3 ms·
The Taliban have significantly more military skill than the Afghan warlords they've been fighting for the last decade. A contrary view was posted to HN just ye
by tokenadult 16y ago
The Taliban have significantly more military skill than the Afghan warlords they've been fighting for the last decade.
A contrary view was posted to HN just yesterday, as I recall.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1427866 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1427866
When the national population is largely in the thralls of tribal superstition, it's easy for people who share that fanaticism (the Taliban) to gain a kind of superficial control over much of the population, but it's not clear that "religious fanatics" (your term) of the Taliban kind will retain the support of the population over the long term.
- MichaelSalib 16y agoNote the distinction between competence of terrorist attacks (especially attacks against targets in the US/Europe) and basic government functions. The fact that the Taliban can't run a suicide bombing operation in NYC to save its life matters a lot less than the fact that lots of people in some parts of Afghanistan prefer taking their disputes to the shadow court system run by the Taliban. The skills you need to be a good jurist have little to do with the skills you need to be a good tactician, and may very well be more significant. Americans focus on terrorism because everything is always always always about us, no matter what, but the Taliban can and does do many things besides terrorist attacks against western targets. Incompetence in one area does not mean that the institution is incompetent in all areas.