4 ms·
But Wikipedia allows user edits, and so is inherently censorable. You don't need to block the site, you can just sneak in propaganda a little at a time.
by kibwen 10y ago
But Wikipedia allows user edits, and so is inherently censorable. You don't need to block the site, you can just sneak in propaganda a little at a time.
- devwastaken 10y agoThat is significantly harder to do.
- dmix 10y agoThat's a casual reductionist definition of censorship. Community edited wiki != Censorship Centrally administered information channels == Censorship The state has equal power as citizens to make edits. Meanwhile the state has exclusive power to shut down network access, persecute people for publishing edits or providing access to censored information, chilling effects, etc. Pretty big difference.
- stcredzero 10y agoThat really depends on the community and the nature of their editing. What if Westboro Baptist Church members decided to do nothing but en-masse gradually edit their Wikipedia page? You would probably categorize their actions as an attempt at propaganda and censorship. (On a short term, of course.) It ultimately wouldn't work, since they are such a small group. However, if a large enough segment of the populace decided on a program like this, which also included an infiltration of the higher-level of Wikipedia's organization, such a program would probably work.
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoContent addressing means that all versions of the page remain available so long as one node hosts it, and they are easily differentiated. On the internet 1000 voices don't speak 1000 times louder than one, it would be relatively easy for a small group to widely advertise that there is a discrepancy. Effective propaganda would only be possible where any contradictions are unable to provide evidence, causing an appeal to authority to become one of the most viable means of resolving the dispute. This is where the majority - but not all - of our current propaganda sits. IPFS would help. It wouldn't solve disinformation but it would tidy up the game.
- stcredzero 10y agoOn the internet 1000 voices don't speak 1000 times louder than one, In a limited context, for a limited time, they can. There are many situations where this is all that's needed. (Like, the run up to an election.) it would be relatively easy for a small group to widely advertise that there is a discrepancy. A large enough, well established enough group would be able to discredit this discrepancy.
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoYes. A lie can run round the world before the truth has got its boots on. For the second case, this is why I talk about the nature of effective propaganda. Evidence is the only reliable way to fight against an authority, as the larger group would be significantly less able to censor evidence they are forced to use unverifiable propaganda - this is much less effective for them.
- obstinate 10y agoThey'd likely eventually get blocked and the page would get edit protected. Wikipedia is not a moderation-free environment.
- stcredzero 10y agoThey'd likely eventually get blocked and the page would get edit protected. As I said, this would only work in the short term. Wikipedia is not a moderation-free environment. Which is why I pointed out that a large enough group would still have to infiltrate the Wikimedia organization.
- roywiggins 10y agoIt's brigading, not censorship. Nasty, but it can be mitigated- that's what Wikipedia editors are for.
- stcredzero 10y agoIn certain times, people find that any system which allows exploitation, will be exploited. Furthermore, it will be exploited by groups of people who feel less powerful, led by demagogues who exploit their attention and outrage for their own benefit. Rules of etiquette and decorum which once protected such systems will be ignored by people who feel sufficiently "justified" in their outrage. Intellectual commons once supported by common values and a love of knowledge will become polluted. The above describes Ancient Rome prior to the change of the Republic into the Empire. It also describes the world 1/6th of the way through the 21st century.
- placeybordeaux 10y agoDo you have evidence that this being employed in a successful manner? We have evidence that simply blocking the site is happening, what you are proposing is way more expensive.
- nemo1618 10y agoThis highlights an important failure of total lassiez-faire: by restricting or distorting access to information, you can effect a nefarious result without violence or even protests. It's like slowly boiling a frog. And it works especially well in a democracy, where political outcomes are (at least in principle) determined by those who are most susceptible to information control.
- syshum 10y ago>>This highlights an important failure of total lassiez-faire: by restricting or distorting access to information What now? Do you believe government never restrict access or distort information to their citizens, it is only a failure of lassiez-faire... Historically governments are the largest propaganda machines
- nemo1618 10y agoI do not claim that it is only a problem with lassiez-faire. Governments are of course capable of the same manipulation. I only claim that lassiez-faire does not solve the problem either, and indeed may be worse since the people believe they are free and are thus more complacent.
- emiliobumachar 10y agoOff-topic, but the "slowly boiling a frog" myth is false. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog
- Houshalter 10y agoThat's true but the metaphor is useful in many places.
- jwilk 10y agoAre there any other popular metaphors based on misconceptions?
- djsumdog 10y agoThere are many articles on Wikipedia that have been deleted that I can no longer find. A few years back, some editors decided to do a huge porn star purge and removed the articles for many prominent adult actors/actresses due to notability. IPFS with snapshots can help people go back to those moments in time and look at articles that are no longer around.
- INTPenis 10y agoExactly, the only uncensorable media is immutable.