3 ms·
From the article: So I opened up a server and started monitoring it. I invited any kind of user in with a strict “no rules” policy. That's ad
by ColinWright 10y ago
From the article:
So I opened up a server and started
monitoring it. I invited any kind
of user in with a strict “no rules”
policy.
That's admirable, but these days it's totally naïve. Seriously, how can anyone with any experience at all of on-line communities believe that this could ever end well?
... I would need to monitor what my
users are saying at all times, ...
goes against my hands off approach.
So I’m closing the server ...
In today's world you either facilitate people doing some things that are utterly vile, or you monitor, constrain, curate, and censor. You can't blame Mastodon for this (although the author never explicitly said they did blame Mastodon, I feel that it's the impression they want to give).
- gus_massa 10y agoI agree. Moreover, one of the thing that surprise me is when someone tries to make a clone of HN and totally forget about the moderation work that is necessary.
- rexpop 10y agoThe author also points out there were people on other instances who would be posting things that I could get into trouble for since my server holds a cache of the other servers. And so his own moderation would be insufficient, in his eyes, to disculpate him.
- onion2k 10y agoFederating content on the public internet is a hard problem. That doesn't mean it's unsolvable though. Currently the only working the solution so far is massive human effort - that just puts managing a Mastodon instance outside of the possibility of doing it on your own. If you want to run a server you really need to recruit people to help. Mastodon makes it very easy to block users on other servers, and entire servers, so it's really a matter of further moderation rather than being actually impossible. There's also an effort by Mastodon admin to share a list of the potentially dangerous servers so admin can block them if they wish to.
- djsumdog 10y agoSo does Mastodon cache everything, even people you don't visit/follow? ZeroNet only serves sites you actively visit, correct? I have been meaning to setup a Mastodon server, but haven't gotten around to it yet. Can't you just chose to help cache/serve content for only people you trust/follow?
- detaro 10y agoWho is "you" in your question? It serves any content a user on your instance follows (unless explicitly blocked).
- arxpoetica 10y agoMy thoughts on this kind of federated gate keeping is that it should always be opt in. Explicit gate keeping in other words. In general though, this doesn't seem to be the inclination?
- ColinWright 10y agoI'd be interested to know what you're suggesting here. The way Mastodon works is that on a given instance there is a local timeline, and you can see everything people toot on that. Additionally, anything tooted by a followee of a local user appears in the federated timeline, as does anything boosted by a local user. It seems obvious that these are desirable features. What sort of gate-keeping are you suggesting? Things tooted on other instances don't turn up unless there's a reason - what then would you then require in addition?
- arxpoetica 10y agoI probably don't understand Mastodon well enough so I might be tooting misinformation. ;) But to answer your question (and I'm probably oversimplifying a problem here), imagine Mastodon was more like WordPress, and less a bunch of federated servers. I set up a site, just for me, and "opt in" who I want to see—and no one else gets through. If you're worried about someone's content, just oust them/unfollow. Granted, this kind of federation requires a centralized follow tree which would have to be hosted somewhere else...OR with a different set of federated sites...(getting complex here)...