3 ms·
It's a little relevant, they aren't capturing any more than the 17% of the premiums (and they aren't capturing all of it as profit, they do provide some necessa
by maxerickson 10y ago
It's a little relevant, they aren't capturing any more than the 17% of the premiums (and they aren't capturing all of it as profit, they do provide some necessary administration).
- kurthr 10y agoYes, but if they are capturing 4% as profit on 17% of the premium, they have a perverse incentive to keep costs high, which is directly opposed to their customer's interests.
- maxerickson 10y agoSure. I was just pointing out that we have pretty clear information about the amount of money that ends up inside the insurance company and how much gets passed on to providers. In a functioning market they would face competition for customers and try to lower premiums (and so try to lower costs). In our system they seem to look at provider prices in a region and decide if they can profit there or not (and in the case of non profits, if they can operate without losing money).
- Decathect 10y agoOne of the provisions of Obamacare was a cap on the administrative costs of insurance companies at 20% of premiums, with any excess returned to the purchaser as a rebate. The first year it was in effect more than a billion dollars was returned. The deadweight cost of the private insurance industry over the years is pretty staggering. In contrast, the Medicare program spends less than 2% of its budget on administrative costs.