9 ms·
'Civilization' Creator Sid Meier: “I Didn't Really Expect to Be a Game Designer”
- Mendenhall 10y agoI miss MicroProse and those fat game manuals! Looking inside for code words so you could land in Gunship...good times. Edit-Airborne ranger was well ahead of its time IMO. Think that was first game I really felt like I was "sneaking".
- stevenwoo 10y agoI loved Gunship on the Atari ST with a full keyboard template, it was quite a rush to land a damaged chopper with autorotation. Got to work with one of the programmers later, which kind of made everything I did up to that point seem pretty inadequate since we were almost the same age.
- sundvor 10y agoAirborne Ranger - that's a title I haven't heard in a LONG while. I must have lost weeks to it though. :) In fact they have so many good ones. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_MicroProse_games https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_MicroProse_games Falcon 4 is still alive today!
- acemarke 10y agoOh, man... I'd totally forgotten about that game! I played it a _ton_ as a kid :) Now that you mention it, the sights and sounds are coming back to my mind's eye. Aaaand now I know what I'm doing with my free time later this week :)
- sundvor 10y agoMmmm. I vaguely remember what it was like to have free time. :) If I can find some again, I do want to get F4 BMS up and running with TrackIr on the 34".
- wowtip 10y agoSilent Service / Red Storm Rising - those were the days
- Terr_ 10y agoIt's interesting to see how many classic/nostalgia-games were actually simulations and sandboxes, rather than scripted experiences.
- danso 10y ago20 years from now, how will our current gaming scene be defined in the compressed, excerpted view of retrospective history? Sure, there are scripted megahits such as "The Last of Us" and the "Call of Duty" series. But the standouts in terms of pure revenue and popularity metrics would seemingly be the Grand Theft Auto series (particularly V) and, for indies, Minecraft (pre-Microsoft).
- rhcom2 10y agoI think of the current scene dominated by a lower barrier of entry to market and the current rise of indie and "early access" games so maybe it won't be defined by games at all but by the dominance of Steam.
- CPUstring 10y agoKerbal Space Program without a doubt.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 10y ago
- chongli 10y agoI remember playing Civ 1 back in the day. It was a great game, albeit easy to win with rapid-expansion strategies. Civ 2 was probably my favourite of the Civilization series (Alpha Centauri being my favourite overall). As time went on, the designers worked harder and harder to block the best strategies in the game rules. They added more and more convoluted systems of upkeep, corruption, etc. in order to slow down a rapid expanding player. This has probably been my biggest beef with the series: redesigning the rules to counteract the player instead of making the AI opponents smarter. I haven't played Civ 6 but Civ 5 just bored me to tears with how much of that nonsense they did. That game felt like you had a million decisions to make and none of them had much consequence.
- Mendenhall 10y agoFall from heaven 2 beyond the sword mod, if you like civ and never played it do yourself a huge favor and get it! I loved the civ games and this mod makes them all look boring.
- JauntTrooper 10y agoIt really was an amazing game. I loved Civ, but FFH2 was just such a good upgrade. The main developer, Kael, is now a game designer at Stardock. His latest is Galactic Civilization 3. Have you tried it?
- baq 10y agoI lost many hours on galciv2...
- scrollaway 10y ago6 is a decent rethink of the core rules and mechanics, that still doesn't stray too far from 5. I would recommend taking a look at it on youtube at the very least, it's definitely the better recent title. Civ is one of the very rare strategy multiplayer games where AI mode is a lot of fun; different than PvP, but still a challenge and a mostly fresh experience. My main issue with it is the exceedingly annoying political behaviour of the ever-complaining AIs. (You're expanding too much! You're not expanding enough! Your army is too large! Your army is weak! One of your units stared at me wrong!)
- mattferderer 10y agoI've heard rumors that Sid Meier is a foreign entity from some other universe. He sucks time away from your life & uses it to help him live forever. If you don't believe me & you need proof (since this is Hacker News) I dare you to play any Civilization game from the series. I suggest Civ 3. Whichever you pick, you will find yourself randomly noticing the people around you are waking up for breakfast & you've been playing all night. You'll be upset with yourself for a minute, but then you'll realize you just need to make a couple more strategic moves to conqueror your neighbor. If you call in sick today, you might be able to take over your entire continent. Then again, now that you've got the hang of it, you could also restart & really perfect your opening moves. Dilemmas..
- mojowo11 10y agoCurrently at 504 hours on Civ V and I don't really even think I'm very good at it. It really eats my brain anytime I play it.
