8 ms·
Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic
- dazzawazza 16y agoTwo men kissing is an act of love not pornography. Having said that, Apple has a right to (IMHO) censor these derivative works, it's their platform, take it or leave it. If they wanted to censor the original text I would have a problem with that as it would, in some ways, be an attempt to rewrite history through the prism of corporate sensitivities. It would be better for them to not publish the text.
- GiraffeNecktie 16y agoNo it is NOT their platform! If I buy it, it belongs to ME. They do, however, own the store and it just so happens that they've rigged the phone to prevent customers from obtaining software anywhere else. That's why my next phone will be anything but Apple.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoNo it is NOT their platform! If I buy it, it belongs to ME. Umm, not really. They do, however, own the store and it just so happens that they've rigged the phone to prevent customers from obtaining software anywhere else. See? That's what "owning the platform" means.
- tjmaxal 16y agoTwo NAKED men kissing The point here is that it is nudity.
- barrkel 16y agoNudity isn't porn either, nor does all porn involve nudity, but this point seems lost on many.
- sambeau 16y agoMen stoking each other's penises is porn, however.
- GiraffeNecktie 16y agoUh. No. It's called sex.
- sambeau 16y agoPictures of men stoking each other's penises is porn, however.
- GiraffeNecktie 16y agoUh. No. Or at least not any more so than than a picture of a woman stroking a man's penis (or a man touching a woman for that matter) If it's a drawn or painted image (as it was in this case) it's probably art. If it's a written description it's probably literature. If it's on porntube, it's porn.
- sambeau 16y agoPictures of men or women stroking each other's genitals is porn, however.
- sambeau 16y agoThere was pornography before there was the internet, young fellow. Once there were special 'cinemas' and printed pictures in 'magazines'. And, before the advent of photography there were etchings. Most of it was purely for titillation rather than artistic pleasure. ---key-------- cinema = youtube-in-a-building photography = jpegs-on-paper magazines = non-electric-ipad hope that helps
- sambeau 16y agoDid you even look at the pictures in the article? It shows two naked men having sex in various ways - one kneeling while removing the other's underwear, in another scene they are sitting on a chair stroking each others penises. I have nothing against men having sex or pictures of men having sex. However, I cannot think of many main-stream shops that would stock such pictures - even most book shops would consider this pornographic. I would rather my children didn't have to confront this yet, too. At least let them wait until they are sexual. It is completely reasonable for Apple to reject this from THEIR shop.
- jrockway 16y agoI would rather my children didn't have to confront this yet, too. Won't someone please think of the adults? You have to be over 17 to buy the app anyway, and parental controls let you explicitly block this sort of app. Plus, if your kids want to see naked men having sex, well... let me tell you about this little thing called the Internet. It's directly accessible in the "safari" app, and it contains porn. Oh so much porn. Anyway, I am tired of "for the children". It's not for the children, it's for the prudes.
- sambeau 16y agoI do see you your point. And I don't disagree. I also don't think that this graphic novel is offensive - it looks interesting, well written and well drawn. It is certainly art, not porn. However I can't see how Apple can curate for quality without also curating for taste. To run a store like this no doubt means employing hundreds of young testers and a bunch of draconian policies. To get them to understand the subtlety between art and porn (or good porn and bad porn) is no doubt asking too much. To do it in a way that will not enrage prudes, governments, religious types, anyone who wants to bash Apple for any other reason etc is something else entirely. To set up a good 18+ store in this way will be nigh-on impossible without either dropping all rules (and therefore all quality) or risking the wrath of the moral majority. Having the occasional piece of genuine art rejected to walk this fine line is no doubt seen as a reasonable compromise. I hope that Apple can fix this - but I'm not sure they will be able.
- lsb 16y agoTo be fair to Apple, they've had same-sex couples' benefits the same as different-sex couples' since the 1970s (back when being a 'mo was a mental illness, not cool and cowboyesque like Jake Gyllenhaal). It's a tricky business, being in the content censorship business, because the shield of common carrier status is very useful.
- jfager 16y agoSo because they have progressive and decent policies for the ~20k or so who work for them, we should be willing to excuse the repressive and reactionary policies they have for the millions of developers and customers who use their products? I don't think that's being 'fair'.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- neonfunk 16y agoAnd they publicly donated $100k to fight against Prop 8.
