6 ms·
The middleman role of insurance companies in American healthcare seems completely useless. They're not serving patients, doctors nor the national economy by sip
by pavlov 10y ago
The middleman role of insurance companies in American healthcare seems completely useless. They're not serving patients, doctors nor the national economy by siphoning off enormous profits from the 17% of GDP that gets spent on healthcare.
Getting rid of them would be extremely hard, of course, given how well entrenched they are thanks to lobbying and regulatory capture.
Insurance companies are a massive-scale version of the car dealerships that have managed to keep Tesla out of many US states by taking advantage of local legislation -- nobody would want to deal with a car salesman or an insurance company given the choice.
- dredmorbius 10y agoAs with most politically-powerful entities: first shrink, then drown. That, ultimately is how the tobacco industry was (mostly) quashed.
- devoply 10y agoYou have to be determined, not just determined, but Ralph Nader determined. If you are Ralph Nader determined, then in America there is no company or lobby that can stop you. That's in fact one of the best things about America, out of everything else. That activism can't be stopped. That free speech is for the most part respected. And if you are determined to get some truth heard, you will eventually succeed if you try hard enough.
- smt88 10y ago> seems completely useless Some people (not me) would argue that their existence and competition create better choices for consumers. For example, in theory, a single-payer system could have a single price (via taxes) and a single level of coverage. By contrast, private insurance companies are able to offer many different products depending on someone's tolerance for risk. I don't think the private, market-driven system for health care is better in that regard, but some people do.
- Broken_Hippo 10y ago1. You can have single payer with the option for private insurance. Many countries do that. From what I can gather, here (Norway) one can get quicker service with the private doctors. The national health plan still pays the private doctors the national rate, and you pay the difference.
- smt88 10y agoIronically, this happens in the US despite the private insurance system. It's the worst of both worlds. If you want to be seen quickly and you're not literally dying, you have to go to an urgent care clinic and pay a much higher fee. And even that is only available for very minor, primary-care issues. I recently took my girlfriend to the emergency room for a very serious illness, and we ended up being there for 12 hours. About 1 hour of that time involved actual treatment or seeing a doctor -- the other 11 hours were just waiting. The bill was $20,000.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThat really isn't the same. Urgent care is useless if you do not have the money to pay for it when you need it, even though insurers provide monetary incentives to go there (my insurance plans generally had a copay of $50-$75 for urgent care, but $100-$150 for the ER). You can still wait hours at these places, just like at the ER. And honestly, in such cases the care is likely similar. You also have absolutely no coverage if you don't have private insurance or are poor enough/old enough for the government-run systems. This system is more akin to visiting a doctor that charges more than the insurance's "customary charges" and expects you to pay the difference. You like the doctor, though, so you happily pay while the insurance still pays the portion they find to be a fair price. It is more akin to finding out the specialists in your networks have a 6 month waiting list, but one outside the network only has a 3 month waiting list. The insurance pays a lower amount and you choose to pay the rest out of pocket for a shorter waiting time. The same thing for surgeries that aren't absolute emergencies (I do hear horror stories, but I heard horror stories in the states as well). Above all, you are unlikely to wind up with such a bill afterwards.
- vidarh 10y ago
- humanrebar 10y agoI think most people are fine getting rid of middlemen, but there is a deep divide over who should actually be paying the bills. Personally, I think health insurance should be, you know, insurance. For catastrophic things you wouldn't wish on yourself and cannot save for. And there's a definite role for government to make sure that market is solvent and available to everyone. For day-to-day healthcare, that should just be included in "cost of living" calculations. General-purpose welfare programs (or ideally a minimum income) would guarantee that people could afford checkups, birth control, etc. Getting employers out of the business of all of the above is paramount and what businesses should be lobbying for. I believe the slow recovery from the recession has been affected by unintended (though not unpredicted) consequences of the ACA's failure to address this issue. The Republicans likewise seem happy to punt on the issue. It's this sort of thinking that is making the American electorate disgruntled with politicians and each other.
- mgkimsal 10y ago> Getting employers out of the business of all of the above is paramount and what businesses should be lobbying for. Amen. I never quite understood what benefit (pardon the pun) it served, although I've got some idea of the origins of employer-provided health insurance. The cynical part of me believes it's definitely a way for larger companies to hold more control over their employees, and they may lobby for this because it provides an extra advantage over smaller competitors. I've known plenty of really sharp/talented folks whose talents may better serve the economy by taking those skills to other companies (sometimes in other parts of the country). "But I'll lose my health insurance" is almost always a primary reason why people've stayed in their job (however crappy it might be otherwise re: pay, commute, colleagues, boss, industry, etc). This seems like it's been a real drag on labor mobility for some time now. I would have thought 'conservatives' would be all over a 'free market' where people make their own choices with their own money. They'll happily deride a "nanny-state" as fostering people who just want the govt to provide them with everything, but ... expecting people to need employers to provide access to basic services? Apparently there's no problem there whatsoever, and it doesn't even seem contradictory to many I talk to.
- 10y ago
- panzer_wyrm 10y agoThis is one of those citation needed moments. IIRC insurance companies paid 90% of their income as "medical loss ratio". Even if you made them NPO - the cost will drop some percent. US needs healthcare costs to drop times.