- BurritoAlPastor 10y agoOf particular note to the HN crowd – the "typical" design process for a Meier game is he shows up at the office with a completely playable game prototype, and if people find it fun, then the whole thing gets reimplemented. Apparently he's been using the same engine for prototyping for some 20 years. http://www.pcgamesn.com/civilization-vi/sid-meier-civ-6 http://www.pcgamesn.com/civilization-vi/sid-meier-civ-6
- graphitezepp 10y agoThat is actually really cool. I bet this strategy is super efficient for game design, you know for designers who do the work to maintain a custom game engine that can do everything they need.
- wcarss 10y agoIf you want to listen to ~7 hours of Sid Meier being interviewed about Pirates, Railroad Tycoon, Civ, the move from Microprose to Firaxis, and more, these podcasts[1] are awesome. They're done by Soren Johnson, creator of Offworld Trading Company and lead designer of Civ IV. https://www.idlethumbs.net/designernotes/episodes/sid-meier-part-1 https://www.idlethumbs.net/designernotes/episodes/sid-meier-...
- PakG1 10y agoAnytime Civ 2 is mentioned, I just remember this. Just so amazing. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4100032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4100032
- drrob 10y agoMy thoughts exactly; I can remember reading that the first time around on HN/Reddit.
- mvindahl 10y agoI played a ridiculous amount of Civ1 back in the day, and later Civ2 and Civ3. I deleted Civ3 around 2003 because I felt that it was sucking too much time away from my real life. Haven't played any of the more recent versions but I'm sure that they're great. Instead, a few years back, I took up the occasional Civ1 again, downloaded as abandonware, and running in a DOSBox. A nice thing about Civ1 is that I can usually complete it in a few hours; as I recall, Civ3 could easily take a night to play through. I even played it with my son for a while. I think that he should know the classics. As for strategy, I play with three civs, I always prioritize research over taxes, and I prioritize expansion over fortification early in the game (I quit when this backfires). Once I get my civ rolling I have found the best strategy for getting a high score is to track down the other civs as fast as possible and to knock them out, starting at the capital. Once their capital has fallen and a few main cities, they will make peace. Then rest of the cities can be conquered at my leisure or they can be cheaply bought by diplomats and their building sold for scraps, decreasing the price further. An important prerequisite for the aggressive strategy to work is to get to them before they build city walls. Often, however, I find myself gravitating towards a "tech hub" strategy instead. It rarely leads to scores above 100% on king level but if feels kind of satisfying. The point of this is to appoint some city with potential for trade and growth (ideally all of its accessible squares should be plains or convertible to plains). Then build, as soon as possible, the Colossus (+1 trade per trade square). Then, in some order, a library (+50% science), a granary (faster growth), Copernicus' Observatory (+100% science), university (+50% science), and Shakespeare's Theatre (everyone is happy). Bring in caravans from the rest of the continent to speed up production, and to set up trade routes from the tech hub. Elsewhere, build the Pyramids (switch to democracy) and J.S.Bach's Cathedral (two happy faces per city and only way to keep democracy while dispatching a sail or a frigate with caravans from the tech hub). Research railroad and, once achived, assign all settlers to put railroads on the area surrounding the tech hub, boosting growth (in preparation for railroad, clear any forests and swamps, and build roads and irrigation). Postpone researching electricity since it will cancel the Colossus. With the tech hub strategy, the science light bulps of the tech hub will often overflow into the next panel on the city details screen and I'll usually have armors and planes and railroads before reaching 0 AD. After that, I guess the correct path is to switch to communism and eradicate all resistance. I tend to do this too late, though.
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 10y agoWhat are civ players thoughts on freeciv?
