5 ms·
> Socialism in healthcare brings rationing, waiting lists, supply shortages This isn't always true. The UK is single-payer, and their wait times are lower than
by smt88 10y ago
> Socialism in healthcare brings rationing, waiting lists, supply shortages
This isn't always true. The UK is single-payer, and their wait times are lower than in the US[1].
Even if that were true, those things are acceptable on average as long as outcomes improve. Australia, the UK, and France (all single-payer) have longer life expectancy[2] than the US.
In fact, the UK is doing better than the US in nearly every health-related metric[3]
> and all the kinds of things you don't want when dealing with people's lives.
So "better care for people who can pay more" is a better system? That's what we want when dealing with people's lives?
If anything should be socialized, it's health care. No one should die because they weren't born with the opportunity to work a high-paying job or accumulate wealth.
1. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/aug/25/gp-appointment-waiting-times-in-us-worse-than-nhs https://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/aug/25/gp-appointme...
2. https://data.oecd.org/healthstat/life-expectancy-at-birth.htm https://data.oecd.org/healthstat/life-expectancy-at-birth.ht...
3. http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2014/jun/mirror-mirror http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/20...
- DarkKomunalec 10y ago"So "better care for people who can pay more" is a better system?" Don't phrase this as an alternative - those able to pay more can still buy themselves better care, they're being denied nothing except to watch the poor die of illness: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_medicine_in_the_UK https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_medicine_in_the_UK
- smt88 10y agoYou're right. A better way to phrase it is this: "Health-care quality in proportion to wealth" -- the poor get worse care because they can't afford to pay for gold-standard care.
- zip1234 10y agoThis is OK as long as there is a sufficiently high floor on the quality of service that the poor receive. Someone has to pay for the advanced treatments, drugs, machinery, and training.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> This is OK as long as there is a sufficiently high floor on the quality of service that the poor receive. Someone has to pay for the advanced treatments, drugs, machinery, and training. Yes, and that "somebody" is the US. Drug prices are high in the US because the US is responsible for funding the the majority of medical and pharmaceutical research for the entire world. Countries like the UK benefit from the research that is being paid by the US, while not actually having to find the R&D that goes into it.
- jessaustin 10y agoIn a time when it is seriously proposed by high-ranking elected officials that e.g. South Korea pay for its own military defense, I think we can consider UK paying for its own drug research.
- smt88 10y ago> consider UK paying for its own drug research Because the UK is single-payer, they have enormous negotiating power -- and they use it[1]. They force drug companies to give them low prices, which means the US indirectly pays some of the costs of the research. However, drugs can be very profitable, so you could just as easily say that all the countries share the cost of the research, and the US subsidizes the profits of the private companies. 1. https://qz.com/509344/the-way-to-fix-outrageous-drug-pricing-in-the-us-is-simply-to-do-what-all-other-rich-countries-do/ https://qz.com/509344/the-way-to-fix-outrageous-drug-pricing...
- chimeracoder 10y ago> However, drugs can be very profitable, so you could just as easily say that all the countries share the cost of the research, and the US subsidizes the profits of the private companies. Sure, though only if you assume that the companies would pursue the same research and achieve the same results without a profit incentive. Except, we have pretty clear empirical evidence that that isn't the case. The overwhelming majority of both medical research spending and clinical medical discoveries come out of organizations that pursue a profit motive. That's true globally - it's true in the US, in Europe, and in China and India. And even then, you can't say that companies "share the cost of research equally", because there is literally no objective metric under which European countries pay an amount of research proportional to how much they consume. Even European pharmaceutical companies obtain the bulk of their research funds from the US market.
- conanbatt 10y agoThat is true for literally anything, from food, education, jobs, lifestyle, etc. Why would just health-care be so different to all those other necessities?
- smt88 10y agoEducation, jobs, and lifestyle aren't necessities. That's how health care is different. And I do believe people need to have food. Every developed country agrees, which is why there are welfare and food programs. They're inadequate and often leave people behind, but the goal is that no one dies just from being poor.