- WalterBright 10y agoThe Atlantic pointed out a few years ago that removing all the profit from health insurance companies would not make a significant dent in health care costs. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/09/how-american-health-care-killed-my-father/307617/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/09/how-ame...
- mgkimsal 10y agoThat was pre-ACA. Given the min 80% payout rule, it would seem the only way to increase profits is to increase the costs of everything, no?
- deegles 10y agoHence the laws prohibiting price negotiation!
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Hence the laws prohibiting price negotiation! Insurers are not prohibited from negotiating prices. Quite the opposite.
- icantdrive55 10y agoCombine it with allowing patients to buy their medicine from any country, tame the AMA, tame the FDA, allow non-profit insurance companies the freedom to sell insurance across state lines, sell more medications OTC, make becoming a General Practitioner easier (just the Family doctor, not specialists.), and then maybe tort reform for all health professionals? Oh, yea--allow certain patients the authority to refill their own prescriptions if they are on a maintenance drug (yes they would have to have a blood test,etc., but they days of doctors holding patients hostage would be over? I'm sure the average Doctor could add a lot to the list. Maybe they don't want much to change, with the exception of making their club smaller, or just the changes that increase their wealth? Yea--my view of them has changed. I don't look at them as The Golden Boys anymore. I just look at most of them as greedy little business entities. Maybe they always were?
- dinglebert1234 10y agoIf we cut out all regulation on health insurance, they'll compete themselves into utility.
- Shivetya 10y agoWell if we stop calling products insurance that are not insurance it might be a step in the right direction. I think catastrophic medical insurance should exist and that earns the name "insurance". What most people perceive as insurance is really a service plan. You pay a fee to have services selected on the plan to be available when you want them and you get provided with a list of those who can deliver. Still the real bogeyman is just like income taxes most people don't see the cost first hand or don't associate it with their income. They see the final check value and somehow disconnect the costs. The step is getting name insurance off of products that are not insurance
- maxerickson 10y agoThe costs of the services in the bronze ACA plans isn't that high. They basically are catastrophic plans. The premiums and deductibles are expensive because medical care is expensive and a real medical catastrophe can have obscene costs. Cheaper coverage can pretty much only be obtained by excluding people or limiting the benefit.
- zanny 10y agoWhich goes against all the evidence - every other first world country with universal coverage that also provides all the same medical services the US does, while paying a third as much per person. The US pays more for a lot of reasons. It isn't a one trick pony: * Americans are much, much more unhealthy than Europeans on average. Way more obesity, way more smoking and drinking for addiction rather than socialiation. * The insurance apparatus imposes a ~20% overhead outright on expenses, and puts further money on top by moving costs out of the consumers hands. They control what doctors you see and what procedures and drugs you get, and often do so in ways that are locally beneficial to the insurer but are more inefficient than a universal system. * Hospitals and doctors, by being decoupled from patient expenses by the insurers, run rampant on spending and salary and hospital administration gets as crooked as insurance bureaucracy. Your healthcare dollar quickly ends up going 60% to bureaucrats and institutionalized middle-men expenses and only 40% to actual care. Solving #1 is something that has to be done over time, and the only way to do that is to have a healthcare system, any system, that stops disincentivizing people from seeing doctors except for during crisis. The ACA did very little to fix this (it basically only mandated that some routine preventative care came at no cost to patients) and until you can get the general unhealthiness of Americans under control you can't get costs under control regardless of healthcare system. The other two, though? Single payer solves them either immediately or with the market pressure of the entire US populations healthcare needs. Every other developed country that adopted single payer was able to use its influence to get hospitals and private insurance in line. That is why the UK now has one of the best systems in the world.
- heisenbit 10y agoThis may be a misconception. In other countries there are also insurance companies at work making good money managing premiums and payments. And yes, they are not liked there ether particularly when they find excuses not to pay. The US problems however run deeper. One of the biggest US health insurer is UnitedHealth Group. In their last financial quarter report they published: Revenues $48.7 billion Earnings From Operations $3.4 billion Net Margin 4.5% These type of good and enviable stable profits are not enough to explain the inefficiencies in the US. Insurance may be lobbying but that is dwarfed e.g. by the marketing expenditure of the pharmaceutical industry (same level as their R&D). Yes health insurance is living well on the inefficiencies and their (in part unnecessary) middle man role but there are way bigger money leaks.
- amalag 10y agoThat is showing only official profits. There is so much else being siphoned off within the insurance companies as inefficiencies. I agree there are efficiencies external to the insurance companies though, but I am not sure how incentivized these companies are to minimize costs.
- maxerickson 10y agoThey spend 83% of premiums on medical care. (they list both numbers on page 9 of http://www.unitedhealthgroup.com/~/media/CEBA762A544B44D19F190F571210532A.ashx http://www.unitedhealthgroup.com/~/media/CEBA762A544B44D19F1... ) Some of the 17% represents necessary administrative costs. Who knows how much.
