3 ms·
This suffers the same issue as Apple's demo site that shows the iPhone 3GS screens blown up 2x to compare against the iPhone 4 screenshots. My eye doesn't have
by ZeroGravitas 16y ago
This suffers the same issue as Apple's demo site that shows the iPhone 3GS screens blown up 2x to compare against the iPhone 4 screenshots.
My eye doesn't have a zoom. I see things at their actual size and even holding my phone right up to my eye I can't get it as large as those images. Details that I can't see without artificial zoom are the same as details that I can't see period.
Clearly, higher resolutions up to some point are better for display purposes, but there's tradeoffs involved. I believe smaller pixels means less light gets through, it's more work for your processors which means less battery life etc.
Everyone knows why Apple doubled ppi and quadrupled pixel count. The benefits of this system over, say, Androids flexibility should be apparent. But there are also limitations that mean the iPad is unlikely to increase its DPI for years unless it follows Android's lead. Certainly not a clear win.
- fh 16y agoI don't understand your point. The iPad has a 130 dpi display, if anything, it should be easier to double that than it was to double the iPhone 3GS's 160 dpi. (I know that making larger displays at that resolution is harder and more expensive, but that won't be an issue forever.)
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoYou've grasped my point better than you realize. As you say the larger screen size and number of pixels outweighs the smaller pixel density. This does change over time but that's also my point, more heterogeneous rivals can re-purpose various display sizes as required and as time passes they'll get higher res screens before the iPad, just like various iPhone rivals did. They've also marketed themselves into a corner since even if they double the 130dpi screen they'll not reach their "magical" figure of 300dpi, and they've now introduced pixel density as a marketable commodity in one market, when they're at a disadvantage in another.
- fh 16y agoAh, I get it now. I agree to a point. I'd add that once resolution itself is no longer an issue (because every phone's screen is above 300 dpi), Android still has the advantage of custom aspect ratios. Regarding the iPad, marketing-wise, they might claim that people typically hold the iPad farther away from their eyes than 12 inches, say 15 inches, which places the "retina limit" conveniently just under 260 dpi.
- loewenskind 16y ago>They've also marketed themselves into a corner I think you're exaggerating their demise, as it were. iPhone competitors released phones with higher res screens. So what, the next release of the iPhone trounced them all. Now the competitors will release something better and Apple will respond, on and on. The difference between a Smart phone and a normal phone is it's not as easy to dump your current phone and just move to another. The differences will have to be pretty big to get people to be willing to go through the trouble of learning a whole new phone, moving their data, etc. And I don't buy the carrier argument because from my experience all US carriers are awful. And having custom resolutions isn't necessarily a win. Look at all the complaining about the different Android resolutions so far. Just wait until they get 5 or 6 new ones.
- dieterrams 16y ago> My eye doesn't have a zoom. I see things at their actual size and even holding my phone right up to my eye I can't get it as large as those images. Details that I can't see without artificial zoom are the same as details that I can't see period. They're zoomed because it's the only way to demonstrate the difference when the display you're looking at almost certainly has a lower PPI. It's no different from having to zoom in on a print sample to show how clear a printer's text is on a monitor. > Clearly, higher resolutions up to some point are better for display purposes, but there's tradeoffs involved. I believe smaller pixels means less light gets through, it's more work for your processors which means less battery life, etc. Which makes it all the more impressive that iPhone 4 has four times the contrast ratio and better battery life than previous iPhones, with the speed of an iPad, in a physically smaller space. Given that everything has been improved, it's clearly not much of a tradeoff. FYI, iOS is perfectly capable of running applications designed for other resolutions. It's not for lack of 'flexibility' on the operating system's part that Apple chose not to utilize intermediate resolutions for its hardware. It's also a little strange to see Android phones' variety of resolutions being described as some sort of path that Android has trailblazed. For one thing, the operating system has nothing to do with it, and for another, that sort of thing has been standard practice for a long time now, whether you're considering computers in general or even just mobile handsets.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoYour definition of trade-off seems broken. If I can make a car much bigger, or make it much more fuel efficient because I've got a new lightweight alloy body then that's still a trade-off even if I decide to make it a little bit bigger and a little bit more fuel efficient. I personally think they've been forced to overshoot on screen density in return for platform homogeneity, the much lesser discussed cousin of the ever popular "fragmentation" and this will cost them money, performance and battery life. They are of course making lemonade from this particular lemon via marketing in an attempt to counteract the benefit that rivals will receive by choosing the screen with the best balance of quality/price/battery at any particular point in time for their devices. Follow the pattern: processor speed: no comment (i.e. the same as everyone else, soon to be lower as new models are released), memory: no comment (i.e. half the flagship rivals, same as the rest), screen density: let's shout this metric from the rooftops because as any longtime Apple follower (like myself) knows, it's only "about the total experience" when you can't actually beat them on the raw figures. If you happen to be forced to use a spec that by your own marketing is higher than actually necessary or visible most of the time, then that figure becomes vitally important since no-one even wants to match it because they want to focus on the "total experience" rather than chase your metric.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]