- conanbatt 10y ago> Education, jobs, and lifestyle aren't necessities. That's how health care is different. I disagree. Lifespan, quality of life and health all depend on all those. > And I do believe people need to have food. Every developed country agrees, which is why there are welfare and food programs. They're inadequate and often leave people behind, but the goal is that no one dies just from being poor. Sure, but not any kind of food at any price. The equivalent would be basic medical care, not advanced cancer treatment solutions. I personally resist the idea that any human life is of infinite value, since it conflicts with the basic reality that economically, we trade some lives for others. Reducing cost is fruitful for everyone but the traders and professionals: supporting any cost as a right is fruitful for the traders and professionals and the recipients at the cost of the givers. And in reality, the givers tend to be the poor more frequently than the rich.
- zip1234 10y agoWhat do you mean wait times are lower? Waiting once you get to the clinic or the multiple months you need to get the appointment for the specialist?
- smt88 10y agoI provided a source that answers your question.
- conanbatt 10y ago> If anything should be socialized, it's health care. No one should die because they weren't born with the opportunity to work a high-paying job or accumulate wealth. I understand the sentiment but that is simply not true. If someone gets cancer and requires the lifetime work of 10 people to survive, then guaranteeing that treatment for everyone would be have very negative results. Life does have a value and a cost, and its not worth spending great amounts of achieve little results. 1000,000U$S might save the lives of a lot of people, but 1000,000U$S cancer treatment might just prolong the life of a single one.
- smt88 10y ago> If someone gets cancer and requires the lifetime work of 10 people to survive, then guaranteeing that treatment for everyone would be have very negative results 1) Living people are taxpayers and consumers. Dead people are not. 2) This is the whole point of insurance. Very few people will be very expensive and most people will be relatively inexpensive. With preventative care and the advancement of research, fewer people should be expensive over time. Regardless, the US, as a society, has more than enough money. There's no reason for someone to buy his second $50M yacht while someone else dies of the flu because they couldn't afford the $25 vaccine. 3) You can make these hyper-rationalist arguments, but the vast majority of people are willing to pay a lot of money to live in a society that doesn't just let them die of something curable. I genuinely believe that people who are uninterested in the social contract of the US or other developed nations should be allowed to "opt out" of society: the citizens of the nation will pay for transport to any border of the country, and then citizenship is permanently lost.
- conanbatt 10y ago> 1) Living people are taxpayers and consumers. Dead people are not. In the example above, you get maybe 5 years + taxpayer+consumer - 10 lifetimes, which is a deficit both for taxpayers and consumers. > This is the whole point of insurance. Very few people will be very expensive and most people will be relatively inexpensive. With preventative care and the advancement of research, fewer people should be expensive over time. Basically everyone needs some sort of medical care. True, the most expensive cases are rare and they befit insurance, but medical costs are normally not about insurance. Checkups, dentists, basic clinical appointments, etc are not great cases for insurance. That is, hard diseases can be convered by life insurance, without the need for socialized healthcare for the rest. > Regardless, the US, as a society, has more than enough money. There's no reason for someone to buy his second $50M yacht while someone else dies of the flu because they couldn't afford the $25 vaccine. This is a typical rabbit hole argument where it turns out nobody wants to donate their salary until they reach the lowest percentile of income to make it fair. Because who are you to spend your money on a vegan deluxe burger when people are dying of malnutrition! Blaming rich people for hardships is akin to blaming immigrants for it, on the other side of the political spectrum. They guy with the 50 million dollars did not make the rest poor, in fact its possibly the exact opposite. There is a lot of ideology in the mere presentation of that argument, i fear this can take a bad turn :). > You can make these hyper-rationalist arguments, but the vast majority of people are willing to pay a lot of money to live in a society that doesn't just let them die of something curable I somehow doubt thats really true, otherwise it wouldnt be a debate at all...