3 ms·
Apple's problem is more subtle. The MacPro was a good choice for a tiny market niche - pro video editors and pro musicians. This is a market in which a $5k 10
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
Apple's problem is more subtle. The MacPro was a good choice for a tiny market niche - pro video editors and pro musicians.
This is a market in which a $5k 10 core PC is considered an entry level machine. 3D houses and some music studios have racks of server-grade hardware that is far outside the reach of most mortals.
There is a bigger market of users who like to label themselves pro, but are actually prosumer. It includes smaller music studios (home or not), design studios, serious hobbyists and dabblers, smaller video houses, academic music composers, and so on.
Also many software developers.
These users are not in the Hollywood league, and they typically have a limited budget.
The old cheesegrater MacPro was a good fit for this market. It was also good enough, and expandable enough, to get some interest from the no-compromise pros.
The new MacPro is too expensive for the prosumers, and poor value - and underpowered - for the no-compromise pros.
I'm not yet convinced Apple understands this. Jobs understood it because his links with Pixar meant he could see first hand what Hollywood pros were using.
I don't think the current management is as open to creative input from creative professionals at all levels.
If I'm right, the 2018 Mac Pros will be open like PCs, but they still won't truly satisfy either type of user.
- fuzzywalrus 10y agoI'd beg to differ on the point of Pro-Video editors and musicians seeing as I've contracted for a few TV shows and am a hobbyist musician etc. It was a mediocre choice, if not poor choice: Generally a TV Show workflow (since FCP X killed its user base) an Avid centric base. Editors grab all their footage off a central server to edit the down converts (1080p). SSD is great for a boot drive but you'll need hefty internal storage. Now you need to buy an expensive external solution. Also for same goes for Digital Musicians or recording, although the storage demands are quite a bit less. The dual GPU setup was under-utilized and the consumer grade cards are far better for render assistance bang-for-buck. So much so that it was better just to upgrade GPUs with gaming cards. Notably, the Fire GLs are underperfomers for After Effects. Also Musicians get almost zero benefit from dual GPUs. It's unnecessary cost. Since in Hollywood TV, you are contract you, you bring your own hardware. When USB 3.0 took off, most of my editor friends just grabbed USB 3.0 cards and popped them into the computers. Mixing guys tended to have a lot invested in PCIe audio interfaces for ProTools. A few friends had MPEG4 encoder accelerators which were great for quick encodes for dailies. I'm not sure what fantasy world Apple was in that small size of the Mac Pro 2013 mattered but post-guys set up shop for weeks at a time, and its easier to cart one heavy tower followed by monitors than a small computer with a box of dongles and misc items. The friends I still keep in touch with in LA mostly have switched to Windows instead of going for the Mac Pro 2013. More bang for the book (time is money) and more performant. Anyhow, other than that I agree. just rerelease the 2012 with new innards and call it a day.
- dredmorbius 10y agoOr, in other words, not the Minimum Viable User: https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/69wk8y/the_tyranny_of_the_minimum_viable_user/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/69wk8y/the_tyr...