- davidedicillo 16y agoThis is the kind of article I can't stand. So, one is an app directly reviewed by Apple, the other has been downloaded from an another app. I'm sure if that was brought to Apple's attention they would send an email to the app owner in order to remove that comic book or censor it. I understand that Apple might not be fair or whatever, but some of the complains are really ridiculous.
- ryanhuff 16y agoConsidering the number of young kids that now carry iPod Touches, and Apple's aspirations of overtaking the Nintendo DS as a kids gaming device, I think this is part of Apple trying to be careful about what it exposes children to. They don't want their products to carry a stigma with parents.
- tjmaxal 16y agoThe idea that Apple is worried about what it exposes kids to is apparent in the "over 17" pop up. The idea that Apple is worried about exposing kids to gay sex is just laughable.
- ryanhuff 16y agoReally? Isn't it clear that Apple is positioning the ipod/iphone as the non-porn device? See Steve Job's multiple mentions of Android as the porn device. http://techcrunch.com/2010/04/19/steve-jobs-android-porn/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/04/19/steve-jobs-android-porn/ http://www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2010/04/steve-jobs-porn/ http://www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2010/04/steve-jobs-porn/ http://www.electricpig.co.uk/2010/04/20/steve-jobs-email-repeats-android-porn-claim/ http://www.electricpig.co.uk/2010/04/20/steve-jobs-email-rep... Look, this is business. Apple isn't out to rid the world of adult material. But it is worried how parents might view their products. The kid market is significant, but if parents are worried that they're handing over a device that has a negative stigma, they'll buy a DS or something else.
- drivebyacct 16y agoThis just in, kissing = gay sex. Also, tjmaxal is defending apple and homophobia up and down this thread.
- ryanhuff 16y agoDespite your personal views of whether this material is suitable for general consumption, wouldn't you agree that many parents would have concerns with their kids having access to the material presented in this comic?
- cageface 16y agoThis is exactly why I hope, in the long term, that HTML5/6/whatever marginalizes apps. Technical and editorial control over what we read and write is just too much power to invest in any single company, however well-intentioned.
- CamperBob 16y agoThen they'll just start blocking sites in Safari.
- cabalamat 16y agoMaybe Apple should be required to trade under the name "We Hate Our Customers' Freedom And Are Actively Working To Destroy It".
- almost 16y agoBefore we all get into a rage, is there any real evidence that they objected to semi-nude homosexual kissing and not just to semi-nude kissing in general? That would still be kind of silly but it loses some of the rage-inducing homophobia...
- jpablo 16y agoGo to page two of the article, there's another comic that was accepted that has implicit sex and a nipple showing. "On a Picasa page, he posted some full pages from the original book, as well as one page from another comic book (from Kick-Ass) of a heterosexual couple. Apple apparently didn't have a problem with that image. Kick-Ass can be bought, uncensored, on iTunes through the iVerse comic reader." http://www.thebigmoney.com/blogs/app-economy/2010/06/11/it-gets-worse-apple-censored-oscar-wilde-comic-featuring-two-men-kissin?page=0,1&obref=obinsite http://www.thebigmoney.com/blogs/app-economy/2010/06/11/it-g...
- starkfist 16y agoApple doesn't censor comics that are purchased through iVerse. They censor the content being sold directly through the iTunes app store.
- jfager 16y agoI don't understand why this distinction is important. You have to click past the same "Are you 17?" scare warning to download both apps that can access external content and apps that are adult-oriented by themselves, and both can be limited with parental controls. The former can access far more pornographic material than this, and yet Apple is going out of its way to black this material out? That makes zero sense.
- starkfist 16y agoI don't know either, that's just the way it is.
- 16y ago
- WiseWeasel 16y agoThis censorship is unacceptable. Either sell the book/comic/whatever or don't, but don't insult us by selling us versions with a bunch of black censor blocks covering up half the page. I'd want my money back after realizing the book I bought was gutted by the distributor. Imagine how offensive it would be if you bought a shrink-wrapped book from a bookstore with controversial passages cut out from the pages.
- dcurtis 16y agoWalmart does this all the time. If you buy a CD that should have explicit lyrics at Walmart, they're bleeped out. Walmart refuses to sell music otherwise.
- iamdave 16y agoThat's an unfortunate side effect of shopping at WalMart.
