4 ms·
Your assertion being that layoffs and cost cutting are inherently unethical? That is to say, it is evil and wrong to ever fire anyone. It is also evil and wrong
by legitster 10y ago
Your assertion being that layoffs and cost cutting are inherently unethical? That is to say, it is evil and wrong to ever fire anyone. It is also evil and wrong to cut costs?
- chrisbennet 10y agoI'm not the OP of the comment you're responding to but... I think it is unethical to take away the livelihood of someone if the only reason you are doing it is to add even more zeros to your already fat bank account.
- legitster 10y agoBut the only reason a business hires employees is to make more money. We are not employed out of charity. Can we complain that greed compels them to fire us when it also compels them to hire us in the first place? Also, you are assuming the only one being rewarded by layoffs are executives. As someone dutifully putting away money for retirement in a 401k, I am the primary beneficiary of such layoffs in their stock prices(assuming the company is publicly traded). Should I feel guilty that my greed has caused layoffs?
- chrisbennet 10y agoOf course not, not anymore than you should feel guilty for investing in tobacco companies. If causing others suffering is really so bad, it would be illegal right? /s
- uiri 10y agoTheir livelihood is already gone. They have nothing productive to do. It is far more ethical to let them go and secure productive employment elsewhere so that they may have some dignity rather than to pay them to do nothing.
- metaphorm 10y agoin principle yes, but implementation details matter. layoffs when accompanied by humane severance packages is ethical. this rarely happens.
- restalis 10y ago"I think it is unethical to take away the livelihood of someone if the only reason you are doing it is to add even more zeros to your already fat bank account." Even if one would agree to judge things within your frame, i.e. employee's share vs. employer's, you still have a moral dilemma with allocating resources wisely. Judging from their past income spending practice, employees will most likely consume, whereas employers will most likely invest. I hardly see any reason against supporting the later kind of players.
- valuearb 10y agoWho deserves the money more, the unproductive worker or the shareholders? Poor people own stocks too, whether in IRAs or pensions.