the consumer sees it.
- mikeash 10y agoThat some current laws are useless doesn't mean better laws couldn't be made. Mandate a final, guaranteed, all-inclusive price, or require disclosing every single discount made available to anybody, or even require charging the same price to everybody. I think the real problem is that Americans mostly aren't willing to have their government going around telling businesses to cut out their shit or else.
- prostoalex 10y agoI don't know if there are simple one-step solutions. > Mandate a final, guaranteed, all-inclusive price How would that work for something like birth? Depending on the amount of time spent in labor and a host of potential complications (some requiring presence of additional doctors like anesthesiologists or surgeons to perform a C-section) the costs will vary greatly. > require disclosing every single discount made available to anybody, or even require charging the same price to everybody That could work, as long as discounts don't evolve into kickbacks or rebates, but then why should an insurance company that signed up 10 customers receive the same discount as an insurance company that sent 100,000 people? The latter loses their leverage, which typically sends the prices up, not down.