3 ms·
Unless you have a seat on the board, your investment in a company should reflect your implicit belief that what they are doing is worth your investment. To buy
by phkahler 10y ago
Unless you have a seat on the board, your investment in a company should reflect your implicit belief that what they are doing is worth your investment. To buy stock and then jump up and down in public trying to move your investment up or down seems inappropriate.
- pfortuny 10y agoWell no: the board is there in representation of the shareholders, who are the technical owners. So the shareholders are who should lead the board, at least in the long term (as owners).
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThe difference between 'trading' and 'investing'. Trading is buying and selling stock, or more often stock derivatives, based on an anticipation of the stocks movement. Investing is buying or selling stock based on an evaluation of a company's value over a longer time frame.[1] He, like some others, can't figure out why people like Tesla's stock. And because of that he has bet it will go down when those investors 'wake up' to the reality as he sees it. The problem is you can't really know which reality is 'correct' until later looking back. People who value Tesla as a car company value it one way, people to value it as an energy company value it a different way. Who is right? We won't know for another 5 years at least. [1] Yes there is this weird marginal point where either definition might apply. But derivatives are (for me) always a 'trading' play.
- maxerickson 10y agoIn what sense are you using inappropriate? Also, should Elon Musk participate in puff pieces that promote Tesla? Or is that inappropriate?
- jackmott 10y agoEinhorn can do what he wants I'm just not inclined to care.
- an_account 10y agoWhen you are a ~4% _owner_ in a company, you should (and do) have say in how that company is managed.
- Retric 10y agoIf you have a ~4% stake in a local car dealership you don't have meaningful control. This does not change with a public company outside of a few votes because majority or often super majority rules.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 10y agoAnd with that percentage you can probably talk directly to the board, and possibly any other large investors. Why does he need to take it to the public?
- tuna-piano 10y agoI strongly disagree. When you look at companies, sometimes the boards and management stop acting in the best interest of shareholders. They may be doing this due to self-serving reasons or incompetence, but it doesn't matter. Activists play an essential role in ensuring companies look out for the best interests of their shareholders. Here's a good quote about some activist investors in a small public company. "He said that the benefits of being public outweighed the costs. He had been at a private company and had worked under pressure from private-equity investors. Public markets, he said, enabled Tejon Ranch to operate under much less short-term pressure, and to take a longer-term perspective. We were flabbergasted: Many companies go private or stay private to avoid the short-term pressure that public markets can create. But the fact is, for companies the size of Tejon Ranch—and there are thousands of them, filling the portfolios of mutual funds and pension funds, even though most investors have never heard their name—Bielli is probably right. Because so many investors are passive today, most CEOs can relax, even if their performance is mediocre." https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-04-17/activist-fights-and-college-recruiting https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-04-17/activist-...