- antisthenes 10y agoIt's irrelevant how much they spend on premiums, because they are the ones who set prices of procedures and drugs. There is no one to step in and introduce hard price controls, because it doesn't benefit anyone on the gravy train, just the consumer. Imagine if there existed a company whose only job was to buy oil from OPEC and deliver it somewhere else. They could say "we spend 99% of our revenue on oil! look at how efficient we are!", ignoring the fact that OPEC is a cartel that sets prices, so not only can they be vastly overpaying, but the amount of oil purchased can be wildly inadequate to cover the needs.
- rl3 10y ago>The middleman role of insurance companies in American healthcare seems completely useless. They're not serving patients, doctors ... I think you're being too generous here. Insurance providers are not only useless, but of negative value to patients and physicians alike. They add yet another bureaucratic layer atop the healthcare system as a whole, and inundate physicians with red tape that interferes with care. In my experience, insurance companies will actively go out of their way to fuck over patients on technicalities—even in life threatening situations—just to try and save a dime. The sheer indifference to humanity can be breathtaking at times.
- refurb 10y agoInsurance companies are just cost control entities. Even in a single payer system that function has to exist. Of course you can argue that having just one system is far more efficient than having hundreds of different ones as exists in the US today. However, someone still has to say "no" to certain care. I know when i was in Canada that role was taken by the gov't.
- rl3 10y agoCost control should not involve denying care to seriously ill people on a routine basis.
- refurb 10y agoTell that to the NHS.[1] [1]http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-3222588/Thousands-cancer-patients-denied-life-extending-drugs-NHS-funding-cuts.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-3222588/Thousands-...
- pgrote 10y ago"Getting rid of them would be extremely hard, of course, given how well entrenched they are thanks to lobbying and regulatory capture." I always go back to when the Affordable Care Act was passed. At the time the amount of money being spent and the future money promised was enough for the federal government to buy every public health insurance company on the open market. If that decision had been made the argument for going to single payer, universal healthcare would have been over. Yes, it would have been a rough transition, but at the time elapsed between now and then would have moved the USA into the rest of the world when it comes to healthcare.
- qeternity 10y agoThat just covers the market cap of the company. You still have to pay for the healthcare. So that analogy isn't really valid.
- brownbat 10y ago> The middleman role of insurance companies in American healthcare seems completely useless. It depends on where you are. There are areas of the country where insurance companies are fighting a cost war on behalf of patients against increasingly conglomerated and monopolistic hospitals. This American Life had a great episode on this a while back. I went in thinking, "This problem's simple, it's all the fault of x." (For a few values of x.) I left the episode thinking, "Wow, who knew health care could be so complicated?" I have moved towards a Marxist philosophy on healthcare. Well, Groucho Marxist: I no longer trust any solutions to healthcare that non-experts like me could understand. https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/391/More-Is-Less https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/391/...
- killjoywashere 10y agoWithout clicking the link: is the hospital conglomerate HCA?
- pavlov 10y agoThere are areas of the country where insurance companies are fighting a cost war on behalf of patients against increasingly conglomerated and monopolistic hospitals. This seems like an unnecessary war. Are patients really being helped by a structure where multiple corporate entities -- the hospital and the insurance companies -- are battling each other to extract the maximum value from both the patient and the government actor paying for some part of the care? If the hospital were not a regular for-profit corporation, they wouldn't turn into a monopolistic conglomerate... But of course it's practically impossible to undo these corporate structures and replace them with something with a whiff of socialism. It might even mean a pay cut for doctors, and then you'd have to restructure their education costs too... It's a very deep problem.
- brownbat 10y ago> This seems like an unnecessary war. Especially insofar as it's a war, yes. In general, I like two strongly motivated and opposing advisors on my healthcare decisions, one advocating for the best possible care, and one team of actuaries arguing about what's least likely to be a waste of money.[0] Anyway, that's just the ideal case where insurance and hospitals oppose each other, possibly motivated by financial incentives, and I benefit. Admittedly, things usually aren't ideal. You might be able to restructure things where hospital incentives are tied to outcomes. Making them responsible for hospital-acquired infections was a step towards that. But it's hard to pin them to long term outcomes, and weight that towards cost of procedures, which is apparently what we really care about judging by the outcomes / cost headlines. You could assign people to a specific hospital for long periods of time to track long term health outcomes, make them responsible for your health full stop. But occasionally some hospitals face systemic challenges and become institutional failures over time.[1] It'd be horrible to chain people to a failing institution, especially the sole institution responsible for their health. > It's a very deep problem. Agreed 100%. -- [0] Even if I'm not paying full costs directly, I don't want society to simply waste money on me. I've heard of plans that give you a weekly back massage from a chiropractor at a $10 copay. I'd feel terrible doing that, like I was stealing money from babies with cancer. [1] e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Joseph_Medical_Center_(Houston,_Texas)#Recent_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Joseph_Medical_Center_(Hou...
- xtracto 10y agoCould some kind of distributed option-contracts (like insurance) be developed using Ethereum or other smart-contract blockchain. Imagine if people with Ether (or other blockchain currency) could "reserve" ethers to serve as insurance spending for other people that buys the insurance contracts... something like crowdsourcing of insurance. That would be really cool.