3 ms·
Linux is still a hobby OS. It's not a particularly wonderful example of software engineering. Its only real benefit is that it's free and comes with an ecosyste
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
Linux is still a hobby OS. It's not a particularly wonderful example of software engineering. Its only real benefit is that it's free and comes with an ecosystem of other free software that kind of mostly works as long as you don't mind the occasional security horror, and can be used as-is or customised at relatively low cost.
That combination of features makes it appealing in a variety of business cases - for business reasons.
RISC-V can't be customised at relatively low cost. It's nominally free, but the freeness doesn't mean much in a business setting.
The total cost of developing a custom core remains beyond the reach of small companies.
Big companies already know there's an established ARM ecosystem with working compilers and a simple, risk-free, and relatively affordable business model.
So what business problem does RISC-V solve?
- Recurecur 10y ago"Linux is still a hobby OS. It's not a particularly wonderful example of software engineering. Its only real benefit is that it's free and comes with an ecosystem of other free software that kind of mostly works as long as you don't mind the occasional security horror, and can be used as-is or customised at relatively low cost." That is complete nonsense. Linux, particularly Red Hat Enterprise Linux is as serious of a server OS as exists in the world today. Companies like IBM and Oracle would never embrace a "hobby" OS in an enterprise setting. As for "occasional security horrors", sadly there is no OS of any flavor that is immune. "So what business problem does RISC-V solve?" For one thing, RISC-V offers the promise of fully open computer systems, without opaque black boxes anywhere providing potential back doors or other problems. The Intel AMT vulnerability is an excellent example of how that can go very wrong: https://www.ssh.com/vulnerability/intel-amt/ https://www.ssh.com/vulnerability/intel-amt/ RISC-V also provides a playground for smaller entities (like university labs) wishing to experiment with innovative new hardware techniques like Unums. That's very valuable in its own right. http://web.stanford.edu/class/ee380/Abstracts/170201-slides.pdf http://web.stanford.edu/class/ee380/Abstracts/170201-slides....