3 ms·
Are you sure about the orbit? Could a Red Dragon not land directly from a Hohmann transfer?
by dotancohen 10y ago
Are you sure about the orbit? Could a Red Dragon not land directly from a Hohmann transfer?
- kirrent 10y agoWikipedia seems to imply that the plan for Red Dragon is a direct atmospheric entry. It makes sense, they don't have a second stage that would last long enough to get there. They don't have the delta-V to get the second stage into a mars transfer with a huge amount of fuel and I doubt there's much utility in spending the 2.3km/s (or thereabouts) of delta-v in getting from the Mars transfer to a low Mars orbit when you can just use aerobraking instead. In fact, it would be highly abnormal for a probe to visit Mars orbit before landing.
- dotancohen 10y agoThere is no dichotomy in aerobraking vs orbit. In fact, I believe most interplanetary orbiters (Galileo, Cassini) used aerobraking to achieve orbit.
- zardo 10y agoThey didn't. Aerocapture has only ever been done on Earth.
- ethbro 10y agoNow I'm curious to run the numbers on how lenient the window is for (I'd assume it would have to be) single pass aerocapture on Mars. And especially interested on what the options for the problem scenarios look like (e.g. burning off too much or not enough velocity).
- kobeya 10y agoIt could land directly, yes, but it makes use of the aerobrake for slow-down. Without that aerobrake it would not have enough fuel to do a powered landing all the way down and then return to orbit (I think -- I don't actually work for SpaceX; I'm just a fan). But it is my understanding that it has enough fuel to do a full propulsive landing from orbit and back again, without an aerobrake.
- zardo 10y ago>But it is my understanding that it has enough fuel to do a full propulsive landing from orbit and back again, without an aerobrake. Not even close. Dragon has something like 450m/s of dv to use. Getting from the surface of Mars to orbit takes 3800. Orbital capture requires around 2000m/s. Without aerobraking, it couldn't enter Mars orbit, let alone land.
- kobeya 10y agoAre you looking at the CRS dragon specs? It is absolutely the case that future designs of Dragon are able to do a direct powered ascent from Mars. That requires a lot more that 450m/s. Current dragon can't do that, but I wasn't talking about current dragon.