- fsiefken 10y agoCompared to Civ1/2 it has nicer graphics tilesets. Sometimes I play (I am more into board games like Eclipse en Scythe) and then I use the 2D tileset and a tiny universe for quick play. For other open source civs - but much more retro - you might like VMS Empire, Classic Empire or XConq. Less is sometimes more. http://www.catb.org/esr/vms-empire/ http://www.catb.org/esr/vms-empire/ http://www.classicempire.com http://www.classicempire.com http://sourceware.org/xconq/README http://sourceware.org/xconq/README
- roschdal 10y agoI suggest you give Freeciv-web a try: https://play.freeciv.org/ https://play.freeciv.org/
- fsiefken 10y agoCIV before pixel graphics, Empire: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classic_Empire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classic_Empire * VMS Empire: http://www.catb.org/esr/vms-empire/ http://www.catb.org/esr/vms-empire/ (apt-get install empire, ascii graphics) * http://www.classicempire.com http://www.classicempire.com * XConq https://sourceware.org/xconq/ https://sourceware.org/xconq/ * A relatively more modern commercial variant (including mobile) http://killerbeesoftware.com/kbsgames/ednew/ http://killerbeesoftware.com/kbsgames/ednew/ http://killerbeesoftware.com/kbsgames/edme http://killerbeesoftware.com/kbsgames/edme
- fab1an 10y agoOh man. Civ 1 was the first computer game my father purchased for my brother and me in our earliest teens. We got to choose ONE game from a store, based purely on its packaging, and obviously pending approval by our dad. I vividly remember the magnetism of the pyramids depicted on the game's box - it had to be that one. Little did we know that we accidentally purchased what is probably the best game in computer game history. Fast forward a year (and many hours of Civ) later in history class, when our teacher asked the class (somewhat rhethorically..) whether anyone had an explanation for why the Roman Empire became as successful as it was. Before he could give us his explanation, I blurted out that it must have been their invention of the aqueduct, which eventually allowed the roman cities to grow as large as they did (which is, of course, the game mechanic of aqueducts in Civ). Regardless of whether that's true or not, let's just say that this wasn't the type of answer our teacher expected from a 6th grader! As someone else noted in here, it's Paradox Interactive games that have somewhat ruined all advanced Civs for me (the exception being Civ 1!). If you're a grown up gamer looking for something to recreate that ol' Civ feeling, give Europa Universalis and Crusader Kings a try.
- Meegul 10y agoI can attest to your recommendation. Europa Universalis, Crusader Kings, Hearts of Iron, Stellaris, and Victoria are their primary grand strategy series these days. Each one of them specializes on a different time period, either in the past or future. They all have a considerable amount of depth, but after a few hours of playing around and accepting a few losses, they're a great step up for people with experience with strategy games.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TuringNYC 10y agoCiv 1 was the closest thing i've ever experienced to addiction, withdrawal and denial and it was frightening. Yet so memorable.
- Shivetya 10y agoI know everyone goes on and on about Civilization but all the simulators from F15/Gunship/etc were my first introduction to his games. I still think Pirates was the real breakthrough. It was an almost sand box game and of course Railroad Tycoon. Oddly its perhaps my playing of traditional board games usually with others that kept Civilization from taking over my computer gaming at the time
- animal531 10y agoPirates was a fun little game. Another one that I loved growing up was Covert Action. Only the electronics and breaking in mini-games were really any good, but the game was set up so that you could focus on those and pretty much ignore the others. I loved the whole mystery and trying to untangle the crime aspect with the different actors, as well as how if you took too long or looked in the wrong places you could miss capturing some of the bad guys, or even screw up the whole mission.
- RogtamBar 10y agoIt's been 27 fucking years since 1990, and the civilization franchise is still a glorified boardgame, where the only agency is had by each player. Totally unlike the real world, where ruling or governing is more about figuring out how to exercise power without getting overthrown. Such a game would be way more interesting.
- tarpherder 10y agoI'm not sure how you came to the conclusion that it would make an interesting game. Making something more like the real world is often exactly what you don't want to do in a game.
- RogtamBar 10y agoBecause it'd be more complex and interesting and not just about optimizing to win. No emergent gameplay at all in Civ.
- chongli 10y agoComplex does not equal interesting. I suggest you take a look at Extra Credits' episode on Depth vs Complexity [0]. [0] https://youtu.be/jVL4st0blGU https://youtu.be/jVL4st0blGU
- RogtamBar 10y agoBy 'complex' I meant that it'd not be a boardgame anymore, but a boardgame in which the 'pieces' would have minds of their own and would do whatever they were could. Have you read about the Russian frontier? As soon as it was at least somewhat secure so living on it wasn't a sure-fire way of getting enslaved by Muslim steppe raiders(Tatars), the empty land was filled up by peasants looking for land to farm. An increase in population led to more slave raids, so Moscow was forced to push the border further south to protect the farmers. In this way the border kept moving south. In 250 years, this mechanism caused the Russian state to expand from Moscow to Crimea.
- 10y ago
- manuelflara 10y agoI never got to play Civ 1 but Civ 2 was one of the first games I ever owned and played endlessly. Its soundtrack still brings back those feelings.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C55Ae3apn5s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C55Ae3apn5s
- elymar 10y ago"The first Civilization was released more than a quarter-century ago in 1991" ...Thanks for making me feel old.
- WalterBright 10y agoI've been told by various people that Civilization was inspired by Empire (the first computer god game as far as I know), but I'd like to ask Sid if that is true! (There's also the older Hammurabi game, but that one has no map.)
- sleepybrett 10y agoNice interview, much longer more in depth one on Soren Johnson's 'Designer Notes' podcast (the fourth part just landed the other day). https://www.idlethumbs.net/designernotes/ https://www.idlethumbs.net/designernotes/