4 ms·
The irony in this piece (which Gassée is classy enough to only point to obliquely) is that what pros are clamoring for is for an Apple that's less like Steve Jo
by smacktoward 10y ago
The irony in this piece (which Gassée is classy enough to only point to obliquely) is that what pros are clamoring for is for an Apple that's less like Steve Jobs' Apple and more like Jean-Louis Gassée's.
The trashcan Mac Pro came out after Jobs died, but in spirit it's a classically Jobsian product: fascinated with aesthetics and style, disinterested in performance and expandability. It's striking to look at, but required a whole bunch of increasingly painful compromises on the inside in order to make that visual statement possible.
Which makes it a lot like the original Mac, which was also a Jobsian product. Its revolutionary industrial design makes the 1984 Mac a wonderful object to contemplate even today; it's like the Platonic ideal of the term "personal computer." But the original Mac was also hobbled in important ways to fit Jobs' vision; it came with just 128K of RAM (low even by the standards of the time), and no mechanism was provided for adding expansion cards or other upgrades inside the enclosure. (It took two years for Apple to come out with a version that included a SCSI port!)
What the pros want, by contrast, is a Mac that puts functionality over aesthetics; it's OK by them if it's a big ugly box, if that big ugly box comes with cutting edge parts and can be stuffed full of RAM and drives and expansion cards. Which sounds a lot like Gassée's baby when he was in charge of product design at Apple, the Mac II: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh_II
The Mac II discarded the beautiful lunchbox form-factor of the original Mac completely, replacing it with... a big ugly box. But it was a big ugly box that was twice as fast as the lunchbox Mac, supported true-color graphics and had plenty of room for expansion, so the pros of the time loved it. The Mac II was the start of the long line of high-performance Macs that would make the Mac the go-to computer for people in creative industries.
So when pro users complain about there not being a Mac for them anymore, this is what they're talking about. They want a modern Mac II. They want a Mac that's less Steve Jobs and more Jean-Louis Gassée.
- Spooky23 10y agoGreat point. The Mac Pro was pretty obviously this decade's G4 Cube. Ironically they didn't learn their lesson and thermal failure was still the Achilles heel. In their defense, Apple hits home runs with those kind of products. I worked in a computer store when the original iMac came out... the serious computer people thought it was a joke, but it sold like hot cakes.
- mcphage 10y ago> In their defense, Apple hits home runs with those kind of products. I worked in a computer store when the original iMac came out... the serious computer people thought it was a joke, but it sold like hot cakes. What "kind of product" do you mean, that includes the G4 Cube and Trashcan Pro (interesting but expensive failures), and the original iMac (decent mass-market computer that was incredibly successful)?
- Spooky23 10y agoI mean products that break the mold. The bondi blue iMac was an incredible gamble. It was bondi blue, looked like a hard boiled egg sliced in half, lacked a floppy drive, and was incompatible with every Apple accessory/peripheral on the market. But it hit the mark and was a hit.
- vacri 10y ago> In their defense, Apple hits home runs with those kind of products. Apple makes plenty of turkeys; it's just when they score a hit, they hit it out of the park.
- scarface74 10y agoDon't give Gassée too much credit. It was under his leadership that Apple decided to overprice the Mac and chase after revenue and they let MS and Windows take over -- almost killing Apple.
- pwthornton 10y agoJobs was a truck user in his famous analogy. As CEO, he clearly didn't do much design or programming or have any true pro needs, but if you see photos of his home office, what do you see? A big honking Mac Pro (and even a scale model on his desk!). Jobs didn't need a Mac Pro and a huge external monitor, and could have clearly used a laptop or iMac. The fact that he used the company's pro computer in his home office tells you a lot about him and the kinds of computers he liked. The Mac Pro is very much a Johnny Ive design and idea (and not updating it feels like something that a numbers obsessed CEO like Cook would do). I'm not convinced at all Jobs would have let the Mac Pro flounder like this. I truly believe that if Steve Jobs were alive today, the Mac Pro would be routinely updated.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- derefr 10y ago> a classically Jobsian product: fascinated with aesthetics and style, disinterested in performance and expandability. That's the description for a Jobsian consumer product. All the previous Mac Pro designs (and Xserve designs!) were greenlighted under Jobs, and it's obvious that tons of thought was put into their expandability and maintainability. The obvious example is the PowerMac G5 with its screwless design (before that was at-all common); but looking further back, you've got things like the PowerMac G3, where most of the computer lived on a slide-out tray (https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/PowerMac+G3+All-In-One+Teardown/2138 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/PowerMac+G3+All-In-One+Teard...). The G3 AIO was obviously an "aesthetic" product (however people might feel about the aesthetics of said "Molar Mac") but it was also built to serve the education market, not the consumer market, so it had maintainability as a goal. > But the original Mac was also hobbled in important ways to fit Jobs' vision; it came with just 128K of RAM (low even by the standards of the time) This was about cost savings! Same strategy as Nintendo: cheap parts + lots of value-add in integration and software = huge profit margin. (But, unlike modern Nintendo, early Apple did this out of necessity—a risky investment into a new product line when you don't have much capital is even riskier if you have to make minimum purchase orders for large quantities of expensive parts. May as well design the first one to be low-end, and then, if you can't sell it, repurpose the low-end parts for something else, like, say, disk drive controllers.) > no mechanism was provided for adding expansion cards or other upgrades inside the enclosure I'm not sure why they did this for the Mac 128K, but I'd guess it was simply that there wasn't room on the motherboard, with the motherboard constrained by the tiny case (where the form-factor of the case was part of the value-prop of the Macintosh product: it fit on your desk without stealing your desk.) Look at the 128K's motherboard (https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Macintosh+128K+Teardown/21422#s57331 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Macintosh+128K+Teardown/2142... )—there's no room there to add anything. > It took two years for Apple to come out with a version that included a SCSI port! The Macintosh 128k was essentially meant to be an all-in-one, classy "8-bit micro" (at only a slightly higher price than one, once you factor in the price of the included color computer monitor in the 1980s.) It's competitors were Amiga, Amstrad, Commodore, etc. Nobody else in that world used SCSI ports either. Apple basically noticed the reaction creative professionals had to their not-originally-intended-for-creative-professionals product, and then started adding "pro" features to it (while still never thinking of the Macintosh line as for professionals, until the popularity of Macs pushed them to eliminate their other lines.) > The Mac II was the start of the long line of high-performance Macs that would make the Mac the go-to computer for people in creative industries. Note that the Macintosh SE continued this trend, and yet returned to the lunch-box form-factor. The difference was that, by then, the chips on the motherboard had miniaturized enough to let them stick some expansion sockets on it as well.