5 ms·
The article underplays the success of Patreon in solving this problem; almost every video creator I follow has set up one. It's a win-win for both content creat
by minimaxir 10y ago
The article underplays the success of Patreon in solving this problem; almost every video creator I follow has set up one. It's a win-win for both content creators and consumers.
I'm actually surprised more programmers/engineers have not set up a Patreon. (in disclosure, I have one set up, but have zero expectation of it replacing a full-time salary.)
- falcolas 10y agoIt's unfortunate that viewers have to pay twice for content - once via Patreon, the second while watching ads.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoOne pays the content, one pays the hosting.
- falcolas 10y agoShould that matter, to the viewer?
- tapoxi 10y agoMy cousin is a YouTuber, and for him (and a few others) they follow a "Premium Content" model. Their YouTube channel has free, ad supported content to develop an audience, and Patreon subscribers get that content ad-free, as well as extra content. It's a decent model, but as I find myself watching more YouTube than Netflix/Hulu these days, I really wish this concept was supported by YouTube itself. They have YouTube Red, but that doesn't directly support my favorite YouTubers.
- jasonlotito 10y agoYouTube Red does directly support the YouTubers you watch.
- jrockway 10y agoI think he's saying that he wants $X per month to be delivered directly to the content creator's bank account regardless of how many of that content creator's videos he watches. That's what Patreon does. Twitch has a clearer subscriber model, I think. When you "subscribe", you're actually giving your actual real money to the channel. I'm not sure why YouTube doesn't have that. (Different horses for different courses, I guess. YouTube is more about the "1 billion people will watch this and some people will see an ad", versus "I know I like you, here's some money." Both can be profitable for everyone involved, but the models are very different. Scale vs. curation, or something.)
- rtkwe 10y agoOnly somewhat. As far as anyone can tell, because afaik Google hasn't come out and said precisely, all the money goes into a large pot and then the whole pot is split by the portion of minutes watched with Red that for each channel. ie in a simple case with two channels and 2 Red viewers if person A watches 20 minutes of channel A and person B watches 10 minutes of channel B in a month: A gets 2/3 of the pot and B gets 1/3. At least that's what seems to be happening as far as I can see from the various articles written about it.
- falcolas 10y agoGiven how a video has to be monitized by the creator (i.e. set up with ads) to get Red dollars as well, I'm curious if the changes to ad placement will have a knock-on effect for Red dollars as well... I'd hope not, but stranger things have happened.
- rtkwe 10y agoI'm not clear on what you're saying.
- mjevans 10y agoIt has the wrong model. The consumer isn't choosing what THEY want to support al-a-cart or even automatically based on what they watch. (Either of these would be good models for the consumer.) The least regressive model would be for viewers to pay per time unit of video, say in 5 min blocks (round down) and probably with a decaying rate of compensation on a series per block of content produced (recovery time would probably vary depending on the popularity of the series, really popular things would recover more quickly, the producer should have some feedback from this metric). That kind of a model avoids penalizing groups of content creators, having them compete against each other (other than for viewer time, which is unavoidable), and it reduces the advertiser influenced network effect of more popular creators being over-paid compared to more niche / rising creators.
- deelowe 10y agoIt's honestly bizarre to me that more YTer's aren't promoting red for this very reason.
- tyfon 10y agoYoutube red is only available in * Australia * Korea * Mexico * New Zealand * The United States I'd buy it in an instant (in fact, I already have all access which is bundled with red) but it's just not available in most of the world.
- EA 10y agoIt is worse with ESPN. I buy the ESPN Magazine. I buy ESPN Insider. And I still have to watch ads on ESPN videos.
- Buge 10y agoYoutubers can disable ads on their videos if they don't want any ad revenue.
- placeybordeaux 10y agoOne of my favorite OSS contributors in scala was recently asking on twitter if any companies would be interested in sponsoring him to spend a couple months working full time on issues on his OSS stuff. Lots of people responded asking for his patreon, enough that he went ahead and set one up[1]. It'll be interesting to see if this kind of thing continues. [1]: https://www.patreon.com/lihaoyi https://www.patreon.com/lihaoyi
- jdietrich 10y agoIn 2008, Kevin Kelly theorised that a successful creative person only needs a few thousand true fans to have a successful career. If that small group of fans are willing to throw you $20 for a book or a t-shirt or a CD every year, you can make a middle-class income. You don't need to be a star, you don't need the backing of a record label or a publisher or a movie studio. While initially promising, this theory didn't seem to bear out in practice. Many creative people replied that the numbers just didn't add up. Margins are too thin, expenses are too high, promotion is too difficult. Unless you're absurdly lucky, you can't make a decent living without access to a mass audience via the traditional media. Patreon seems to be the technology that brings this theory to life. A huge variety of creative people now have a regular, sustainable income thanks to their Patreon subscribers. If you can find 1000 people willing to throw you an average of $5 a month, you're earning more than the median US household. With those subscribers paying your bills, your merch sales and ad revenue and whatever else are just gravy. It's SaaS for creatives - recurring revenue always trumps one-off sales. http://kk.org/thetechnium/1000-true-fans/ http://kk.org/thetechnium/1000-true-fans/