4 ms·
Sow now I have devices of all of these varieties: - Mini-USB (stupid bike lights ...) - normal Micro-USB (battery packs, smartwatch, flashlight) - Qualcomm™
by dheera 10y ago
Sow now I have devices of all of these varieties:
- Mini-USB (stupid bike lights ...)
- normal Micro-USB (battery packs, smartwatch, flashlight)
- Qualcomm™ Quick© Charge® 2.0 that heats up and drains its batteries if plugged into a non-QC charger (phone)
- Qualcomm™ Quick© Charge® 3.0 that refuses to charge in a QC 2.0 charger but will charge in a non-QC charger (battery pack)
- low-voltage USB-C that my high-voltage USB-C adapter refuses to charge (another phone)
- high-voltage USB-C that won't accept low voltage USB-C (laptop)
Travelling has officially become a bag full of AC adapters and wire mess again.
I miss the barrel connectors of the old days. They came in far fewer varieties than these silly USB connectors. And the USB connectors break if you smack the cable by accident. The other day I had a USB-C socket that got snapped right off the PCB because the protruding cable bumped into something. Who designed these things?! Connectors being torqued off PCBs was nearly unheard-of 15 years ago.
- neverminder 10y agoIn my opinion some kind of standard is better than no standard. Now is an unavoidable transitional period and if all goes well within a few years most of portable devices will charge through USB Type-C by default. I don't agree with Qualcomm's approach, but it's always like that when some major standard is emerging - big players will at least try to pull some proprietary crap. I am an early adopter of USB Type-C charging and I've selected my devices with that in mind, so for me it works flawlessly. I have a laptop Chromebook Pixel LS (2015) and a phone Nexus 6P. I can charge the phone with laptop's charger (it has variable voltage) and vice versa. The only difference obviously is that laptop charges considerably slower with phone charger, but I can plug it from either side, which for laptop users is very convenient. When was the last time you could do that with a barrel connector?
- lojack 10y ago> if all goes well within a few years most of portable devices will charge through USB Type-C by default I feel like I've heard this one before. If history repeats itself in a few years there will be a new standard that does something better and 30% of manufacturers will switch to that.
- qb45 10y ago> Connectors being torqued off PCBs was nearly unheard-of 15 years ago. Well, 10 years ago my sister snapped off a mini jack which isn't that far from a barrel jack. It really is a problem with those stupid surface-mount connectors without through-hole mounting tabs. Even USB-C and micro-USB can be had with through-hole tabs, but I bet these are more expensive to assemble.
- mpweiher 10y agoInteresting. My life (well, the "powering electronic devices" part of my life) got a lot easier with the new MacBook Pro, because now I have a single adapter that can power all my devices directly. Alternatively, I can power the same devices via my laptop via the same cables. While getting rid of some of these connector types would certainly be welcome, it wouldn't reduce my cable carrying burden that much because I'd still want to be able to charge my laptop at the same time as my phone, for example.
- LeifCarrotson 10y ago> - Qualcomm™ Quick© Charge® 2.0 that heats up and drains its batteries if plugged into a non-QC charger (phone) > - Qualcomm™ Quick© Charge® 3.0 that refuses to charge in a QC 2.0 charger but will charge in a non-QC charger (battery pack) Which devices are these, if you don't mind sharing? My QC devices (LG G5, battery pack for G5, Moto X) work fine on either 2.0 or 3.0, or a 500 mA slow charger, or a 2A 'tablet' charger.
- dheera 10y agoFirst one is my Nexus 6. Plug it into a non-QC charger and it will go into a runaway discharge mode. Plug it into a QC charger and it charges up very fast. On a similar note my Nexus 10 (not a QC device) will go into a similar runaway discharge if plugged into a 1-amp USB port instead of a 2-amp port. Second one is a certain particular Anker battery pack.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoWow, Nexus and Anker devices? I would have been less surprised if it was some off-brand or a manufacturer known for incompatibility, but those should be fine. Here's hoping this will all smooth out and we'll eventually have uniform quick charge technology.
- averagewall 10y agoCan you elaborate on the last two? Do you mean power delivery (PD) devices that don't degrade gracefully when connected to non PD devices? It sounds like they must be violating the standard. In that case, it's hopefully something we'll see improve with time. If it really is the standard, that's terrible!
- dheera 10y agoI think they violate the standard. But I guess that is bound to happen when the standard is so complicated to implement correctly.
- gumby 10y ago> I miss the barrel connectors of the old days. They came in far fewer varieties than these silly USB connectors. Perhaps, but there was no standard either, so that two identical barrel connectors could have opposite polarity and different voltage and power levels. You had to keep track of which brick went with which device. DIN connectors were worse. > And the USB connectors break if you smack the cable by accident. Those barrel connectors are longer and so provide even more leverage..
- lightedman 10y ago"Those barrel connectors are longer and so provide even more leverage.." Those are rarely surface-mount components, though. Even in my new sound chair, the input and output jacks are thru-hole.
- lightedman 10y ago"Connectors being torqued off PCBs was nearly unheard-of 15 years ago." That's because we were still primarily doing through-hole soldering, and SMD wasn't such a big thing, yet.