5 ms·
> I find it a bit disgusting actually But withdrawing and depositing money is a service that costs the banks money to do doesn't it? I'm can see why you don't
by chrisseaton 10y ago
> I find it a bit disgusting actually
But withdrawing and depositing money is a service that costs the banks money to do doesn't it? I'm can see why you don't like but I can't see it as morally 'disgusting'.
Would you look after someone else's meagre current account for them, and give it back on demand, for free? I wouldn't.
I don't really know who covers that cost in the UK. It's certainly not interest they earn lending out our savings is it? Especially this type of customer since they have no savings because the point of the card is to encourage them to do so, and since interest rates are so low.
Who is paying to cover the costs of a basic bank account of someone who doesn't save? I've no idea.
- nightcracker 10y agoThose are the costs associated with running a bank. It's paid for by giving them access to our capital, that they can use to invest. Have we forgotten what a bank is for? It's to conveniently and safely store money. Part of that convenience is to withdraw and store money at many locations. If a bank didn't offer that they wouldn't get my money.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> It's paid for by giving them access to our capital, that they can use to invest. What capital? The people referred to in this article don't have any savings. Many working class people have no savings at all, and only a few thousand in their current accounts.
- watwut 10y agoWhich does not make this offer reasonable, it is still ripoff. They are better off keeping money in box at home. Criticising this offer is as valid as criticising any other expensive and bad service.
- alkonaut 10y agoA person being a customer of a bank means the bank has first access to that persons business when they need mortgages, other loans, home insurance, buying funds for retirement savings etc. I suppse where bank accounts are free including services like ATM that might be an indication that banks compete for all customers - which might ni turn be an indication that all customers are reasonably likely to buy financial products such as taking loans or savings products in the future.
- rhino369 10y ago"Free checking" is a relatively new practice in banking that really only caught fire after ATMs were invented. Banks would charge fees on transactions--like most financial services do. Even now, most free checking accounts only require a certain amount of money, transactions they collect fees on, etc. With interest rates so low, they don't make much just holding onto 500 dollars for someone. Savings accounts had less fees, but you couldn't use them to write checks out of, etc.
- orf 10y ago> But withdrawing and depositing money is a service that costs the banks money to do doesn't it? It's literally their job. It's their function. Why am I reimbursing them? I'm giving them my money essentially to invest, why am I also paying them to support basic business functions on my money, with my money, while they make money using my money? It's easy to say "hurr durr why are you paying them for a service they provide, who does that??" but that's missing the point. Banks are a special case. > I can't see it as morally 'disgusting'. It disproportionately affects the poor, and for no real reason than 'I can charge this so I will'. Apparently some places charge you to even check your balance? What the hell. > I don't really know who covers that cost in the UK The big, fat, rich banks do. Because the total cost of running all their ATM's is a fraction of a rounding error on their yearly turnover.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 10y ago> I'm giving them my money essentially to invest But what about those people who aren't giving the bank any meaningful capital to invest? What is the bank getting in return in that case? Or are you arguing that banks should be forced to provide it as a kind of social service even if they don't earn anything? I can understand that kind of point of view.
- orf 10y agoThe answer to "not enough people are giving banks capital to invest" is not "charge people more", it's to work out why nobody is putting their money in banks. Could the charges be a factor? Or a paycheck-to-paycheck economy? The people not giving the bank any meaningful capital are going to cost them much/anything,because it's not as if Joe Bloggs with $500 in his account is going to be doing a thousand withdrawals and balance checks a month. The point is the banking fees hit those who can least afford to pay them the most. It doesn't have to be like that, and I can understand a kind of point of view that supports it.
- CaptainZapp 10y ago
- psyc 10y agoDo believe that banks are setting their fees based on their associated costs?