- CamperBob 16y agoIt's a hell of a lot more than an 'unfortunate side effect.' When 30-40% of your product's sales go through WalMart, you will toe their party line when you write and edit the content you're selling. Any sufficiently dominant corporation is indistinguishable from a government. Eventually people are going to understand that.
- WiseWeasel 16y agoThe differences are that, 1) the music distributors supplying Walmart were already distributing "clean" versions for radio play, so Walmart simply chose those versions over the explicit ones, and 2) you can buy CDs from any other retailer than Walmart and get the explicit versions if you want. You can only get iPhone software from the App Store.
- dieterrams 16y agoBefore people work themselves into self-righteous fury (too late) about how authoritarian Apple is censoring homosexuality and promoting a culture of homophobia, you need to understand that this is about no-nudity, a policy the article's writer knows full well about already, seeing as how he wrote a previous article about it and linked to it. As davidedicillo pointed out, he attempts to work this into an anti-gay angle by pointing out how a comic book not directly reviewed by Apple (it is downloadable through a comic store app) containing more explicit heterosex was not similarly censored, which is about as airtight an analysis as you might expect from Fox News. He literally has nothing else to base his anti-homosexual conclusions on. I do think Apple is fundamentally misguided in its attempts to regulate content, and they're only going to dig themselves into a deeper hole by doing anything beyond adopting ratings and age blockers. But unfortunately this article is a yet another example of anti-Apple hysteria fueled sensationalism.
- aphyr 16y agoGiven that there is no frontal nudity in any of the panels shown, and many of the censored scenes have no nudity whatsoever, could you further explain your case that this censorship is "about no-nudity"? You can see more explicit nudity than this in most daily papers, or heck, walking down the street during a pride parade.
- axod 16y agoIt's not just about nudity, it's about social acceptability. Apple seem to be on some content policing crusade which is ill judged IMHO, but it's fairly obvious why this is censored.
- dieterrams 16y agoI'm not defending this policy or suggesting that it makes any sense given how easy it is to find nudity (or sexual acts, etc.) elsewhere. It doesn't. But the writer has simply failed to present any compelling evidence that this censorship was about homosexuality. Given that there's an established policy against nudity and not homosexuality, it makes more sense to consider the former as the determinative criteria, doesn't it? Apps get rejected merely for showing women in bathing suits. There is one panel in the comic which does not contain any explicit or implied nudity that's censored, but which is still obviously sexual. I've no idea if blacking this panel out was Apple's idea and is consistent with other policies, or if the creators just decided to play it safe. And Apple's content regulation policies have never been consistently enforced, subject to individual reviewers' interpretations of what's kosher. (A particularly good reason why they should drop this process.) Apple deserves much legitimate criticism over content regulation, but this article isn't an example of that.
- mbateman 16y agoThis headline is really misleading. It's not just a gay kiss, it's gay nude fondling of genitals. Seems pretty reasonable to think that the homosexual element is incidental to the pornographic element in Apple's decision.
- pavlov 16y agoI demand that Apple immediately censor all apps that give access to art from the world's greatest museums. As it stands, innocent children can be exposed to trash such as this gay-kissing piece in the Louvre: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Kiss_Briseis_Painter_Louvre_G278_full.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Kiss_Briseis_Painter_Louvr...
- ErrantX 16y agoApplying the same (Apple) rules to that image as has been to these panels I don't think anything would be censored.
- ErrantX 16y agoTroll. The kiss is not censored. The message is that the sight of two men kissing is a bad thing, and that homophobia is a good thing. For allowing Apple to send that message, Steve Jobs should be ashamed of himself. Sorry, but I entirely despise soapbox-authors like this.
- nnutter 16y agoImages suggesting oral sex, hand jobs, and anal sex... I would ban it too.
- jrockway 16y agoI think people figured all this stuff out without the aid of a comic on the app store.
- jkincaid 16y agoApple has reversed the block and the developers are being invited to resubmit the app in its original form: http://techcrunch.com/2010/06/14/apple-reverses-block-of-oscar-wilde-graphic-novels-gay-kissing/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/06/14/apple-reverses-block-of-osc... For what it's worth, I specifically asked them if it was the kissing itself or the imagery of mens' buttocks that Apple objected to. Didn't get an answer to that question.